Saved to Favorites

Please contact the business for updated hours/services due to the COVID-19 advisory.

Proud To Serve Your Home, Auto, Farm and Business Insurance Needs Since 1960!

Call Today
General Info

McCormick Insurance Agency in Vincennes, Indiana, is your locally-owned, hometown insurance agency that has proudly served the insurance needs of Knox and surrounding counties since 1960. Protecting individuals, families and businesses for over half of a century, McCormick Insurance (founded by Don McCormick) is the area’s oldest, most established, independent insurance company. We have been the exclusive agents for Farmers Home Insurance Company, Knox County’s locally established mutual insurance company, dating back to 1895. Writing both homeowners and farm coverage for over 115 years, we do it right! As an independent agent McCormick Insurance has the flexibility to write policies for a wide variety of carriers, which not only allows you the best coverage available, but at the most competitive rates! We shop and compare coverage and rates for you. Something that director writers cannot do! Wouldn’t you like that option? We partner with and write policies with reputable insurance companies including Indiana Farmers, Grinnell, Travelers, Indiana Insurance, Hanover, Selective as well as specialty carriers like Rain and Hail and Progressive Insurance.

Regular Hours
Mon - Fri:
Sat - SunClosed

Business Insurance, Life Insurance, Health Insurance, Homeowners Insurance, Boat Insurance, ATV Insurance, Motorcycle Insurance, Car Insurance, Truck Insurance, SUV Insurance, Earthquake Insurance, Flood Insurance, Natural Disaster Insurance, Indiana Insurance, Farmers Insurance, Grinnell Mutual Insurance, Travelers Insurance, Hanover Insurance, Selective Insurance, Vincennes, IN, Knox County, Indiana, Lawrence County, IL, Insurance Quotes, Insurance Rates

Grinnell Insurance, Hanover Insurance, Indiana Farmers, Indiana Insuance, Progressive Insurance, Rain and Hail Insurance, Selective Insurance, Travelers Insurance
Payment method
all major credit cards, check

We offer homeowners insurance, auto insurance “car insurance and truck insurance”, business insurance “commercial insurance”, life insurance, health insurance, motorcycle insurance, boat insurance, AT V insurance, rain and hail insurance, earthquake insurance, flood insurance and more! McCormick agents Doug Steele, Lee Tuggle and Wally McGiffen have over 50 combined years of insurance experience and they will help you determine what insurance policies best fit your and your family’s everyday needs. So, if you are unhappy with your current insurance provider, looking for better service or would like to inquire for better rates, Call 882-5300 to schedule an appointment with Doug Steele, Lee Tuggle or Wally McGiffen today and let them help you!

Business & Commercial Insurance, Agriculture Insurance, Auto Insurance, Financial Planning Consultants, Financial Services, Homeowners Insurance, Insurance, Insurance Consultants & Analysts, Property & Casualty Insurance, Travel Insurance


Hi there!
Rate this business!
First-classBetter than mostAbout what I expectedNot the worst...Disappointing
Click to Rate
Share Review

Like this review? Share it on your social network to get the word out!

Carol K.



The service has been outstanding for years. They know what they are doing and they are the best at it. I highly recommend this company.

Dan K.



McCormick Insurance Agency has been great to work with over the past 15 years. Very personalized service, they really care about their clients.

Andy B.



Have been very happy with the service we have received from McCormick Insurance Agency. They keep us well informed and have done great work.

Diane C.



I have commercial, home and auto insurance with McCormick Insurance Agency and they have been great. They are always helpful when I have questions about my policy and they are pleasant to work with.

Tiff R.



Huge fan of McCormick Insurance Agency. I have been a client for 15 years and have never had a problem. I would highly recommend their services.