Reynoldsburg, OH Pizza Cottage

About Search Results

About Search Results

YP - The Real Yellow PagesSM - helps you find the right local businesses to meet your specific needs. Search results are sorted by a combination of factors to give you a set of choices in response to your search criteria. These factors are similar to those you might use to determine which business to select from a local Yellow Pages directory, including proximity to where you are searching, expertise in the specific services or products you need, and comprehensive business information to help evaluate a business's suitability for you. “Preferred” listings, or those with featured website buttons, indicate YP advertisers who directly provide information about their businesses to help consumers make more informed buying decisions. YP advertisers receive higher placement in the default ordering of search results and may appear in sponsored listings on the top, side, or bottom of the search results page.

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

1. Pizza Cottage

1000 Old Diley RdPickerington, OH 43147

(614) 856-3333

From Business: 11:00-22:00[mon,tue,wed,thu] 11:00-23:00[fri,sat] 11:00-22:00[sun]

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

2. Cottage Inn Pizza

2167 N High StColumbus, OH 43201

(614) 564-9292

From Business: Looking for the best pizza in Columbus? Rejoice, you purveyors of all things pizza pie the seemingly endless search is finally over. From thin crust to deep dish …

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

3. Pizza Cottage

(2)
BBB Rating: A+

4592 Walnut RdBuckeye Lake, OH 43008

(740) 928-1144

Had a really GREA Italian salad and the thin crust pepperoni pizza had fresh baked flavor and lots of topping. Will be back when in area.

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

4. Pizza Cottage

(1)

2223 W Fair AveLancaster, OH 43130

(740) 654-2400

The best Pizza! We used to Drive to Buckeye Lake which is about 20 or so minutes away from Lancaster to eat at the Pizza Cottage. Thank goodness we …

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

5. Cottage Inn Pizza

(1)
BBB Rating: A+

8317 Market Exchange DrWesterville, OH 43081

(614) 888-8488

I'm gluten free and haven't been able to enjoy pizza or garlic cheesy bread until coming here.

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

PREFERRED

6. Pizza Cottage

(1)

969 Mount Vernon RdNewark, OH 43055

(740) 281-2738

Always fast, and delicious pizza.

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

7. Cottage Inn Pizza

(1)
BBB Rating: A+

4674 Cemetery RdHilliard, OH 43026

(614) 777-5450

New management and crew has this place moving up. Great food

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

9. Cottage Inn Gourmet Pizza - CLOSED

1145 Columbus PikeDelaware, OH 43015

(740) 362-0111
Businesses in related categories to Pizza
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

12. MKD Industries

499 Lancaster AveReynoldsburg, OH 43068

(614) 868-0055
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

13. Fox's Pizza Den

8130 E Broad StReynoldsburg, OH 43068

(614) 863-5500
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

14. Zero's Pizza & Delivery

7950 E Broad StReynoldsburg, OH 43068

(614) 328-8130
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection
Alatoby's - CLOSED

15. Alatoby's - CLOSED

(4)

1361 Brice RdReynoldsburg, OH 43068

(614) 868-1998

Good pizza fare price friendly people a must try place

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

16. Bread Baskets Family Bakery

7516 E Main StReynoldsburg, OH 43068

(614) 322-9587
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

17. Marco's Pizza

8072 E Broad StReynoldsburg, OH 43068

(614) 367-9999
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

18. Little Caesars

14958 E Broad StReynoldsburg, OH 43068

(614) 866-5487
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

19. Reynoldsburg Romeos Pizza

499 Lancaster AveReynoldsburg, OH 43068

(614) 863-1000
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

20. Massey's Pizza

(1)

7070 E Main StReynoldsburg, OH 43068

(614) 868-0690

Masseys pizza is very very good and they never mess any thing up you never will recieve a cold pizza always piping hot and delivered very quickly th…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

21. Cajun Island

1765 Brice RdReynoldsburg, OH 43068

(614) 866-6300
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection
Pizza Hut

22. Pizza Hut

6736 E Main StReynoldsburg, OH 43068

(614) 861-3924

From Business: Get oven-hot pizza, fast from your local Pizza Hut in Reynoldsburg. Enjoy favorites like Original Pan Pizza, Breadsticks, WingStreet Wings, Hershey's Chocolate Ch…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

23. Grandma's Pizza & Pasta

(1)
BBB Rating: A+

7117 E Main StReynoldsburg, OH 43068

(614) 863-0777

Ordered from them twice and both times our order was f---ed up. Food cold, soggy slimy bread, long ass wait 1 hr and 6 minutes? And we are just minu…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

24. Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery

(4)

7516 E Main StReynoldsburg, OH 43068

(614) 322-9587

Very good pizza and priced well.

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

25. Classic Pizza - CLOSED

(3)

7619 E Main StReynoldsburg, OH 43068

(614) 577-9000

We moved into our house in August of 1998, and our first meal was Classic Pizza. 10 years later, they're still our exclusive pizza joint. The food i…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

26. Vick's Gourmet Pizza

(2)
BBB Rating: A+

7333 E Main StReynoldsburg, OH 43068

(614) 866-5021

Great Pizza and friendly atmosphere. I can't wait until they move into the old Connell Hardware building on the same block. They're moving in there …

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

27. Papa John's Pizza

BBB Rating: A+

7061 E Main StReynoldsburg, OH 43068

(614) 751-8000

From Business: Papa John's is one of the world's largest pizza companies that maintains more than 3,000 locations in over 45 U.S. states and nearly 25 international markets. Est…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection
Creno's Pizza

28. Creno's Pizza

8305 Taylor Rd SWReynoldsburg, OH 43068

(614) 863-5444
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection
Donatos Pizza

29. Donatos Pizza

(1)

1815 Brice RdReynoldsburg, OH 43068

(614) 861-0211

I order here at least once a week. My delivery is alway fast, hot and exactly as I ordered!

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

30. Minuteman Pizza

(1)
BBB Rating: A+

2723 Independence Village CtrReynoldsburg, OH 43068

(614) 575-0033

I love Minuteman! Their pizza has a great sauce, their italian subs are the best in the city, and my kids adore their wings.

Didn't find what you were looking for?
magnifying glass
Helpful Reviews 
Vick's Gourmet Pizza
George A. rated

Great Pizza and friendly atmosphere. I can't wait until they move into the old Connell Hardware building on the same block. They're moving in there for more dinning space and easier access

Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery
George A. rated

The one time I ordered a pizza from them, they forgot to put the sauce on it. Never went back, never will. I go to Vick's, Grandma's or Pizzaroni's for me when it comes to Pizza in Reynoldsburg.

Grandma's Pizza & Pasta
Rhoda S. rated

Ordered from them twice and both times our order was f---ed up. Food cold, soggy slimy bread, long ass wait 1 hr and 6 minutes? And we are just minutes away? We will not be giving them our service anymore!!!!!!!!!!

Classic Pizza
Larry S. rated

My son came home from the service and wanted classic pizza last week. We grew up on it. We went there and got pizza and a 16 inch sub. The bun on the sub was so hard we couldn't eat it and oh my the pizza was just down right nasty. I think I seen mold in the cheese, the crust was gooey but burnt on the sides and the girl that served it to us was playing with her hair the whole time she was making food. I think she had her whole family in there. Someone needs to call the health department on that place. We will never go back or will my friends

Classic Pizza
holmez80 rated
Experience

So I just had classic pizza from the Reynoldsburg location. I grew up on classic pizza and this was not it. So they changed the cheese, the pepperoni was not to par and the sauce not there, either. Needless to say, if you love classic pizza don't waste your money here.

Alatoby's
Ross R. rated
Friendly family

Good pizza fare price friendly people a must try place

Vick's Gourmet Pizza
blueeyes7 rated
AWESOME

AWESOME, and so so yummy.Vick's is the Best Pizza, Subs,, Wings, Strombolli's, etc, everything is amazing. You can not go wrong at all, the #1 Best Pizza Place in Reynoldsburg, Ohio on Main St.Must try, You'll Love them

Alatoby's
vleake rated

Best wings I have had in Columbus, and the Cream Puffs are to die for.Can't wait till go back

Donatos Pizza
mrjleew rated
Bad Service

This location taught me to always look at your pizza before you leave. When I got home and opened the box, I got a big surprise, my pizza looked like it had been dropped. All the pepperoni was on one side and it looked like some was missing. Well, I called back, told my story, was told to come back or when I order again I would have a credit. Needless to say I never got the credit. Called their Corporate office and was given the runner-round.

Feedback