Yum yum yum! Great, fun, unique experience! We would come once a month at least if it weren't 45 minutes away! (But we still come when we can because we love it!) The Cactus dessert pie is to DIE FOR!(As for the other reviewer. They were not playing Christian music when I went. I am sure they just play what the people working there want to hear. Giving such a poor rating on that alone is terrible!)
101 W Main StSun Prairie, WI 53590
From Business: Voted Best of Madison for Pizza 17 years in a row! Online reviews will tell you Glass Nickel Pizza also has amazing Sandwiches, Salads, Fish, Shrimp, Chicken, Cal…
for $9 burgers you would think they would know how to tell a medium from a medium rare burger - hint... neither are so rare the inside is still cold and bright red. Varsity sauce was NOT all it was talked up to be.Cajun chicken sandwich should be called just a plain chicken sandwich.The only thing they had going for them was the staff! I would not go back again nor would I ever recommend this place to anyone!
Great place to grab a burger!
Don't come here if you don't want to listen to Christian music because that's what music they are playing! Ahhhhh never will I come here again!
This is my new favorite pizza place in Sun Prairie (which is saying something since we have a dozen plus). The pizza is way more flavorful than anywhere else and no matter what combination of ingredients I chose it always tastes amazing (try the banana peppers). The cinnamon bread and breadsticks are fantastic too.
small town charm, and the best pizza for miles around!! Run by Anna herself-an amazing young lady with a lovely personality--THANKS!!
The greatest pizza ever- never the cardboard, industrial, pre fab pizza, real pizza. Great salad. Wonderful dessert.
The reviews were right. I ate here last weekend and it was magnificent. The food was scrumptious and the service was very pleasant and prompt. I will definitely be back for more. Thanks!
Great food and awesome service! Every time I come here I'm greeted by a very warm and welcoming hostess, who immediately seats me. The food here is great and the servers always do a wonderful job. Thank you very much!