Italian Restaurants in New Paris, IN

About Search Results
About Search Results

YP - The Real Yellow PagesSM - helps you find the right local businesses to meet your specific needs. Search results are sorted by a combination of factors to give you a set of choices in response to your search criteria. These factors are similar to those you might use to determine which business to select from a local Yellow Pages directory, including proximity to where you are searching, expertise in the specific services or products you need, and comprehensive business information to help evaluate a business's suitability for you. “Preferred” listings, or those with featured website buttons, indicate YP advertisers who directly provide information about their businesses to help consumers make more informed buying decisions. YP advertisers receive higher placement in the default ordering of search results and may appear in sponsored listings on the top, side, or bottom of the search results page.

Please contact the business for updated hours/services due to the COVID-19 advisory.

Stumpys Old Time Pizza

1. Stumpys Old Time Pizza

(574) 831-4160

19152 County Road 46
New Paris, IN 46553

User Avatar

great people and great food love their pizza and their chicken also pork chops are great.

Gerace's Pizzeria

2. Gerace's Pizzeria

(574) 535-0011

65529 State Road 15
Goshen, IN 46526

Samuel Mancino's Italian

3. Samuel Mancino's Italian

(574) 534-6000

905 Linway Dr
Goshen, IN 46526

The food was fairly decent though my sons grilled cheese was not. I was really surprised by the lack of cleanliness. The fountain pop machine…

Per Bacco Ristorante Italiano

4. Per Bacco Ristorante Italiano

(574) 226-0838

28046 County Road 16
Elkhart, IN 46516

Lucchese's Italian Restaurant

5. Lucchese's Italian Restaurant

(574) 522-4137

655 County Road 17 Ste 9
Elkhart, IN 46516

User Avatar

Locally owned and operated. Great atmosphere and great service. Only drawback it is in a strip shopping center and not readily seen from the…

Antonio's

6. Antonio's

(574) 295-8424

1105 Goshen Ave
Elkhart, IN 46516

Best Italian in town must try the calamari

Samuel Mancino's Italian Eatery

7. Samuel Mancino's Italian Eatery

(574) 825-2565

422 S Main St
Middlebury, IN 46540

Cavin Street Pizzeria

8. Cavin Street Pizzeria

(260) 894-4240

316 S Cavin St
Ligonier, IN 46767

User Avatar

Quite possibly the best pizza I've ever had! It isn't cheap, but it is definitely worth the extra dough!

Samuel Mancino's

9. Samuel Mancino's

(574) 294-2020

23810 Old Us 20
Elkhart, IN 46516

Samuel Mancino's Italian Eatery

10. Samuel Mancino's Italian Eatery

(574) 522-7400

2930 S Nappanee St
Elkhart, IN 46517

User Avatar

Ordered a chicken cordin bleu grinder. Had one slice of ham and 8 cubes of chicken. Seriously?

Samuel Mancino's Italian

11. Samuel Mancino's Italian

(574) 266-8664

1230 N Nappanee St
Elkhart, IN 46514

The Channel Marker

12. The Channel Marker

(574) 457-5900

5793 E Pickwick Rd
Syracuse, IN 46567

Food is wonderful, staff is fun, and the setting on Lake Wawasee tops it all off. They have seafood, steak, pasta, sandwiches, and salad choices. …

Volcano Pizza Concord Commons

13. Volcano Pizza Concord Commons

(574) 875-6568

3704 E Mishawaka Rd
Elkhart, IN 46517

BE

The pandemic has shown just how out of date their method is. Lack of online ordering makes it impossible to order as the phone is usually busy. Of…

Venturi

14. Venturi

BBB Rating: A+
11
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
(574) 485-2985

123 E Lincoln Ave
Goshen, IN 46528

From Business: Serving Italian pizza made with the finest ingredients.

Pizza Depot

15. Pizza Depot

(574) 642-4229

104 N Jefferson St
Millersburg, IN 46543

Samuel Mancino's - Nappanee, IN

16. Samuel Mancino's - Nappanee, IN

(574) 221-2367

903 W Market St
Nappanee, IN 46550

Enzo Pizza

17. Enzo Pizza

(574) 875-8225

3701 S Main St Ste 1128
Elkhart, IN 46517

Whetten Pizza

18. Whetten Pizza

(574) 658-9795

130 S Main St
Milford, IN 46542

Tony's Famous Grill

19. Tony's Famous Grill

(574) 534-2777

103 N 5th St
Goshen, IN 46528

The Godfather is by far the best 1lb hamburger a person can buy. I have ate many other fresh made hamburgers from other well known restaurants.…

Michael's Italian Restaurant

20. Michael's Italian Restaurant

BBB Rating: A+
61
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
(574) 522-3664

528 Harrison St
Elkhart, IN 46516

Rulli's Pizza

21. Rulli's Pizza

(574) 825-7222

851 Us Highway 20 Ste 2
Middlebury, IN 46540

Milano's Pizza

22. Milano's Pizza

(574) 293-2682

2808 S Main St
Elkhart, IN 46517

My family has been going to Milanos for 20 years. We have turned all of our friends into Milano lovers too. BEST pizza in Elkhart Co.

Bruno's Pizza

23. Bruno's Pizza

(574) 296-9680

28046 County Road 16
Elkhart, IN 46516

Pizza is amazing here. its the real deal and cheap pizza won't cut it anymore! But, beware of other brunos, like the one on licolnway, its not half…

Saylor's Pizza & More

24. Saylor's Pizza & More

(6)
BBB Rating: A+
16
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
(574) 293-3683

2047 Oakland Ave
Elkhart, IN 46516

User Avatar

Excellent food. I would recommended

Volcano Pizza

25. Volcano Pizza

(1)
BBB Rating: A+
64
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
(574) 295-8606

126 Easy Shopping Pl
Elkhart, IN 46516

User Avatar

The Greatest Pizza Ever Good Crust Great topping Pic-up Close delivery only. While in store very friendly staff prompt service

Danny's Pizza & Sports Bar

26. Danny's Pizza & Sports Bar

(1)
BBB Rating: A+
29
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
(574) 834-1111

3620 N Barbee Rd # 2
Warsaw, IN 46582

Danny's,pizza is the Best pizza around here. Only had the thin crust so far but it was fantastic.

Volcano Pizza

27. Volcano Pizza

(574) 262-3339

1900 Berry St Ste G
Elkhart, IN 46514

the best piazza in town. breadsticks are awesome while they last.

523 Tap & Grill

28. 523 Tap & Grill

BBB Rating: A+
13
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
(574) 523-1523

523 S Main St
Elkhart, IN 46516

From Business: Bistro fare with a Mediterranean flair. Perfect for a quiet lunch, evening out, group dinner or a nice nightcap. Delicious martinis, craft and mainstream beers…

Rulli's Italian Rest Inc

29. Rulli's Italian Rest Inc

BBB Rating: A+
34
YEARS
IN BUSINESS
(574) 825-7222

851 Us Highway 20 Ste 2
Middlebury, IN 46540

magnifying glass

Didn't find what you were looking for?
Please help others by helping us do better.

Suggest a Business