Find a business

        HomeNYShelter IslandBakeries

        Cupcakes in Shelter Island, NY

        View all businesses that are OPEN 24 Hours
        Shelter Island House - Hotels

        1. Shelter Island House

        HotelsBed & Breakfast & InnsCoffee Shops
        Website
        Years in Business Icon
        9 Years
        in Business
        Amenities:
        Offers outdoor seatingWheelchair accessibleHas WifiServes alcoholTakes reservations
        (631) 749-1633
        11 Stearns Point Rd
        Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
        OPEN NOW

        From Business: Drawing inspiration from its original roots in the 1800s, Shelter Island House has been reinvented with luxurious modern beach flair and opulent accommodations.…

        Butta Cakes - Bakeries

        2. Butta Cakes

        Bakeries
        Years in Business Icon
        12 Years
        in Business
        Amenities:
        Wheelchair accessible
        (631) 477-6666
        119 Main St Unit B
        Greenport, NY 11944
        OPEN NOW
        Aldo's Cafe - Bakeries

        4. Aldo's Cafe

        BakeriesRestaurants
        Website
        Amenities:
        Offers outdoor seatingWheelchair accessible
        (631) 477-6300
        103 Front St
        Greenport, NY 11944
        $
        Amazing Flavors - Ice Cream & Frozen Desserts

        5. Amazing Flavors

        Ice Cream & Frozen DessertsTake Out RestaurantsBakeries
        Website
        (631) 477-5042
        216 Front St
        Greenport, NY 11944
        OPEN NOW
        CAKE HAMPTON - Children's Party Planning & Entertainment

        6. CAKE HAMPTON

        Children's Party Planning & EntertainmentBakeriesCaterers
        (516) 233-0251
        Sag Harbor, NY 11963

        From Business: At .c.a.k.e. we take pride in creating the perfect cake or confection for any event. Our cakes are designed to inspire lasting impressions and delicious…

        Sag Harbor Baking Co - Bakeries

        7. Sag Harbor Baking Co

        Bakeries
        Years in Business Icon
        13 Years
        in Business
        Amenities:
        Wheelchair accessible
        (631) 899-4900
        51 Division St
        Sag Harbor, NY 11963
        CLOSED NOW
        Blue Duck Bakery - Ice Cream & Frozen Desserts

        8. Blue Duck Bakery

        Ice Cream & Frozen DessertsBakeriesDessert Restaurants
        (1)
        WebsiteView Menu
        (631) 629-4123
        56275 Route 25
        Southold, NY 11971
        $$
        OPEN NOW

        I love the chocolate chip cookies and the service is great. Right next to the carousel. Check it out!"

        Dunkin' - Donut Shops

        9. Dunkin'

        Donut ShopsBakeriesRestaurants
        (1)
        Website
        Years in Business Icon
        11 Years
        in Business
        (631) 876-5133
        View all 9 Locations
        53345 Route 25 # 1
        Southold, NY 11971
        OPEN NOW

        These donuts are out of this world."

        Butter, Cream & Berries - Butter

        10. Butter, Cream & Berries

        ButterKnobsBakeries
        (1)
        Years in Business Icon
        14 Years
        in Business

        Serving the
        Shelter Island Area

        OPEN NOW

        Stopped in this early afternoon, Very Pleasant and helpful the donuts and frosting were very good belive the donuts were cake donuts! I Highly recommend #Good Selection #Good…

        South Fork Bakery - Bakeries

        11. South Fork Bakery

        Bakeries
        Website
        (631) 725-7166
        3333 Noyac Rd
        Sag Harbor, NY 11963
        OPEN NOW
        Christophers Hampton Bakery - Bakeries

        12. Christophers Hampton Bakery

        Bakeries
        (631) 283-1323
        58 Mariner DR
        Southampton, NY 11968
        Tesauro Bakery Inc - Bakeries

        13. Tesauro Bakery Inc

        Bakeries
        (631) 661-1717
        West Babylon, NY 11704
        Rainbow Rounds - Caterers

        14. Rainbow Rounds

        CaterersBakeries
        (631) 889-4700
        Ronkonkoma, NY 11779
        Bakingmyheartout.Com - Bakeries

        15. Bakingmyheartout.Com

        Bakeries
        Website
        (631) 896-3754
        Huntington, NY 11743
        Bedrock Bakers - Bakeries

        16. Bedrock Bakers

        Bakeries
        Website
        (516) 532-2640
        Amityville, NY 11701
        Sweet Treats Bakeshop - Bakeries

        17. Sweet Treats Bakeshop

        BakeriesTake Out RestaurantsRestaurants
        Website
        (631) 682-2892
        Port Jefferson, NY 11777
        OPEN NOW
        Blondie Cakes - Bakeries

        18. Blondie Cakes

        Bakeries
        Website
        (631) 838-8919
        Coram, NY 11727
        Bella Grey Baked Goods - Bakeries

        19. Bella Grey Baked Goods

        Bakeries
        Website
        (877) 784-6139

        Serving the
        Shelter Island Area

        JB Treats - Bakeries

        20. JB Treats

        Bakeries
        (855) 748-5966

        Serving the
        Shelter Island Area

        Kona Ice of Long Island, Hamptons, Town of Islip - Bakeries

        21. Kona Ice of Long Island, Hamptons, Town of Islip

        Bakeries
        (516) 404-5050

        Serving the
        Shelter Island Area

        OPEN NOW
        DonutNV - Donut Shops

        22. DonutNV

        Donut ShopsBakeries
        Website
        (631) 519-9998

        Serving the
        Shelter Island Area

        Hocus Pocus Sweets & Treats - Bakeries

        23. Hocus Pocus Sweets & Treats

        BakeriesCandy & Confectionery
        (631) 627-8153

        Serving the
        Shelter Island Area

        The Bread Man - Bakeries

        24. The Bread Man

        Bakeries
        (631) 412-3233
        376 Neptune Ave
        West Babylon, NY 11704
        Gerry Annes - Bakeries

        25. Gerry Annes

        Bakeries
        (631) 765-3645
        1945 Calves Neck Rd
        Southold, NY 11971
        D & J Xclusive Parties - Clowns

        26. D & J Xclusive Parties

        ClownsParty & Event PlannersFamily & Business Entertainers
        Years in Business Icon
        18 Years
        in Business
        (347) 547-8824
        Central Islip, NY 11722

        From Business: We are founder and creator of D&J Xclusive Parties. We are a family created business with 5 years of fun filled party experience so you will be treated like…

        Soulful Kitchen - Personal Chefs

        27. Soulful Kitchen

        Personal ChefsBakeriesCaterers
        (1)
        Years in Business Icon
        32 Years
        in Business
        (631) 949-2268

        Serving the
        Shelter Island Area

        OPEN 24 Hours

        The service was great, Everyone was on time and food was Fabulous. It made our corporate event a great success. I just wanted to thank Ayesha and the Soulful Kitchen staff…

        Crystal M Design - Food Delivery Service

        28. Crystal M Design

        Food Delivery ServiceBakeriesParty Favors, Supplies & Services
        (631) 772-9047
        Shirley, NY 11967

        From Business: Hello, My Name is Crystal M. I am the baker as well as the designer of Crystal M. Design. Please review the previous cakes that i have completed. If you are…

        The Brownie Factory - Bakeries

        29. The Brownie Factory

        Bakeries
        Years in Business Icon
        17 Years
        in Business
        (631) 299-1327
        Commack, NY 11725
        OPEN NOW

        From Business: Hi, We're The Brownie Factory Llc. We are a gourmet organic dessert company that wants everyone to enjoy and indulge in real hand made desserts that are made…

        Waggin' Tails Dog Biscuits - Bakeries

        30. Waggin' Tails Dog Biscuits

        Bakeries
        Website
        Years in Business Icon
        33 Years
        in Business
        (631) 682-4060

        Serving the
        Shelter Island Area

        CLOSED NOW

        From Business: Dog Biscuits, Cakes, Cup cakes, T-shirts

        About Search Results

        YP - The Real Yellow PagesSM - helps you find the right local businesses to meet your specific needs. Search results are sorted by a combination of factors to give you a set of choices in response to your search criteria. These factors are similar to those you might use to determine which business to select from a local Yellow Pages directory, including proximity to where you are searching, expertise in the specific services or products you need, and comprehensive business information to help evaluate a business's suitability for you. “Preferred” listings, or those with featured website buttons, indicate YP advertisers who directly provide information about their businesses to help consumers make more informed buying decisions. YP advertisers receive higher placement in the default ordering of search results and may appear in sponsored listings on the top, side, or bottom of the search results page.

        Places Near Shelter Island, NY with Cupcakes

        Related Categories

        RestaurantsCoffee & Espresso RestaurantsCoffee ShopsDonut ShopsBagelsDessert RestaurantsCaterersIce Cream & Frozen DessertsTake Out RestaurantsWedding Cakes & Pastries