Wish this review was better. A friend brought one of these Pizzas to a party several months ago and I was thrilled to finally taste a New York Style Pizza from this area. It was great. A week ago I took a friend to this place for lunch. First thought was this is a bit expensive but ok, worth it if it's a good as I had the first time. Was 18.00 for medium Pepperoni and Mushroom, must of got the bill wrong as this is a large pie price and not whats posted on their website. The Pizza came out odd shaped and the crust was practically flat. NY style is a thin crust with bubbly edge like you see in the pictures here. That's not what we got. I would guess there was no yeast in the dough, it was flat, dry and bland. The sauce was very good but the Cheese, Pepperoni and Mushrooms were very, very scarce. My friend even commented, "didn't we order a Pepperoni, Mushroom?" Very disappointing and hope they get it back together so I can once again a NY style Pizza in this area.
Quick to take my order, make my order and it tasted good too. Keep up the good work.
Great local dive pizza shop. And I mean dive in a good way. On the square.
Great new york style pizza!!