Such a let down. Cici's is advertising these new artesian pizzas so when this location finally reopened I was excited. All they did was reduce the size of the buffet by half, no desserts, no pasta, no new pizzas. Such a shame. I used to eat there once a week, but no more.
Wasn't impressed at all. No pasta which sucks because my 11 month old can't really eat pizza yet. No desert unless you pay for the ice cream. This trip wasn't worth it and disappointed.
I will never go there again! Horrible customer service absolutely rude, the place is dirty and the owner should be ashamed of himself!!
Not true NY style pizza like I expected, and over priced. They cook the pizza on a turn style rotational ringer (same type pizza hut uses) versus a true NY pizzeria oven. The dough was thick and heavy and not what NY style pizza is supposed to be. The taste of the cheese and sauce was ok. The buffalo wings were great- best I have had in watertown, but I would not buy another pizza from Papa Tinos.
I've had better pizza from a Casey's general store. The crust was like cardboard, rubbery cheese, boring sauce. The staff was rude as well. I will not be returning to OIP in the future.
This has to be the best Pizza I have ever had in Watertown. I like New York style Pizza, and this rivals anything I have had in NYC. It is a MUST TRY!