What are you looking for?

        HomeNYBay ShoreRestaurantsMexican Restaurants

        Mexican Restaurants in Bay Shore, NY

        About Search Results
        Tacos Guacamole - Mexican Restaurants

        1. Tacos Guacamole

        Mexican RestaurantsLatin American RestaurantsSpanish Restaurants
        WebsiteView Menu
        20
        YEARS
        IN BUSINESS
        Amenities:
        Wheelchair accessible
        (631) 859-9662
        617 E Main St
        Bay Shore, NY 11706
        $
        CLOSED NOW
        QDOBA Mexican Eats - Mexican Restaurants

        2. QDOBA Mexican Eats

        Mexican RestaurantsFast Food RestaurantsRestaurants
        WebsiteView Menu
        28
        YEARS
        IN BUSINESS
        (631) 647-5080
        View all 7 Locations
        331 E Main St
        Bay Shore, NY 11706
        $
        CLOSED NOW

        From Business: At QDOBA Mexican Eats, we’re all about flavor. From our unique ingredients, freshly prepared in-house throughout the day, to our friendly, dedicated employees,…

        Verde Kitchen & Cocktails - Mexican Restaurants

        3. Verde Kitchen & Cocktails

        Mexican RestaurantsLatin American RestaurantsCaterers
        WebsiteView Menu
        10
        YEARS
        IN BUSINESS
        Amenities:
        Offers outdoor seatingHas WifiServes alcoholTakes reservations
        (631) 665-6300
        70 E Main St
        Bay Shore, NY 11706
        $$
        CLOSED NOW
        Pico Tequila Grill - Mexican Restaurants

        4. Pico Tequila Grill

        Mexican RestaurantsCaterersRestaurants
        WebsiteView Menu
        Amenities:
        Serves alcohol
        (631) 647-8907
        19 W Main St
        Bay Shore, NY 11706
        $$
        OPEN NOW
        Order Online
        Pecado Mexican - Mexican Restaurants

        5. Pecado Mexican

        Mexican RestaurantsBarsCocktail Lounges
        Website
        (631) 992-7717
        49 W Main St
        Bay Shore, NY 11706
        CLOSED NOW
        Pollo Campero - Latin American Restaurants

        6. Pollo Campero

        Mexican RestaurantsLatin American RestaurantsFast Food Restaurants
        (2)
        WebsiteView Menu
        18
        YEARS
        IN BUSINESS
        Amenities:
        Good for groups
        (833) 226-7376
        View all 4 Locations
        1665 5th Ave
        Bay Shore, NY 11706
        $
        CLOSED NOW

        The food in out of this world. Highly recommended to anyone who enjoys great service and excellent food. They also have locations in Freeport,…

        Order Online
        Chili's Grill & Bar - American Restaurants

        7. Chili's Grill & Bar

        Mexican RestaurantsAmerican RestaurantsBars
        Website
        33
        YEARS
        IN BUSINESS
        Amenities:
        Good for groupsServes alcoholGood for families
        (631) 665-2777
        View all 4 Locations
        2020 Sunrise Hwy
        Bay Shore, NY 11706
        $$
        OPEN NOW

        From Business: Family-friendly chain serving classic Tex-Mex & American fare in a Southwestern-style setting. Favorites include ribs, burger, fajitas and signature margaritas…

        Chipotle Mexican Grill - Fast Food Restaurants

        8. Chipotle Mexican Grill

        Mexican RestaurantsFast Food RestaurantsRestaurants
        Website
        Amenities:
        Serves alcohol
        (631) 666-0731
        View all 26 Locations
        1675 Sunrise Hwy
        Bay Shore, NY 11706
        $
        CLOSED NOW
        Cafe Rio - Fast Food Restaurants

        9. Cafe Rio

        Mexican RestaurantsFast Food RestaurantsRestaurants
        Website
        (631) 650-6940
        2042 Sunrise Hwy
        Bay Shore, NY 11706
        CLOSED NOW
        El Pollo Loco - Fast Food Restaurants

        10. El Pollo Loco

        Mexican RestaurantsFast Food RestaurantsRestaurants
        Website
        (858) 451-1884
        29 Bay Shore Rd
        Bay Shore, NY 11706
        Taco Bell - Fast Food Restaurants

        11. Taco Bell

        Mexican RestaurantsFast Food RestaurantsRestaurants
        WebsiteView Menu
        61
        YEARS
        IN BUSINESS
        (631) 665-7292
        View all 29 Locations
        1701 Sunrise Highway FC-6 South Shore Mall
        Bay Shore, NY 11706
        $
        CLOSED NOW
        Order Online
        El Apretador - Seafood Restaurants

        12. El Apretador

        Mexican RestaurantsSeafood RestaurantsLatin American Restaurants
        WebsiteView Menu
        29
        YEARS
        IN BUSINESS
        Amenities:
        Wheelchair accessibleServes alcoholTakes reservations
        (631) 666-9390
        1531 Brentwood Rd
        Bay Shore, NY 11706
        $$
        CLOSED NOW
        Order Online
        Green Cactus Mexican Grill - Mexican Restaurants

        13. Green Cactus Mexican Grill

        Mexican RestaurantsTake Out RestaurantsVegetarian Restaurants
        (1)
        WebsiteView Menu
        30
        YEARS
        IN BUSINESS
        (631) 242-2008
        1209 Deer Park Ave
        North Babylon, NY 11703
        $
        CLOSED NOW

        Green Cactus is an very good restuarnt whether you eat in or take out! Everything is fresh and very tasteful!

        Bubba's Burrito Bar - Mexican Restaurants

        14. Bubba's Burrito Bar

        Mexican RestaurantsTake Out RestaurantsCaterers
        Website
        15
        YEARS
        IN BUSINESS
        Amenities:
        Offers outdoor seatingWheelchair accessibleGood for groupsServes alcohol
        (631) 650-6333
        513 Main St
        Islip, NY 11751
        CLOSED NOW
        Swell Taco - Mexican Restaurants

        15. Swell Taco

        Mexican RestaurantsBarsBrew Pubs
        (1)
        WebsiteView Menu
        10
        YEARS
        IN BUSINESS
        Amenities:
        Offers outdoor seatingWheelchair accessibleServes alcohol
        (631) 482-1299
        135 Deer Park Ave
        Babylon, NY 11702
        $
        CLOSED NOW
        User Avatar

        My wife and I are big fans of Mexican, so we gave this little place a chance being nearby. The spicy steak Taco (a special that day) was the best…

        Panchita Grill - Mexican Restaurants

        16. Panchita Grill

        Mexican RestaurantsSpanish RestaurantsCaterers
        (2)
        View Menu
        Amenities:
        Wheelchair accessibleServes alcoholTakes reservations
        (631) 242-0355
        354 Commack Rd
        Deer Park, NY 11729
        $$
        CLOSED NOW
        User Avatar

        Excellent attention, great food, well located and good decoration

        Del Fuego - Mexican Restaurants

        17. Del Fuego

        Mexican RestaurantsCaterersBars
        (1)
        WebsiteView Menu
        10
        YEARS
        IN BUSINESS
        Amenities:
        Has WifiServes alcohol
        (631) 620-3700
        117 Deer Park Ave
        Babylon, NY 11702
        $$
        OPEN NOW
        User Avatar

        It was a great experience, the tacos were great and the service was also good! I would definitely go there in the future again.

        Bang Bang Burritos - Mexican Restaurants

        18. Bang Bang Burritos

        Mexican RestaurantsRestaurants
        WebsiteView Menu
        (631) 314-4900
        464 Union Blvd
        West Islip, NY 11795
        $$
        CLOSED NOW
        Order Online
        Texas Taco - Mexican Restaurants

        19. Texas Taco

        Mexican RestaurantsRestaurants
        Website
        (631) 392-1006
        297 Bay Shore Rd
        Deer Park, NY 11729
        $$
        CLOSED NOW
        Order Online
        Super Taco - Mexican Restaurants

        20. Super Taco

        Mexican RestaurantsRestaurants
        Website
        (631) 586-8226
        177 Bay Shore Rd
        Deer Park, NY 11729
        CLOSED NOW
        Flyingtortilla - Mexican Restaurants

        21. Flyingtortilla

        Mexican RestaurantsRestaurants
        (631) 524-5295
        743 Suffolk Ave
        Brentwood, NY 11717
        Viva Mexico Restaurant - Mexican Restaurants

        22. Viva Mexico Restaurant

        Mexican RestaurantsRestaurants
        (631) 232-1031
        19 Montgomery St
        Brentwood, NY 11717
        Mi Ranchito - Mexican Restaurants

        23. Mi Ranchito

        Mexican RestaurantsRestaurants
        (2)
        23
        YEARS
        IN BUSINESS
        (631) 273-5821
        739 Suffolk Ave
        Brentwood, NY 11717
        $$
        CLOSED NOW
        User Avatar

        Simply one of the best Colombian places to eat.

        Order Online
        Casa Vieja - Mexican Restaurants

        24. Casa Vieja

        Mexican RestaurantsTake Out RestaurantsCaterers
        WebsiteView Menu
        30
        YEARS
        IN BUSINESS
        Amenities:
        Good for groupsServes alcoholTakes reservations
        (631) 434-8255
        1768 Brentwood Rd
        Brentwood, NY 11717
        CLOSED NOW
        Super Taco - Mexican Restaurants

        25. Super Taco

        Mexican RestaurantsTake Out RestaurantsRestaurants
        (1)
        WebsiteView Menu
        10
        YEARS
        IN BUSINESS
        Amenities:
        Wheelchair accessibleServes alcohol
        (631) 434-1544
        47 Wicks Rd
        Brentwood, NY 11717
        $$
        OPEN NOW
        User Avatar

        I like the tortas mexican and tacos

        Salsa Pica Mexican Grill - Mexican Restaurants

        26. Salsa Pica Mexican Grill

        Mexican Restaurants
        11
        YEARS
        IN BUSINESS
        (631) 620-3123
        84 Rt 109
        W Babylon, NY 11704
        CLOSED NOW
        Island Grill - Mexican Restaurants

        27. Island Grill

        Mexican RestaurantsBar & GrillsRestaurants
        Website
        19
        YEARS
        IN BUSINESS
        (631) 321-0194
        926 Little East Neck Rd
        West Babylon, NY 11704
        CLOSED NOW
        Green Cactus of West Babylon - Mexican Restaurants

        28. Green Cactus of West Babylon

        Mexican RestaurantsRestaurants
        Website
        (631) 991-3288
        655 Route 109
        West Babylon, NY 11704
        Vicky' S Casa Del Sabor - Mexican Restaurants

        29. Vicky' S Casa Del Sabor

        Mexican RestaurantsDelicatessensPizza
        Website
        12
        YEARS
        IN BUSINESS
        Amenities:
        Wheelchair accessibleGood for groups
        (631) 225-5040
        771 Wellwood Ave
        Lindenhurst, NY 11757
        $
        CLOSED NOW
        California Cactus Cafe - Mexican Restaurants

        30. California Cactus Cafe

        Mexican RestaurantsCaterersRestaurants
        WebsiteView Menu
        26
        YEARS
        IN BUSINESS
        Amenities:
        Wheelchair accessible
        (631) 585-5640
        3320 Veterans Memorial Hwy Ste B
        Bohemia, NY 11716
        $
        CLOSED NOW
        About Search Results

        YP - The Real Yellow PagesSM - helps you find the right local businesses to meet your specific needs. Search results are sorted by a combination of factors to give you a set of choices in response to your search criteria. These factors are similar to those you might use to determine which business to select from a local Yellow Pages directory, including proximity to where you are searching, expertise in the specific services or products you need, and comprehensive business information to help evaluate a business's suitability for you. “Preferred” listings, or those with featured website buttons, indicate YP advertisers who directly provide information about their businesses to help consumers make more informed buying decisions. YP advertisers receive higher placement in the default ordering of search results and may appear in sponsored listings on the top, side, or bottom of the search results page.