Atlantic Pizzeria & Resta

Delicious, great value and the space was surprisingly really nice for a pizza place.

A Great atmosphere envelopes you as you walk through the door.The best Pizzeria in the Baldwin/ Freeport area.. Gorgeous aroma and fantastic blues music combined with gorgeous murals and divine food. I loved it!

I was driving home from work today and I stopped by here for a quick bite to each. I tried my personal favourite chicken parm and it was def worth the visit. The sauce was tasty and the chicken was tender. I would come back again soon.

I placed an order over the phone for my companies lunch. I went in to pick it up- they had everything ready, very organized and nice people to deal with. Came back to the office and everyone was raving about how good the food was. A+ food.

Best Tasting Pizza I have found on Long Island.. I eat dinner here more than I eat dinner in my own house. I love it, they treat you like family once you walk in the door. & once you sit down, their famous Blues music keeps you occupied so you never want to leave. It is just a very cozy place, with Five Star homemade Italian cooking

Yummy Yum Yum....... Goody Good Food....... Tonight I had the eggplant parmesan, and let me tell you it was second to none, I don't think I could have done a better job myself. I also ordered a large Greek salad, and let me tell you, they put plenty of feta cheese , olives, and loads of other vegetables into that salad. It's just not some lettuce and a couple of carrots scrapings that a rabbit would turn his nose up to, like you getting so many other restaurants. The decor of the restaurant is simple, but effective and the staff all more than friendly and very helpful. When I want Italian , this is the only restaurant I would go to.

This could be one of the best slice of pizza I ever had.. what place a truly Italian Pizzeria. I haven't seen this type of pizza joint since my old days in Brooklyn. I never write anything about people or places but I was soo impress with this place, I had to. Atlantic Pizzeria I thank you, for taking me back to the good old days. Anyone who hasn't tried this place... they should. Their pizza is to kill for their crust is amazing.

i'm new to long island, I lived in brooklyn all my life. now living in baldwin, i realized that it will be harder than i expected to find a pizzeria that is as good as back in brooklyn.. i tried two different places in baldwin and it was just pizza, nothing special...nothing like home.. I found that Freeport has more pizzerias than baldwin so i was sure i would find a good one. after trying three pizzerias in this town, i began to lose hope. while i was in Seven11 complaining about pizza, someone said i should try Atlantic Pizzeria which was pretty much right across the street. so i said what the hell, cant be worse than the cardboard slices ive tried so far on this island and walked over....Let Me Tell You, it was an experience. Probably my BEST long island experience so far, aside from being allowed to make a right at a red light. before i even got in I noticed the blues music playing outside, unusual i thought, but unique. when i got inside, the countergirl laughed as my

Could be the best Pizzeria on Long Island, if not NY. I am a pizza lover. I LOVE pizza. I've been in over 200 pizzerias in my time, but I got to tell you..This pizzeria is It. Atlantic Pizzeria has it all. Their crust is to kill for. I highly recommend trying their layered eggplant pizza and their buffalo pizza, they are two of my personal favorites

Great Service, Great food Really enjoyed this place - attentive staff - good location, food tasty and well presented - reasonable prices - would return .