Italian Restaurants in New Castle, PA

About Search Results
About Search Results

YP - The Real Yellow PagesSM - helps you find the right local businesses to meet your specific needs. Search results are sorted by a combination of factors to give you a set of choices in response to your search criteria. These factors are similar to those you might use to determine which business to select from a local Yellow Pages directory, including proximity to where you are searching, expertise in the specific services or products you need, and comprehensive business information to help evaluate a business's suitability for you. “Preferred” listings, or those with featured website buttons, indicate YP advertisers who directly provide information about their businesses to help consumers make more informed buying decisions. YP advertisers receive higher placement in the default ordering of search results and may appear in sponsored listings on the top, side, or bottom of the search results page.

Please contact the business for updated hours/services due to the COVID-19 advisory.

Ladies Of The Duke

1. Ladies Of The Duke

(724) 658-9258

1114 N Croton Ave
New Castle, PA 16101

The Ladies of the Dukes makes the best homemade sauce and pasta. You can dine there or you can get take out sauce or food. You need to bring your…

II Tomato

2. II Tomato

(724) 658-3380

2409 Wilmington Rd
New Castle, PA 16105

Gallo's Italian Villa

3. Gallo's Italian Villa

(724) 656-9280

2420 Wilmington Rd
New Castle, PA 16105


You feel a warm welcome as soon as you go in! Mr. Gallo comes to every table & talks to you! He must never take a day off because he's there every…

Soni's Italian Restaurant

4. Soni's Italian Restaurant

(724) 652-8900

3208 Wilmington Rd
New Castle, PA 16105

Sonis italian restaurant makes the best flat bread sandwiches around. They have them in italian or steak and they are delicious. You can get take…

Pizza's  By Marchelloni

5. Pizza's By Marchelloni

(724) 734-5728

418 W Washington St
New Castle, PA 16101

From Business: Locally owned and operated for 20 years. We make all of our dough fresh daily, and use only the freshest ingredients for a taste you'll love. Your satisfaction…

Mangino's Pizzeria

6. Mangino's Pizzeria

(724) 202-6278

2710 Wilmington Rd
New Castle, PA 16105

Pagley's Pasta & More

7. Pagley's Pasta & More

(724) 658-3066

1235 E Washington St
New Castle, PA 16101

As a visitor to New Castle looking for good Italian food I was directed to this restaurant by real local Italians. This place is to Italian food as…

2 Tomato

8. 2 Tomato

(724) 658-3380

207 E Long Ave
New Castle, PA 16101

This is an Italian restaurant that's food is like the sunshine in Florida lots of it and it is wonderful. Directed here by our favorite Italian …

Faraon Brothers

9. Faraon Brothers

(724) 654-6347

1015 S Mill St
New Castle, PA 16101

Mangino's Pizzeria

10. Mangino's Pizzeria

(724) 652-7621

106 N Liberty St
New Castle, PA 16102

User Avatar

Best pizza I've had in a long time. Moved to New Castle in November I'm glad I found a great pizza place close to home

Chuck Tanner's Restaurant

11. Chuck Tanner's Restaurant

(724) 658-5900

2305 Wilmington Rd
New Castle, PA 16105

This is the best place to eat liver and onions in the universe.. OK you don't like liver and onions? How about breakfast or lunch menu's????...…

Pizza Man's Pizza

12. Pizza Man's Pizza

(724) 658-0333

15 S Jefferson St
New Castle, PA 16101

Two Fat Guys and An Oven

13. Two Fat Guys and An Oven

(724) 202-6518

839 Moravia St
New Castle, PA 16101

Pizza Joe's

14. Pizza Joe's

(724) 658-1716

1203 N Croton Ave
New Castle, PA 16101

From Business: Here at Pizza Joe’s, we know there’s nothing quite like a fresh, hot and delicious pizza to satisfy your craving. When it’s shared with the important people in…

Tuscany Square Ristorante

15. Tuscany Square Ristorante

(724) 654-0365

3470 Wilmington Rd
New Castle, PA 16105

We had a bereavement dinner at Tuscany Square in February 2011 for about 35 guests. They presented an excellent buffet which was completely set up…

Medure's Catering

16. Medure's Catering

(724) 654-5465

2500 New Butler Rd
New Castle, PA 16101

From Business: Medure s Catering serves Lawrence, Mercer, Butler, Beaver and Allegheny counties in Pennsylvania. It is a full-service catering company that hosts weddings,…

2 Tomato

17. 2 Tomato

(724) 658-3380

2409 Wilmington Rd
New Castle, PA 16105

From Business: >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>…

R-Js Pizza

18. R-Js Pizza

(724) 498-5498

1101 Highland Ave
New Castle, PA 16105

From Business: Family Owned and Operated. We use a Stone Gas oven to ensure you get the right Crisp to the Crust!! We make every pizza as if it was for our own family!!

CR Brewing Company

19. CR Brewing Company

(724) 656-1553

3009 Wilmington Rd
New Castle, PA 16105

From Business: CR Brewing Company is a family owned and operated brewery. New Castle's Newest custom brewery!

Pastaking Catering

20. Pastaking Catering

(724) 654-8093

208 E Wallace Ave
New Castle, PA 16101

La Cucina Di Colucci Bakery

21. La Cucina Di Colucci Bakery

(724) 658-4441

3107 Wilmington Rd
New Castle, PA 16105

La Rocca's Pizza & Pasta

22. La Rocca's Pizza & Pasta

BBB Rating: A+
(330) 757-1212

6505 Clingan Rd
Youngstown, OH 44514

From Business: Poland, Ohio is a suburb of Youngstown, Ohio.

De Chellis Italian Cafe

23. De Chellis Italian Cafe

(330) 542-3733

11092 Main St
New Middletown, OH 44442

What a hidden surprise..staff is is excellent ...Friends from from Pittsburgh and NYC love it

Nico Luciano's

24. Nico Luciano's

(724) 752-1755

813 Woodside Ave
Ellwood City, PA 16117

User Avatar

I've been there about four times. The calzones are great and huge and only 7.00! You won't be disappointed.

Nicolinni's Ristorante

25. Nicolinni's Ristorante

(330) 259-3343

1247 Boardman Poland Rd Ste B
Youngstown, OH 44514


Best pasta bolognese in the area! I had Seabass with spinach and marinara sauce that was on special once and wish they would put it on the…

Combine Brothers Inc

26. Combine Brothers Inc

(724) 983-1057

2376 S Hermitage Rd
Hermitage, PA 16148

The food was phenomonal, the service was wonderful, it is easy to find and there are tons of leftovers!!! It was my first time hearing of the…

Cassese Mvr

27. Cassese Mvr

BBB Rating: A+
(330) 746-7067

410 N Walnut St
Youngstown, OH 44505

I totally found this place by accident! They have the best Italian food in a town that has an Italian restaurant on every street corner. Not just…

Inner Circle Pizza

28. Inner Circle Pizza

(330) 757-3719

1816 Boardman Poland Rd
Youngstown, OH 44514

User Avatar

Best dining experiance ever!Staff is very friendly and accommodating. Maybe a fee too many low cut tops for a family man, but if you dont have…

Caffe Capri Italian Bar & Grille

29. Caffe Capri Italian Bar & Grille

(330) 726-9900

8000 Market St
Youngstown, OH 44512

From Business: Caffe Capri Italian Bar & Grille, established in 2005, is a local, independent, family-owned and operated restaurant. It offers gift certificates of several…

Scarsella's Restaurant

30. Scarsella's Restaurant

(330) 788-0806

4151 Market St
Youngstown, OH 44512


You can’t get sauce anywhere like Scarsellas. Homemade and tastes great. Good prices! This should be your first stop! Family oriented. Great…

magnifying glass

Didn't find what you were looking for?
Please help others by helping us do better.

Suggest a Business