Find a business

        Saved to Favorites

        (305) 294-5369Call
        Add Website
        Map & DirectionsDirections5510 3rd AveKey West, FL 33040Write a ReviewWrite Review

        Menu

        Appetizers
        • Conch Fritters
          best fritters in town and lots of conch
          $5.25
        • Smoked Fish Dip
          fresh caught fish, smoke, and blended into a creamy dip
          $5.75
        • Calamari Rings
          hand breaded tender rings
          $6.95
        Salads
        • The Fishermen's Lite
          fresh mahi mahi from the florida keys, served on a bed of crisp lettuces topped with pepporicinis onions and tomatoes
          $19.95
        • Garden Salad
          $3.95
        Dinner
        • Yellowtail Snapper
          $18.95
        • Grouper
          $22.95
        • Mahi Mahi
          $16.95
        View Full Menu
        Provided by
        Partner Logo

        Reviews

        Hi there!
        Rate this business!
        What do you rate this business?First-classBetter than mostAbout what I expectedNot the worst...Disappointing
        Click to Rate
        marybevis

        11/15/2010

        Overall
        Best on the Island

        Ramona always has the freshes catch. Dont miss this restraunt if your a visitor.

        Helpful(0)Flag
        1seafood

        08/08/2010

        Overall
        If you don't buy your seafood ...

        If you don't buy your seafood at the rusty anchor your missing the boat.

        Helpful(0)Flag
        kathylevin

        11/16/2009

        Overall
        Got to go there!

        You will love the fresh seafood, the owner Ramone, his lovely daughter and staff, and better yet the seafood, surpasses any Key West restaurant for 1/2 the cost. What a find! Top off the evening at the HogFish Restaurant nearby for music and drinks and for a taste of "Old Key West", take a look at the adjacent "Safe Harbor Marina", We love you Ramone!! Kathy and Keith

        Helpful(0)Flag
        emcoilco1

        10/09/2008

        Overall
        FRESH FROM THE BOAT

        LOVE IT, ,LOCALS SECRET, THE FRESHEST FISH, ANYWAY YOU LIKE IT. GOOD SIDES AND GREAT BLOODY MARY'S. EVERYTIME I GO TO KEY WEST, I EAT THERE. CLOSED ON SUNDAYS.

        Helpful(0)Flag
        jfpk0004

        08/20/2008

        Overall
        Don't Miss for Fresh Fish!

        If you like to go where th locals go for fresh seafood, this is the place. It's a little hard to find but it is worth it. The yellowtail snapper just came in that day and is wonderful. Atmosphere is nothing to write home about, but that isn't why they come. If you have an extra minute go out back and check out the packing and shipping area. We had a kitchen in our lodging and purchase some snapper to go.

        Helpful(0)Flag

        Details

        Phone: (305) 294-5369

        Address: 5510 3rd Ave, Key West, FL 33040

        More Info

        General Info
        The Rusty Anchor Seafood Restaurant is one of Key West s best kept secrets. Just 1 mile north of Key West, nestled in a quiet neighborhood off US 1 on Stock Island, it has been owned and operated by a local family since 1983. It offers the freshest local seafood that comes straight from the commercial fishing fleet to its fish market and restaurant. The Rusty Anchor has been a local and tourist favorite for years, featuring unbelievable conch fritters, fresh shrimp, and a selection of local fish that is prepared to the customer s liking. Prices and portions are always agreeable to the customer looking for great seafood at an affordable price. The Rusty Anchor is open for lunch and dinner and offers a full bar with a wide selection of tropical drinks, including Patty s famous rum punch. The Rusty Anchor accommodates many small and large parties in its main dining room and has a beautiful adjoining room with an outdoor garden for private parties. Come join Ramon and Patty Rodriquez and family for an unforgettable dining experience and share the local s best kept secret since 1983.
        Extra Phones

        Phone: (305) 296-2893

        Payment method
        master card, all major credit cards
        Price Range
        $$
        AKA

        Rusty Anchor Fisheries

        The Rusty Anchor Restaurant

        Rusty Anchor Seafoods of Key West, Inc

        Rusty Anchor Restaurant & Fisheries

        Rusty Anchor Seafood of Key West

        Categories
        Seafood Restaurants, Caterers, Family Style Restaurants, Fish & Seafood Markets, Fish & Seafood-Wholesale, Restaurants
        Other Information

        Cuisines: Caterers, Family Style, Seafood

        Parking: On Site

        Price Range : Average

        People Also Viewed