Old Town Saint Augustine, FL Captain D S

The food was top of the line....Sesame Ahi Tuna topped with Seaweed Salad!!!!! Wait staff was very attentive. Will definitely go back.

I'm surprised this place doesn't have more reviews! great seafood and great crowd. I went alone just to check it out and ill be bringing people back very soon.

We were a party of 7, the food and atmosphere were great but the waiter was slow, didn't bring drinks promptly, didn't offer water or even ask if anyone wanted another drink. I had to get the other waitress to have him clear our table and bring out a bday cake I had brought. He brought out the desert dishes before he had even cleaned the table off. I ended up putting plates onto another table to clear it. Usually the restaurant is superb in every way, but not this time.

Food was acceptable taste but would of liked in a whole bunch more if "all" or food was hot. We had the early bird shrimp special with fries. My husband had a side salad and I had cauliflower au gratin which was just warm like the rest of our food. Not recommend.

Great appetizer and steak! the waitress was very attentive and the kitchen staff was able to accommodate with a custom entree for my son who has allergic reactions.

Food was poor. Very much so a tourist restaurant. Our server sat at a table next to us with two guys and was eating from their plates and didnt realize we were her table until 30 minutes later when a hostess told her. She forgot our drinks, another 20 minutes pass by. Food was cold, she walked up to our table shoving food in her mouth and then started talking badly about the table across the restaurant about how "needy" they are. Horrific.

This is the most over priced bad restaurant I've ever visited. My $37 10 oz haha filet, ordered medium, was about 6 oz burned to a crisp around the edges and tough as an ol shoe. There were five adults. Shrimp an grits was a few small shrimp in a bowl of what appeared to be broth with the grits stuck to the bottom of the bowl. The fried shrimp reportedly was ok, but how you gonna screw up fried food anyway? The sirloin was also reported as good, but was ordered well done, so. I would say it's more like jerky as designed. The service was sub par. The restaurant has 1 high chair. There were three small children there in the 7pm timeframe, two of which had to sit in a booth. The bill was north of $200. I was flummoxed!

I have tried items from both the breakfast and lunch menu. Food is full of flavor and far from the average breakfasts and lunches you get downtown for the same prices. I highly recommend trying this restaurant.

I had breakfast at Oyster Creek this morning to try them out and was very pleasantly surprised. I had the Breakfast Wrap and it was huge, almost more than I could eat. I sat outside on a very nice little patio and appreciated the friendly service. If they can keep up the good work it won't take long for this place to become a local favorite.

DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY!!! I ordered the steak which was $50.00. I ordered it medium and within less than 5 minutes it came out to my table and it was well done. They brought me out yet another one in less than 5 minutes again. I ordered the risotto and it was the worst I have ever had. All you could taste was cream and fake cheese... Everything is pre cooked here and when I walked by the kitchen, it did not look very clean... I would not advise anyone to spend their hard earned money on inferior quality food...