Jerry's Coney Island is my go-to spot for great American food. I love the wonderful service and atmosphere. Someone left a review on here saying that there is a fee for using a credit card which is not true. I have been going here for years and there is no fee for using a credit card.
Went here for lunch today the atmosphere and service was great! However the tuna melt was the worst i've ever had. Don't get it ever and you should take it off your menu. I never had a tuna melt with sauteed onion and possibly red bell peppers!? accompanied with a weird spice (none of it was in the discription). I seriously thought i was going to be sick i sent it back!!
For as long as I can remember, this is the best coney around!! Great service and awesome food!! 5 stars!!
Used to have good food and be a cute little place w/ friendly young waitresses. Our waitress acted crazy. She couldnt run the register,forgot someones wings so she ran outside,played w/ the ice machine and left my coney getting cold.She just seemed stoned. My DD"s potato pancakes were cooked on high and the inside was mushy. IDK whats happened but RUN AWAY. Owner never came over to comment or help.
Ordered carry out 6:45 pm on 2/13/15. They first of all forgot to put my "chili special" in with the rest of the items, so I had to go back and get it. HUGE MISTAKE!!! When chili is on the menu next to soup, you believe it will be chili. You know beans, ground beef and all that stuff. Not here, it was the bean less chili dog sauce with powdered cooked beef, no beef chunks at all, with onions and cheese added to it. I took one bite to try it. It was the most disgusting thing I have ever tried. Also my son had the club sandwich. The bacon is so thick it's like trying to eat leather. Stick to their breakfasts.
Great hometown Coney!! Great food, great service and that small town family atmosphere!
I've never had a bad meal! We live really close and this seemingly hole in the wall coney is such a hidden gem!! Their all you can eat fish on Fridays is incredible and my favorite is their Waterford skillet. Breakfast food is amazing! I'm in my late 20s and when my husband and I have friends over everyone wants Waterford Coney!
Absolutely the best Reuben I've ever had and I'm picky about my reubens, they don't chince you on the corned beef even slightly. Also their chili cheese fries are to die for. My husbands swears they soak them in crack because they're so addicting good lol. We make it a point to stop here everytime we're in town!!
As a world traveler, I can tell you that the offerings for restaurants are slim in Waterford. I notice two things most: The cleanliness of the restaurant, and more importantly, the friendliness of the staff. Some of the other cafes in Waterford fail in the friendly service category. However, Waterford Coney has the others beat by a mile because their waitresses are great. The food is very good. I just wish they had a few more square feet to grow into. I highly recommend this place - especially for breakfast.
The coney was great and my husband had a mushroom swiss burger....He said it was awesome. Will go back for sure.