Italian Restaurants in Montauk, NY

View all businesses that are OPEN 24 Hours
Pointe Di Vista Ristorante - Italian Restaurants
(800) 773-5099
Fairview Ave
Montauk, NY 11954
Blade + Salt - Italian Restaurants
(631) 668-1601
54 S Erie Ave
Montauk, NY 11954
$$$
CLOSED NOW

From Business: Serving up pizza and good food. Coming to Montauk Village Spring 2021!Serving up pizza and good food. Coming to Montauk Village Spring 2021!

Kenny's Castaways - Italian Restaurants
(631) 668-5555
432 West lake Drive
Montauk, NY 11954
OPEN NOW

From Business: Italian Restaurant

Harvest on Fort Pond - Seafood Restaurants

4. Harvest on Fort Pond

28
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Offers outdoor seatingWheelchair accessibleServes alcoholTakes reservations
(631) 668-5574
11 S Emery St
Montauk, NY 11954
$$$
CLOSED NOW

Consistently great food. The portions are large, and many meals are served family style. Reservations are a must. Beautiful view. I cant say enough…

Kenny's Castaways - Seafood Restaurants
(631) 668-5555
432 W Lake Dr. Ground Floor
Montauk, NY 11954
$$$$
CLOSED NOW

From Business: Italian RestaurantItalian Restaurant

Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa - American Restaurants
(631) 668-2345
290 Old Montauk Hwy
Montauk, NY 11954
$$$
OPEN 24 Hours

From Business: Situated on Montauk's most pristine stretch of oceanfront real estate, Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa is a Hamptons icon and the only four-season resort…

Sausages Pizza & Pastabilities - Pizza

7. Sausages Pizza & Pastabilities

19
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Offers outdoor seating
(631) 668-1144
781 Montauk Hwy
Montauk, NY 11954
$
CLOSED NOW
Roberta's Pizza - Pizza
(631) 238-5430
240 Fort Pond Rd
Montauk, NY 11954
CLOSED NOW
Bella Nonna - Italian Restaurants
(631) 864-2600
149 Veterans Memorial Hwy
Commack, NY 11725

Since moving to the area 1 year ago, we've tried every pizzeria & this one is the best by far!The prices are much more reasonable as well.Way…

Cittanuova - Italian Restaurants

10. Cittanuova

18
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Offers outdoor seatingWheelchair accessibleGood for groupsServes alcohol
(631) 324-6300
29 Newtown Ln
East Hampton, NY 11937
$$
OPEN 24 Hours

Cittanuova in the heart of east hampton village, a great restaurant/bar to people watch while dining with a short list of excellent food a…

Sam's Restaurant - Italian Restaurants

11. Sam's Restaurant

75
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Wheelchair accessibleGood for groupsServes alcohol
(631) 324-5900
36 Newtown Ln
East Hampton, NY 11937
$$
CLOSED NOW

Sam's is the real deal. No pretense. Real food for real people. The service is warm and friendly, and the restaurant has a home-like feel with…

Il Buco al Mare - Italian Restaurants
(631) 557-3100
231 Main St
Amagansett, NY 11930
CLOSED NOW

From Business: Il Buco al Mare offers a simple, relaxed menu presenting the best of The Hampton's local seafood & produce. The restaurant offers the telltale il Buco ingredient…

Felice's Italian Restaurant - Italian Restaurants

13. Felice's Italian Restaurant

39
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Wheelchair accessibleServes alcoholTakes reservations
(631) 267-3339
237 Main St
Amagansett, NY 11930
$$
CLOSED NOW
Pepperoni's II Inc - Italian Restaurants

14. Pepperoni's II Inc

32
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Offers outdoor seatingWheelchair accessibleGood for groupsHas WifiServes alcohol
(631) 329-1800
281 Springs Fireplace Rd
East Hampton, NY 11937
$
OPEN NOW
Paola's East - Italian Restaurants
(631) 359-3100
341 Pantigo Rd
East Hampton, NY 11937
CLOSED NOW
Dopo La Spiaggia - Italian Restaurants
(631) 658-9063
31 Race Ln
East Hampton, NY 11937
$$$$
CLOSED NOW
Villa Italian Specialties - Italian Restaurants

17. Villa Italian Specialties

43
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Good for groups
(631) 324-5110
7 Railroad Ave
East Hampton, NY 11937
$$
CLOSED NOW

Let me start by saying I am full Blood Italian, and my parents were born in Italy. I have spent my whole life enjoying the best italian food... so…

L I Pasta Co - Italian Restaurants
(800) 591-2204
48 Sag Harbor Tpke
East Hampton, NY 11937
La Famiglia - Italian Restaurants

19. La Famiglia

20
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Serves alcoholTakes reservations
(631) 382-9454

Serving the
Montauk Area

$$$
CLOSED NOW

From Business: La Famiglia is a family style restaurant. All portions serve 2 to 3 people, however 1/2 portions are also available. Call in orders is ready in 15-20 minutes.…

La Famiglia - Italian Restaurants

20. La Famiglia

11
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Good for groupsServes alcoholTakes reservations
(631) 661-0101

Serving the
Montauk Area

$$
CLOSED NOW
User Avatar

I really like this place! Great Italian food and the service was amazing. I definitely will be going a lot more in the future.

Branchinelli's Pizza & Restaurant - Italian Restaurants

21. Branchinelli's Pizza & Restaurant

34
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
5
YEARS
WITH
Amenities:
Wheelchair accessibleServes alcohol
(631) 724-6663

Serving the
Montauk Area

$$
CLOSED NOW
User Avatar

This place is amazing! The family owns Branchinelli’s, Coloseo‘s and Mario’s in East Setauket. Chicken cutlet and eggplant Parmesan are my two…

Colosseo - Italian Restaurants

22. Colosseo

46
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
5
YEARS
WITH
Amenities:
Wheelchair accessibleServes alcohol
(631) 928-4972

Serving the
Montauk Area

$
CLOSED NOW
User Avatar

Excellent pizza the best in the area for quite some time. I go out of my way for it and the excellent service

Popei's Clam Bar - Seafood Restaurants

23. Popei's Clam Bar

27
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Wheelchair accessibleServes alcoholTakes reservations
(631) 254-3561

Serving the
Montauk Area

$$
CLOSED NOW
User Avatar

If youre looking for a fancy place to eat, this isnt the place! If you're looking for a great seafood meal that is absolutely fantastic and a…

Best Pizza & Dive Bar - Pizza
(631) 668-8378
2095 Montauk Hwy
Amagansett, NY 11930
CLOSED NOW

From Business: Best Pizza & Dive Bar is a large format, casual bar and pizzeria with indoor and outdoor seating, a great nightlife scene, a pool table, and laid back vibe. Best…

Nick & Toni's - American Restaurants

25. Nick & Toni's

33
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Offers outdoor seatingWheelchair accessibleGood for groupsHas WifiServes alcoholTakes reservations
(631) 324-3550
136 N Main St
East Hampton, NY 11937
$$
CLOSED NOW
AA

Food is good, service is outstanding, bar tender is great provides a nice atmosphere for patrons eating alone. Really lively place and nice wood…

Luigi's Italian Specialties - Delicatessens

26. Luigi's Italian Specialties

26
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Offers outdoor seatingGood for groups
(631) 329-0558
199 Pantigo Rd
East Hampton, NY 11937
$$
CLOSED NOW
Fierro's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Pizza
(631) 324-5751
104 Park Pl
East Hampton, NY 11937
$
CLOSED NOW

i live on pizza i could probably set a guiness world book record for how many slices i have consumed in my life and travels i suffer…

Fresno - American Restaurants

28. Fresno

18
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Offers outdoor seatingGood for groupsServes alcoholTakes reservations
(631) 324-8700
8 Fresno Pl
East Hampton, NY 11937
$$
CLOSED NOW

This is one of the restaurants by the team that gave us the Red Bar in Southampton which was an instant hit and still is.I love going with my…

The Palm - East Hampton - Steak Houses

29. The Palm - East Hampton

96
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Wheelchair accessibleGood for groupsServes alcoholTakes reservations
(631) 324-0411
94 Main St Ste 1800
East Hampton, NY 11937
$$$$
CLOSED NOW

We have been customers for years at this quaint restaurant that sits on the Main Street but you wouldn't know it because the landscaping outside…

Astro's Pizza - Pizza

30. Astro's Pizza

51
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
Amenities:
Offers outdoor seatingServes alcohol
(631) 267-8300
237 Main St
Amagansett, NY 11930
$$
CLOSED NOW

From Business: Our pizza place has been family owned and operated for over 40 years with our variety of delicious pizzas and Italian Cuisine. Our restaurant serves an array of…

About Search Results

YP - The Real Yellow PagesSM - helps you find the right local businesses to meet your specific needs. Search results are sorted by a combination of factors to give you a set of choices in response to your search criteria. These factors are similar to those you might use to determine which business to select from a local Yellow Pages directory, including proximity to where you are searching, expertise in the specific services or products you need, and comprehensive business information to help evaluate a business's suitability for you. “Preferred” listings, or those with featured website buttons, indicate YP advertisers who directly provide information about their businesses to help consumers make more informed buying decisions. YP advertisers receive higher placement in the default ordering of search results and may appear in sponsored listings on the top, side, or bottom of the search results page.