Saved to Favorites

Pizzeria New York

Add to Favorites
CLOSED NOW
Today: 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm
Tomorrow: 4:00 pm - 11:00 pm
Years in Business icon
19 Years
in Business
BBB Rating icon
Accredited
Business
Amenities:
Wheelchair accessible
(614) 862-4743Visit WebsiteMap & Directions833 Hill Rd NPickerington, OH 43147Write a Review

Reviews

Hi there!
Rate this business!
What do you rate this business?First-classBetter than mostAbout what I expectedNot the worst...Disappointing
Click to Rate
abbyandcurt04

01/25/2012

Overall
Best pizza in Picktown

My family loves New York Pizziaria for the stone cooked pizza, great atmosphere, and friendly service.

kenz24

04/06/2011

Overall
delicious

great pizza but it is kind of greasy

other than that this is the place to go

dk4kids01

02/18/2010

Overall
war of words

it sounds to me like the bad review was written by a competitor and the glowing review was written by someone with a vested interest in the business. Neither review is correct. The place isn't the worst ever, but they are not a gift from the pizza gods either. Pickerington doesn't have great pizza selection so until adriaticos moves a location in this is the best we have but the others we have are donatos, pizza hut, pizza cottage, domino's, etc you get the idea.

picktown1

08/22/2008

Overall
this is not the pizzeria i know

The pizzeria new york in pickerington ,ohio is very good at there job. Everytime i have been in there i have had nothing but great food and service. All the employes is very respect full. i have never known the pizza shop to have ever close at 6:00 or 6:45pm because i am in there at least every two days. So i dont think that you should bad mouth this nice establishment without really trying to give it a chance.



pny's #1 fan

bkcar24

05/31/2008

Overall
Not Dependable

I drove an hour to get what was supposed to be the best pizza in town and they were closed at 6pm. Two weeks later, I called on a Sunday at 5:30pm to specifically ask what time they closed and was told 8:00pm. I once again drove an hour and the door was open, but the staff told me they were sorry, it was slow so they closed at 6:45pm. I have tried to make contact with the owner and he has not returned any of my calls. Management terrible, service terrible, ownerterrible. I will be filing with the Better Business Bureau. STAY AWAY FROM THIS ONE!

Details

Phone: (614) 862-4743

Address: 833 Hill Rd N, Pickerington, OH 43147

Website: http://www.pizzerianewyork.com

More Info

General Info
AUTHENTIC NY STYLE PIZZA
Email
BBB Rating
A+
BBB Rating and Accreditation information may be delayed up to a week.
Extra Phones

Phone: (740) 862-4743

Payment method
all major credit cards, amex, cash, discover, master card, visa
Price Range
$
Neighborhood
South Columbus
Categories
Other Information

Cuisines: Caterers, Italian, European, Continental, Pizza

Wheelchair Accessible: Yes

Parking: Lot, Private

Attire: Casual

Takes Reservations: No

Outdoor Seating: No

Price Range : Below Average

People Also Viewed