Barney's Gourmet Hamburgers
4138 24th St, San Francisco, CA 94114
Barneys Noe Valley
Good for Kids: Yes
Cuisines: Burgers, American, Family Style, Hot Dogs, Breakfast, Brunch & Lunch
Price Range : Below Average
No coupons available
09/13/2009Provided by Citysearch -
since the last review back in September 2007. That review described almost the same experience we had today. The service was slow, although it was just after the lunch rush and the dining room had emptied out. The kitchen got our burger patties confused. And the waitresses seemed frazzled, distracted, rushed, tired,...what I don't expect from a full staffed restaurant. I used to love Barney's and missed it when I moved away (Barney's in LA just isn't the same). Having just moved back, I was so excited for my first Barney's burger back home. I was sorely disappointed, and am now questioning if I will ever return. I'm giving it three stars because I have a soft spot for the Barney's of yesterday.
This place is truly a shadow of its former self. Bring back the days of praised cooking and atmosphere!
09/03/2007Provided by Citysearch -
The sign said ""please wait to be seated"" but a confused staff member handed us three menus and said ""sit anywhere."" That was our first clue. We wove through the myriad of poorly behaved children and dirty, un-bussed tables to find a corner where the music wasn't too obnoxious. This had once been a great place for burgers and salads so we gave it the benefit of the doubt. In hindsight - we should have come up with a plan B while we waited 10 minutes for water - no waitress in sight. When she did show up she was rushed. Burgers, salads and curly fries - all standards at this restaurant - so we thought our order would be a snap. Nearly 20 minutes later, some cold fries were delivered. When we pointed this out we were told, ""the kitchen just made them"" - and there was no offer to fix the situation. Another 10 minutes and the food arrives. The salad was pretty but not made as requested. The burgers were overcooked and somewhat room temperature. It's hard to tell if the kitchen staff doesn't care or if the service is just poor - or both. We elected to get up and leave our uneaten meals for the busboy - who was obviously still on break. We found an alternate eating establishment and I would recommend that you save yourself the aggravation we experienced and do the same.
04/30/2007Provided by Citysearch -
I had been going to Barney's for years. My last 3 times in 2005-6 were real disappointments though. My requested medium rare / medium burger came in at well done, dry and crumbly, not moist meat. Even after sending it back (something I've only done 1 other time in the last 5 years) it came back almost inedible.
I tried switching to the chicken breast sandwich the next time and the experience was unfortunately even worse. The breast was dry and tasteless.
So by luck I went into the 24th Street Cafe (aka Joe's cafe) at 3853 24th St., cross street Vicksburg looking for a burger and found burger heaven. The owner (Joe or his staff) will cook the Niman Ranch hamburger medium rare, medium, however you like! And the chicken breast sandwich has always been moist and tender. I have been going back once a week for over a year now and every time the thick cut fries are crispy on the outside, hot on the inside, the lettuce green and cool, the milk cold and the service always friendly, (especially when Joe and his wife or daughter are working.
If you want a consistent excellent, fresh burger or chicken breast go here! The phone numbers is 415-282-1213 and is in the middle of the 24th street shopping district. bon appetite!
10/31/2006Provided by Citysearch -
My first Barney's was the one in LA, and I've been there way too many times to count. The Barney's up here just aren't the same. The menu is the same, but there is something about how it's prepared here. And I've never, ever had good service at a Barney's in the Bay Area. I know Barney's started here, but it's just not what I'm used to...
09/24/2006Provided by Citysearch -
I'm not a hamburger enthusiast, but the burger meat here is very, very good. It's overwhelming to find 24 beef burger choices alone. And, there's chicken, vegan & turkey burgers to chose from or salads & sandwiches. The pesto burger was served on a wide baguette w/pesto sauce, a thin slice of pickle and Thousand Island dressing on the side. We ordered ""skinny"" fries on the side, it was unsalted & crispy. It is so nice to be able to eat where the food is not drenched in salt and you can actually taste the food. My beef burger came exactly medium rare. There is a front patio extensively shaded by trees where you can dine outside, or inside. Lots of families w/small kids and residential couples dine here. Looking forward to returning here in the future and sampling other burgers along w/their milkshakes or rootbeer (IBC) float. The beef burgers are reasonably priced between $6.96-$7.50. The most expensive items were the chicken burgers at $7.95. If you like burgers, go no where else.
08/26/2005Provided by Citysearch -
Everywhere i've gone to try ""the best burger"", has disappointed. They're all good, but only Barney's is amazing. My boyfriend and I will drive from the mission all the way over there, look for parking for 20 min and still it's worth it agree that it's worth it. The pesto cheeseburger is awesome and their curly fries are irresistable.
04/28/2005Provided by Citysearch -
If you live nearby and you're in the mood for a tasty, moist burger, then you have found the place. Parking is somewhat difficult, the atmosphere is completely uninspired, but on a warm day when you can sit out in the patio and have a beer and burger this is THE place to hang out. It's the kind of food that's filling after a day of cleaning, biking, or working in the yard. An almost infinite array of burgers. Good fries to.
02/17/2005Provided by Citysearch -
I've tried to figure out the appeal of this place. Does the bun compliment what's inside? No. Is the beef moist, flavorful, and tender?No. The patties here are big and the buns are even bigger, but size does not a good burger make. I event went back a 2nd time to see if I was nuts. Barney's is consistent at serving up a mediocre burger.
Maybe it's that I lived in the midwest for two years, where steakburgers are plentiful and people take great care in slapping a perfectly cooked cut of meat on a bun with tomatoes, lettuce, and onions in a way that makes a delicacy out of what most people consider fast food, and i'm just spoiled.
For a good burger around here, I'd say your best bet is 1)the restaurant in the Palace Hotel (get it medium-rare), or 2)the $12 Kobe burger at Rogue Ale.
08/16/2003Provided by Citysearch -
The hamburgers here are decent, but smothered in something to give them a grilled/smokey flavor. What happens is the tast becomes overwhelming and you can't enjoy the burger. I'd recommend the burgers at Orphan Andy's on 17th just off Market over Barney's anyday.
08/06/2003Provided by Citysearch -
They have a large variety of different burgers to choose from and they're all delicious! Also, compliment your burger with a side of curly fries and a strawberry milkshake! Make sure you come in real hungry because once you're out, you'll want to unbuckle that belt! I love it! Great service and friendly staff. Would recommend.
04/15/2003Provided by Citysearch -
Barney's is about the only place to get an actual gourment burger. They do it exactly right there. They use quality meat, and fresh, tasty toppings. It's the only burger place I know of in the Bay Area that puts out a top-notch product. Hands down my choice as best burger. The curly fries are excellent, and the ranch dressing they serve is unbelievably tangy.
02/28/2003Provided by Citysearch -
the best thing about Barney's is that you can go as often as you like and get a different type of burger everytime! where else in the city can you find a hamburger with ham, pinapple, and a yummy glaze? and the fries are in a category all of their own-- try the curly fries-- they are amazing
10/25/2002Provided by Citysearch -
I have traveled to numerous parts of the world and there is no doubt Barney's qualifies as one of the best places in the world to enjoy hamburger fare.
Their menu is so diversified and can easily please everyone from carnivores to vegans. Prices are reasonable and service is usually great. Oftentimes we enjoy outdoor seating on a patio in the middle of busy neighborhoods.
Every guest I have taken to Barney's was pleased with the taste of the food.
10/02/2002Provided by Citysearch -
To this day I do not understand why everyone raves about Barney's...the meat is poor quality, the restaurants are always messy, the service is mediocre at best. The only thing they have going for them is their 1000 or so topping choices for burgers, and anyone can do that.