More Info

Extra Phones

Phone: (414) 258-1437

Payment method
no credit cards
Supreme Builders has various locations. They are located in Greenfield (Greenfield Park), Frankin, St. Francis, West Allis, Oconomowoc. Their Main Office is in West Allis located at 1491 S. 98th Street # 104


Hi there!
Rate this business!
First-classBetter than mostAbout what I expectedNot the worst...Disappointing
Click to Rate
Edited: 06/29/2017

SAVE YOUR TIME, MONEY, and many headaches-DO NOT RENT from Supreme Builders. They are rude, unhelpful, do NOT maintain their buildings and will walk in your apartment with NO prior notice and LIE that notice was given. Carpets are filthy, units aren't painted and carpets aren't cleaned good if at all in between tenants. Cigarette smoke PENETRATES your unit if your neighbors smoke as well as their dinners.
Carol, the office hench is nothing further than a complete bitter rude snot & that's being polite. She's nice when you come to sign the lease but other than that forget it-she won't help you with ANYTHING unless it comes to occupying the units she has for rent.
Kellie the daughter in law to Bob (married to Jonathan) is a lying sneak who will try to bully you to get what she needs. KNOW YOUR LEGAL RIGHTS and use them, if needed!
"Maintenance" which happens to be some of the BAIERL family WILL enter your unit without your knowledge or permission and then deny that they did so; they will also claim that you wouldn't allow them entrance; OR say that they gave prior notice when in all actuality THEY didn't. When you question them and that's when the bullying starts from Kellie (Kelly) Baierl. That don't work well w/me.
If something breaks or is supposed to be fixed don't HOLD YOU BREATH because it won't get fixed for weeks upon weeks upon weeks.
Sure the units are large and would be a GREAT place to live IF they were maintained and upkept but for the Greenfield Park ones where Monica & Felippe are in charge of on sight care, good luck with that. My apartment is infested with Boxelder bugs, Earwigs, Carpenter ants and I have a noisy neighbor with medical issues which causes him to bang against my walls and scream at the top of his longs ALL NIGHT LONG which means NO and I mean NO sleep for me.
Despite asking to get out of my lease, they won't allow it even though Kellie claims they don't "have to put up with tenants like me". Well, Supreme Builders, I gave you a FREE pass for entering my apartment once; NO more free passes from me.
Do it again, not just to me but to the worng person at the wrong time and you may be surprised at some point at what could be waitiing for you the next time you turn someones door knob the next time!
Bottom line is this; if you want to pay high rent to be a good locations but don't want any maintenance or clean UPGRADED MAINTAINED apartments (the appliances are from the 80's (oh did I mention the earwigs in my fridge too?), not to mention there's no ceiling fans just light fixtures from the 80's and the closets are bigger than the kitchen) -GREAT then this is the place for you!
If you're like me and want to get what you pay for, a quiet nights sleep, management that CARES, management that is on YOUR side and management that actually FIXES, maintains and does what it's supposed to do, save yourself the headaches, cigarette STENCH, nasty food cooking smells, the stress, the condesending tone from Carol the office hench, and SAVE YOUR MONEY find a nicer place, a cleaner place, a quiet caring place. This place is legitimately a money pit with flickering lights (oh did I mention two of their locations have had fires? One where people actually died becaue they couldn't get out) which may be due to an electrical issue (BUT AGAIN THEY DIDN'T care) that's why they have you sign a FIRE disclaimer upon lease signing.
Seriously people don't do it. They may be large but they are unkept; unreliable and disturbingly vendictive, IF you let them!

Edited: 06/29/2017


Smelly, filthy, cigarette burned carpet-worn out/faded carpet upon start of lease; unclean apartment upon moving in, certainly NOT painted between tenants even though supreme builders claimed it was. Took 4 weeks upon moving in to get the water to stop running even though it was running before I moved in (and not made aware), kitchen floor damaged and 6 months later-still not replaced, I too have a bug infestation but not the kind the health department acts on unfortunately. Management if that's what you want to call them; THEY DON'T CARE about you-AT ALL and will talk to you like you're the skum of the earth. Call there, see for yourself. Carol will most likey answer the phone. She's been running the main office in West Allis for 10+ years and acts like life is the most miserable thing there is. She is moody, rude, snotty and overly condescending. She acts like she should be bowed down to.
Maintenance; FUNNY....there is no maintenance on site unless you call the 'un'caretakers of the building maintenance and if they can't fix what's broken-low and behold get ready for the "work order" (did I mention my kitchen floor hasn't been fixed yet...6 months later-yeah that's what I mean by "work order"). Another HUGE issue; they WILL enter your apartment without prior notice and LIE and say notice was given. KNOW YOUR LEGAL RIGHTS. (P.S. They don't like when you know them either, that's when the fun begins from the Baierl family (Kellie especially), they have a MAJOR issue with you questioning anything they do. Bottom line THEY don't care about you.

The units, sure, they are large which is a bonus for the need for larger rooms/furniture or for roommate situations. The appliances are older, I can't even read the numbers for the temp settings on the stove. There are outdated light fixtures, possibly from the early 80's.
There is no ceiling fans in ANY room, the free heat is basically the DRY baseboard turn the dial 'heat'. The washer and dryer are the small & the stackable kind. The kitchen is SMALL and certainly not functional. AT ALL.
There's no storage room whether its in the kitchen or the hall closet (unless you use the bedroom closets or under beds for extra storage) and there is NO microwave either in the kitchen.
So, with all that said; if you like paying HIGH rents for a filthy apartment, cigarette stench that waffs in from your neighbors apartments, smelling their food cooking and hearing your neighbors SLAM the doors to the underground parking-THIS is this place for you! Oh before I forget, the underground parking is a nice perk, sure BUT the spaces are so small so either your neighbor will DENT your car or you'll hit the cement pilar. Unreal.
Trust me, you can find a BETTER place out there. STAY AWAY, FAR AWAY from Supreme Builders. You will avoid a nightmare, I promise you!

Robert G.



I have no idea where anyone else is coming from with all of them being 1 star reviews. Maybe it was based on which property they lived in and the issue was the on-site manager.

I lived in their Greenfield Park property from June 2001 to August 2011 and couldn't have been happier. Any issues I ever had were dealt with quickly and the one time they said they didn't receive my rent check they didn't charge me fees as clearly it had to be an issue with the mail (they gave me the benefit of the doubt). I'm back looking them up as I'm looking to move back to the Milwaukee area from Chicago. I lived in their 2 bedroom 1900 sq foot loft which I see is currently priced at $1140. Here in suburban Chicago I pay $1156 for a 2 bedroom 990 sq foot apt in a bad area with no underground parking.

They are a great deal and great people. Loved Kellie, Carol, and Johnnie

Review ImageReview Image
Lanita W.



I wish I would have read the reviews! God why me! Please I sign a year lease and lord knows I came from a Christian/ Baptist background! This was a lessoned learned! Never again! They are the true definition of dirty stallis!

Star J.
Edited: 11/03/2016

READ ALL COMMENTS! Very Unprofessional!

I wish I had read the reviews on this place before paying a $30 application fee for my spouse and I . The process of applying was horrible so I could only imagine what it would be like living there. My story is my BF and I applied and what was suppose to be a 2 day process took 2 weeks for a response. We called twice in a 2 week period and was told that the Manager had our applications. Come on now 2 weeks! For some reason people think that b/c you prefer to rent and not own you are stupid. That is neither here nor there. When Kellie finally called after 2 weeks to my better half ONLY, she stated that he was not qualified enough and there was an applicant who had a better credit score. Really.. Keep in mind she still has not contacted me. This was such a lie. My BF has 2 friends that stay in one of the properties closer to the NORTHSIDE that are felons and horrible credit. One had to pay a double security deposit before moving in. We didn't mention this b/c there wasn't a need. My dilemma is the property manager stated to us that no had showed interest in this particular building for sometime. Could that have changed of course. My theory is that Kellie held on to our application until someone else applied or until she realized she couldn't keep stringing us along. 1. We are African Americans applying for an apartment in a predominantly Caucasian and other race area outside of our color 2. We have a child and no one else in the building has children. So maybe Kellie thought we would tear the place up, play loud music, have our homies running in and out all day or leave dirty diapers laying around like you see in hood. LOL But after reading all the reviews the place sounds like a zoo. Thank you Kellie for saving us from living in you and your family's establishment. If we wanted to see animals we have the Milwaukee County Zoo for that. We don't do unwanted pets, unprofessional/racist people that feel we don't belong in a certain area. Btw Conceal and Carry is real. You may want to think about that before you send someone in a place and they are not expected. Some of us colored folks do know more rights than you think. Best of luck to the next people that apply or rent from these people.

Liliana L.
Edited: 11/03/2016

one day the water heater leak and the carpet was disgusting because all the dirty water the water heater spilled on it, instead of washing the carpet the same day they leave and don’t tell me anything about why they aren’t taking care of it the same day. I have kids in the apartment obviously is not safe for my kids to step on that kind of liquid. Yet next morning at 8am while I was sleeping I hear a Knock JUST ONE KNOCK!!! And a bunch of guys enter my apartment!!! I totally freak out since I was in my pajamas and my daughter was in a towel only because she had gotten out the shower! They still trying to walk next to me and I yelled to get out of my apartment and they were refusing because they said they had approval for the owner to come in! What kind of BS was that! I didn’t care and told them if they didn’t get out I was going to call the police. The owner just don’t care at all about his tenant and my privacy.

Disgusting Hallways smelling like pot! ghetto!

Nicole F.



I had the worst rental experience ever with this company! They were very, very rude and unprofessional even refusing to provide me with the owner's information! I left my information and never received a callback! Upon vacating I cleaned the apartment meticulously and still had 345.00 of my security deposit wrongly taken! I took pictures and will be taking them to court soon! Do not rent from these people, you will regret it!

Constance L.


Do NOT Rent!

I wish there was a half star so I could give them it! I also wish I would have searched reviews for them before I moved in! Supreme Builders is the absolute WORST place I have rented from and I haven't rented from anyone else! Mice, roaches, and multiple electrical issues is all I have to say! Never before had roaches and we saw not one but 2-3 when we first moved in! The moaner told us the ONLY way we would get extermination is if we found one and brought it in! Terrible! We saw mice and the manager Paul lied right to our face, pretty much called us and our spotless apartment dirty, and claimed they never had them. The other manager then preceded to tell us that they actually did have mice as well in the other building. My cousin and I even saw one in the hallway once! Place was absolutely disgusting! It didn't help that we also had electricity problems and our room lights went out but no other lights did and Paul had the nerve to ask why we were up so late! They are truly pathetic and they do not care at all! Carol is very rude and hung up on me when I wanted to ask her a question on the phone! Even though we've moved they still are causing problems, $800 for a LINOLEUM counter and replacement of an already old rarely used stovetop for "excessive blackness". Like I said they're pathetic, I tried my hardest to be nice, but they're no worth the money you will pay!

Christine B.



Renting here is one of the worst mistakes anyone can make worst management in the world!!!! The have barely any parking that they dont charge for an one visitor section for visitors. Which is a joke !!! My sister park there in the day time and almost got her car towed!!! I parked there one night out of desperation and got a ticket...the police office was way more helpful and caring of my situation then the management and said they will clean it up if SB would write a letter saying it would be ok to amend the ticket they wouldn't even do gave the worst attitude in the world!!!



Renting here is one of the wor...

Renting here is one of the worst mistakes I've made. The managing staff is very unprofessional. Without notice, one of the staff members came into my house. I was in my underwear. I've asked for assistance, with rodents, only to get inconsistent and rude responses. The receptionist will not allow you to speak with anyone else. I've asked to speak with the owner numerous times. Although I have two parking spaces I'm only allowed to use one. Please save yourself the stress and trouble and rent elsewhere.



BEWARE: Please save yourself t...

BEWARE: Please save yourself the trouble of renting from Supreme Builders. The staff is unprofessional and incompetent. Whenever there is an issue the staff is very short with me and do not care if the issue is resolved or not. I’ve had to deal with an infestation on ants and insects; which the staff said is my problem to deal with. There are dead mice around the complex. When I had an issue with my washer/dryer it took them 1 month to fix. They also tried to keep a portion of my security deposit due to the carpet being unclean. However, I had the carpet cleaned prior to leaving. RENT AT YOUR OWN RISK.



Very unprofessional staff. Th...

Very unprofessional staff. They are very short and unwilling to help. I heard them refer to someone as a racial slur and consistently use the word. I asked them to stop using word because it offended me. They laughed. There is an ant and rodent infestation.



The office staff is very unpro...

The office staff is very unprofessional and unfriendly. When I call, I have to ask whom I’m speaking to because they do not state their names. They are often impatient and short on the phone. There are various issues in the apartment that I didn’t notice before signing the lease; including a bug infestation, mice, poorly working washer & dryer, a toilet that does not flush properly, and more. They have entered my apartment, for maintenance, without giving a prior notice. Although, they said they gave a notice which I didn’t receive. When requesting maintenance it takes weeks to get a response. I’ve had to follow-up with them on maintenance requests, because they have not followed up with me. Please refrain from renting from Supreme Builders. You will say yourself a lot of stress and time.


Phone: (414) 774-1491

Address: 1491 S 98th St Ste 104, Milwaukee, WI 53214


People Also Viewed