In mybook® Fun Collection (edit)

Added to your fun collection.
Removed from mybook!

We took this business out of your fun collection.

Sponsored Links
Hours

Regular Hours

SunClosed

Payment method
all major credit cards
Price Range
$$
Neighborhoods
Midtown Manhattan, Theater District
AKA

Pig'n' Whistle

Pig n Whistle - Times Square

Categories
Bars, Night Clubs, Taverns, Restaurants
Other Information

Price Range : Average

COUPONS & DEALS

No coupons available

Reviews

Hi there!
Rate this business!
First-classBetter than mostAbout what I expectedNot the worst...Disappointing
Click to Rate
Share Review

Like this review? Share it on your social network to get the word out!

CPNY

06/15/2010

Provided by Citysearch - 
Overall
Rude Bartender, high prices

I went with 2 friends who were in town visiting and staying near Times Square. We ordered a few drinks and shots, were chatting with the bartender, and having a good time (the shots weren't great and were pricey, and the place was fairly empty, but the music was decent and we were happy anyway).

The bar started to close, and we got our tab, and paid half cash half credit. Upon getting the cards that had been charged, my friends realized their cards weren't charged enough, and decided to do the honest thing and tell the bartender, Mark, the mistake. Without even saying thank you, he fixed the prices, re-ran their cards, and had them re-sign. I told him very calmly that I thought it wasn't cool that these girls had been honest and saved him from a $20 mistake and that he didn't offer them a drink or anything, and he rudely snapped back ""It makes no difference to me, and it's time for you to leave girls.""

We'll never go back to that bar, and I would suggest to anybody looking for nice, honest service not to go either.

shupirate9

12/09/2009

Provided by Citysearch - 
Overall
It's NYC, there's other places

stopped in for a quick bite to eat after seeing the tree in rockefeller center and probably won't go back.

the waitress was very inattentive - not that we wanted another drink, but she didn't come back to ask until we were done with our meal... the food was perfectly undistinguished, other than the steak fries, but that doesn't make much of a meal.

half-joked to my gf that a hot dog on the corner would've been a better meal than what we paid for here... but it's probably not far from the truth considering the price you pay to eat in times square and the quality or lack there of this burger and chicken sandwich provided.

in short, with so many other pubs and restaurants in the city, there's no reason to go here.

WHOA12

02/28/2009

Provided by Citysearch - 
Overall
PIG AND WHISTLE STINKS

TY THING]K THEY HAVE GOOD FOOD, AND GOOD MUSIC, THEY ATTRACT TOUISTS... NOT GOOD ANYTHING. iRISH BAND THAT STUNK. tH nELSON BAND. nOT REALLY iRISH. sKIP ALL TOGETHER

mysteryirishdiner

01/12/2009

Provided by Citysearch - 
Overall
Great all round bar

What can I say good atmosphere and very friendly bar staff. Two of us went to new york visiting from Boston and this is 1 of the few bars we were really looked after.Good food good drink and good atmosphere.

myfiction

09/17/2008

Provided by Citysearch - 
Overall
Great pub

Pig 'n' Whistle was the best pub I visited while in NYC, hands down. The atmosphere was great as was the food. The only thing advice I'd offer would be to encourage the bar tenders to engage in a little more conversation with the customers at the bar, it would be a great final touch to the environment of the pub. Can't really think of anything to complain about when it comes to the Pig 'n' Whistle!

karen5246

04/02/2008

Provided by Citysearch - 
Overall
Nice bar

Dropped in here before a show on a recommendation from a friend and it was my 1st time there. My friend had the burger which she said was good and I just had drinks. It was normal NY prices and the bartenders were great! Always ready 2 get us another drink.There was arelaxed atmosphere with a little buzz around, we had fun though. I'll def go back again to check it out at the weekend!

donnaire

02/10/2008

Provided by Citysearch - 
Overall
great service, friendly atmosphere

i found my new local. warm friendly staff.very polite waitreses.food wasnt great but would def go back for a few drinks when around time square. cute bartenders here too!!

jackb35

12/08/2007

Provided by Citysearch - 
Overall
I'm Tourist and this my main stop every Christmas

I always eat sandwitches there, but the irish people are really great. bartenders been there for ever. Never an empty glass. Fun, Fun without being a drunk. great atmosphere! I'm Texan(they don't understand me()they are all Irish and I don't understand them. how real can you get wow

charybdis

09/30/2006

Provided by Citysearch - 
Overall
Awful

Maybe tourists think this hell-hole is fun but no New Yorker in their right mind would have a good time here. Lousy service, bad food, drunk-filled bar, zero ambience, bartenders who leer at female customers. The Guiness is OK though. A must to avoid.

mlhauge

08/23/2006

Provided by Citysearch - 
Overall
Great pub with atmosphere

This is definitely a place I stop every trip. I love the food, atmosphere, cider beer and bartenders. This is a great place for a group to watch a game or for a meeting spot before a date. The seating area is kind of tight but the food makes up for it. It's a great place to duck out of Times Square and eat at.

littlecherub

12/04/2005

Provided by Citysearch - 
Overall
Bad Service

We went there after a show, we were seated promptly, drinks arrived then dinner. Then we waited and waited and waited. Tried to get the waitress's attention and were ignored, at one point she came over with two dinnners that she thought were ours, she forgot we had dinner, finally she came back and wanted to take our orders? We told here we had already had dinner and we wanted the check. She mumbled something about our order being ""closed out"" on the register. I won't go back, there are too many other choices in NYC.

citydano

12/18/2002

Provided by Citysearch - 
Overall
Rude waitress, rude manager

I've been here many times in past. Recently, I was showing relatives around the city and stopped in for a drink. They sat us at a table without bothering to ask if we wanted dinner, not our problem really. After the rude waitress took our order we were sipping our drinks when the manager comes over and says we have to leave as the tables are reserved for dinner patrons. For one thing, nobody was waiting for dinner anyway secondly, THEY sat us there without asking whether we wanted dinner or not, again not our problem, third and most importantly that is just an unbelievably poor way to treat your customers. And you wonder where the stereotype of New Yorkers as being rude comes from? I left a penny tip. Obviously I am NEVER coming back here, it's not like there is a shortage of bars in the city.

pubpatron

11/16/2002

Provided by Citysearch - 
Overall
Middle ground

My second visit to this Pub, sorry I can not agree with the rest. Waitress forgot drinks, and watched us begin our dinner without even water, strange.

Food average, wife had sheppards pie and I fish & chips. I do not understand how one can make bad french fries but I had them here. They were so brown my wife thought they were made from sweet potatoes.

On the plus side there is an upstairs bar and seating for us older folk. Downstairs is noisy and crowded.

maritericann

09/12/2002

Provided by Citysearch - 
Overall
Hidden Gem

Great food, prices & staff make this a must. Highly recommended.

Sponsored Links
Feedback