Italian Restaurants in Bay Shore, NY

View all businesses that are OPEN 24 Hours
Mulberry Street - Italian Restaurants

1. Mulberry Street

47
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Has WifiServes alcoholTakes reservations
(631) 665-2004
192 Howells Rd
Bay Shore, NY 11706
$$
OPEN NOW

One of the best hidden gems of the South Shore. A nice little restaurant tucked in a little strip mall just off of Sunrise Hwy. The staff was very…

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant - Italian Restaurants
(631) 665-5213
1715 Sunrise Hwy
Bay Shore, NY 11706
$$
OPEN NOW

From Business: Since its founding in Orlando in 1982, Olive Garden has been dedicated to providing a warm, welcoming dining experience and Italian hospitality to everyone who…

Butera - Italian Restaurants
(631) 328-4948
8 3rd Ave
Bay Shore, NY 11706
CLOSED NOW
I.T.A Kitchen - Italian Restaurants
(631) 267-5916
45 W Main St
Bay Shore, NY 11706
CLOSED NOW
Tinas II Italian Rstrnt & Pzzr - Italian Restaurants
(631) 665-1010
635 E Main St
Bay Shore, NY 11706
$$$$
OPEN NOW
Fratelli Pizzeria - Italian Restaurants

6. Fratelli Pizzeria

46
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Serves alcohol
(631) 666-0458
553 E Main St
Bay Shore, NY 11706
$$
OPEN NOW

Very good pizza. Food is great and so are the owners. Although the place is small the food is still very well made.

Giordano's - Pizza
(631) 647-8107
45 W Main St
Bay Shore, NY 11706
The Pie at Salvatore's - Pizza

8. The Pie at Salvatore's

17
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Offers outdoor seatingGood for groupsServes alcoholTakes reservationsGood for families
(631) 206-1060
120 E Main St
Bay Shore, NY 11706
$$
OPEN NOW
Buseto - Pizza

9. Buseto

Amenities:
Wheelchair accessibleGood for groupsServes alcoholTakes reservations
(631) 665-4939
1851 Sunrise Hwy
Bay Shore, NY 11706
$
OPEN NOW
Joe's Pasta & Pizza - Pizza

10. Joe's Pasta & Pizza

50
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Wheelchair accessibleServes alcohol
(631) 665-2524
73 Howells Rd
Bay Shore, NY 11706
$$
OPEN NOW

I thought their pizza was excellent. They always have customers. The restuarant is very clean. I Found the service fast and efficient.

Frank and Marias - Delicatessens

11. Frank and Marias

Amenities:
Offers outdoor seatingWheelchair accessibleHas Wifi
(631) 665-0047
10 W Main St
Bay Shore, NY 11706
$$
CLOSED NOW
La Casa Pizza - Pizza
(631) 665-1010
635 E Main St
Bay Shore, NY 11706
OPEN NOW

From Business: Order your favorite pizza, pasta, salad, wings and more with La Casa located at 635 E Main St in Bay Shore, NY. La Casa is accepting orders online for delivery…

Sbarro - Fast Food Restaurants
(631) 807-0968
1701 Sunrise Highway Fc#8
Bay Shore, NY 11706
OPEN NOW

From Business: Sbarro is the home of The Original NY Style pizza featuring our XL NY Slice. We make our dough fresh and shred 100% whole milk mozzarella cheese in store each…

Gino's Pizza - Pizza
(631) 665-6350
45 W Main St
Bay Shore, NY 11706
$$
OPEN NOW
Nicky's Clam Bar - Seafood Restaurants

15. Nicky's Clam Bar

33
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Wheelchair accessibleServes alcohol
(631) 665-6621
99 Maple Ave
Bay Shore, NY 11706
OPEN NOW
Francesco's Trattoria - Italian Restaurants

17. Francesco's Trattoria

19
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Good for groupsServes alcohol
(631) 277-3704
234 E Main St
East Islip, NY 11730
$$
CLOSED NOW
Villa Monaco Restaurant - Italian Restaurants

18. Villa Monaco Restaurant

39
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Wheelchair accessibleGood for groupsHas WifiServes alcoholTakes reservations
(631) 661-5599
778 Montauk Hwy
West Islip, NY 11795
$$$
OPEN NOW

Love This place. Great service, fun people, and even better food. we also had our rehearsal diner here, upstairs in the Loft room! Thanks Nick and…

Mulberry Street - Italian Restaurants

19. Mulberry Street

35
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Wheelchair accessibleHas WifiServes alcoholTakes reservations
(631) 321-5980
30 E Main St
Babylon, NY 11702
$$
OPEN NOW

A few years ago I used to visit this place often for their salad pizza. One day I happened to notice something foreign on the slice. I showed the…

Verace - Italian Restaurants

20. Verace

14
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Offers outdoor seatingWheelchair accessibleServes alcoholTakes reservations
(631) 277-3800
599 Main St
Islip, NY 11751
$$$
OPEN NOW

Best authentic food in Islip. Every week on Wed is a great deal. Culinary delights paired with wine $40 pp. theeee best

Ristorante Gemelli - Italian Restaurants

21. Ristorante Gemelli

26
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Wheelchair accessibleGood for groupsHas WifiServes alcoholTakes reservations
(631) 321-6392
175 E Main St
Babylon, NY 11702
$$$
CLOSED NOW

From Business: In response to a society that is moving ever so fast, when there is less personal communication between people, dining has become fast and casual, and everything…

Martino Pizza - Italian Restaurants

22. Martino Pizza

75
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Wheelchair accessible
(631) 277-6141
22 E Main St
East Islip, NY 11730
$$
OPEN NOW

Excellent prices and delicious food, isn't that what you expect from a pizza place? Do yourself a favor and try the zeppolies and garlic cheesy…

Gemelli Fine Foods - Italian Restaurants
(631) 321-4515
115 E Main St
Babylon, NY 11702
$
OPEN NOW

I stop in at least once a week.... sometimes more. We do pasta sundays so every sunday we go in there to pick up the pasta, and tomatoes and…

The Pizzeria - Islip - Italian Restaurants
(631) 581-9500
591 Main St
Islip, NY 11751
$$
OPEN NOW

From Business: The Pizzeria provides online ordering and delivery, catering, pizzeria to Islip, NY area.

Vinnie's Mulberry Street - Italian Restaurants

25. Vinnie's Mulberry Street

BBB Rating: A+
Amenities:
Serves alcoholTakes reservations
(631) 277-9500
42 E Main St
East Islip, NY 11730
$$
OPEN NOW

From Business: At Vinnie's Mulberry Street, we take pride in our quality food, professional service and great ambience. Our experienced staff is on-hand to ensure that your…

A S Italian Fine Foods - Italian Restaurants
(631) 581-6229
87 E Main St
East Islip, NY 11730
$$
OPEN NOW

From Business: A S Italian Fine Foods provides gourmet, high-end meats, cheeses, and main dishes to the East Islip, NY area.A S Italian Fine Foods provides gourmet, high-end…

Mamma santina Pizzeria inc - Italian Restaurants

27. Mamma santina Pizzeria inc

36
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Wheelchair accessibleGood for groupsHas WifiServes alcoholTakes reservations
(917) 207-7709
201 Orinoco Dr Fl 1
Brightwaters, NY 11718
$$
OPEN NOW
Our Little Italy - Italian Restaurants

28. Our Little Italy

40
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Wheelchair accessibleGood for groupsServes alcohol
(631) 661-6246
636 Union Blvd
West Islip, NY 11795
$$
OPEN NOW
Oak Neck Pizzeria & Catering - Italian Restaurants
(631) 669-4400
945 Montauk Hwy
West Islip, NY 11795
$
OPEN NOW
Primi Italian Steakhouse - Italian Restaurants

30. Primi Italian Steakhouse

Amenities:
Offers outdoor seatingHas WifiServes alcoholTakes reservations
(631) 526-9779
999 Montauk Hwy
West Islip, NY 11795
$$$
CLOSED NOW
About Search Results

YP - The Real Yellow PagesSM - helps you find the right local businesses to meet your specific needs. Search results are sorted by a combination of factors to give you a set of choices in response to your search criteria. These factors are similar to those you might use to determine which business to select from a local Yellow Pages directory, including proximity to where you are searching, expertise in the specific services or products you need, and comprehensive business information to help evaluate a business's suitability for you. “Preferred” listings, or those with featured website buttons, indicate YP advertisers who directly provide information about their businesses to help consumers make more informed buying decisions. YP advertisers receive higher placement in the default ordering of search results and may appear in sponsored listings on the top, side, or bottom of the search results page.