Browse through our top-ranked Hotels, curated exclusively by YP based on business popularity, reviews, and ratin…Full collection »
Popular in Shelter Island, NY
The Cheesecake Factory
610 Smith Haven Mall, Lake Grove, NY
Every type of food is served here. Fun place to enjoy a meal. The cheesecake is...
This Friday's is alright, but not as good as the one in Islandia. They use too much...
A good place to stop and have a coffee or other menu item.
Good steer is great! Every meal i had there was delicious, the food comes quick, the...
Uncle Joe's Pizza
My husband and I come from Brooklyn (Italian heritage) so believe me we know great...