Italian Restaurants in Bay Shore, NY

About Search Results
About Search Results

YP - The Real Yellow PagesSM - helps you find the right local businesses to meet your specific needs. Search results are sorted by a combination of factors to give you a set of choices in response to your search criteria. These factors are similar to those you might use to determine which business to select from a local Yellow Pages directory, including proximity to where you are searching, expertise in the specific services or products you need, and comprehensive business information to help evaluate a business's suitability for you. “Preferred” listings, or those with featured website buttons, indicate YP advertisers who directly provide information about their businesses to help consumers make more informed buying decisions. YP advertisers receive higher placement in the default ordering of search results and may appear in sponsored listings on the top, side, or bottom of the search results page.

Mulberry Street Bay Shore

1. Mulberry Street Bay Shore

(631) 665-2004

192 Howells Rd
Bay Shore, NY 11706

User Avatar

One of the best hidden gems of the South Shore. A nice little restaurant tucked in a little strip mall just off of Sunrise Hwy. The staff was very…

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

2. Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

(631) 665-5213

1715 Sunrise Hwy
Bay Shore, NY 11706

From Business: Since its founding in Orlando in 1982, Olive Garden has been dedicated to providing a warm, welcoming dining experience and Italian hospitality to everyone who…

I.T.A Kitchen

3. I.T.A Kitchen

(631) 267-5916

45 W Main St
Bay Shore, NY 11706

Fratelli Pizzeria

5. Fratelli Pizzeria

(631) 666-0458

553 E Main St
Bay Shore, NY 11706


Very good pizza. Food is great and so are the owners. Although the place is small the food is still very well made.


6. Giordano's

(631) 647-8107

45 W Main St
Bay Shore, NY 11706

Pie At Salvatore's

7. Pie At Salvatore's

(631) 206-1060

120 E Main St
Bay Shore, NY 11706

First, let me say that I have made several trips to this place through the last few years I've lived in the area. When I first started going, I…


8. Valentino's

(631) 666-5172

1597 Manatuck Blvd Ste A
Bay Shore, NY 11706

El ceviche Buenazo.....y el pollito a la brasa..Omg...puta k caga#@!!!@ ven te vas a…

Joe's Pasta & Pizza

10. Joe's Pasta & Pizza

(631) 665-2524

73 Howells Rd
Bay Shore, NY 11706

User Avatar

I thought their pizza was excellent. They always have customers. The restuarant is very clean. I Found the service fast and efficient.

Gino's Pizza

11. Gino's Pizza

(631) 665-6350

45 W Main St
Bay Shore, NY 11706

This is the best pizza in the surrounding area. I don't go as often as I would like because I can never find parking on main st - but if the…

Slice of Bay Shore

13. Slice of Bay Shore

(631) 647-9016

298 W Main St
Bay Shore, NY 11706

From Business: Slice of Bay Shore offers a variety of Italian comfort food utilizing the freshest ingredients. We can accommodate large groups for family celebrations in our…

Nicky's Clam Bar

14. Nicky's Clam Bar

(631) 665-6621

99 Maple Ave
Bay Shore, NY 11706

Albert's Pizza

15. Albert's Pizza

(631) 650-6939

2042 Sunrise Hwy
Bay Shore, NY 11706

Danny's Pizza & Deli

16. Danny's Pizza & Deli

(631) 968-6810

1585 5th Ave
Bay Shore, NY 11706


17. Sbarro

(631) 807-0968

1701 Sunrise Hwy
Bay Shore, NY 11706

From Business: Sbarro is the home of The Original NY Style pizza featuring our XL NY Slice. We make our dough fresh and shred 100% whole mile mozzarella cheese in store each…

Amore Pizzeria And Fine Foods

19. Amore Pizzeria And Fine Foods

(631) 968-8181

2110 Union Blvd
Bay Shore, NY 11706

We live near the pizzeria the staff is great , very nice. the food is great .... when im tired and don't want to cook there fast to diliver .oh and…

Francesco's Trattoria

20. Francesco's Trattoria

(631) 277-3704

234 E Main St
East Islip, NY 11730

Villa Monaco Restaurant

21. Villa Monaco Restaurant

(631) 661-5599

778 Montauk Hwy
West Islip, NY 11795

Love This place. Great service, fun people, and even better food. we also had our rehearsal diner here, upstairs in the Loft room! Thanks Nick and…


22. Verace

(631) 277-3800

599 Main St
Islip, NY 11751

User Avatar

Best authentic food in Islip. Every week on Wed is a great deal. Culinary delights paired with wine $40 pp. theeee best

Ristorante Gemelli

23. Ristorante Gemelli

(631) 321-6392

175 E Main St
Babylon, NY 11702

I really don't mind paying a little more to get exceptional food... .and they're really not all TOO expensive considering the quality and service…

Gemelli Fine Foods

24. Gemelli Fine Foods

(631) 321-4515

115 E Main St
Babylon, NY 11702


I stop in at least once a week.... sometimes more. We do pasta sundays so every sunday we go in there to pick up the pasta, and tomatoes and…

Our Little Italy

25. Our Little Italy

(631) 661-6246

636 Union Blvd
West Islip, NY 11795

As Pork Store & Fine Foods

26. As Pork Store & Fine Foods

(631) 581-6229

87 E Main St
East Islip, NY 11730

From Business: A S Italian Fine Foods provides gourmet, high-end meats, cheeses, and main dishes to the East Islip, NY area.

Gio S Pizzaria

28. Gio S Pizzaria

(631) 581-0886

213 Carleton Ave
East Islip, NY 11730

Oak Neck Pizzeria & Catering

29. Oak Neck Pizzeria & Catering

(631) 669-4400

945 Montauk Hwy
West Islip, NY 11795

Sunset P Laza Italian

30. Sunset P Laza Italian

(631) 392-1620

1142 Deer Park Ave
North Babylon, NY 11703

We found 645 results for Italian Restaurants in or near Bay Shore, NY.

They also appear in other related business categories including Restaurants, Pizza, and Caterers.

The businesses listed also serve surrounding cities and neighborhoods including Huntington NY, Massapequa NY, and Farmingdale NY. These businesses offer their services in one-or-more of the following languages: Italian, and Spanish.

magnifying glass

Didn't find what you were looking for?
Please help others by helping us do better.

Suggest a Business