In mybook® Food Collection (edit)

Added to your food collection.
Removed from mybook!

We took this business out of your food collection.

General Info
* For Special Occasions We Do Cookie And Pastry Trays * We Will Ship Anywhere In The U.S. Welcome to our website! At Peter Sciortino's Bakery, we make all of our products from scratch on a daily basis to ensure that our customers receive the freshest baked goods in Milwaukee. Peter Sciortino's Bakery takes enormaous pride in quality, service and of course,the tast of our products. From our amzingly fresh breads to our delicious Italian pastries, we assure you will not find a fresher or better tasting backery in the Greater Milwaukee area!
BBB Rating
BBB Rating and Accreditation information may be delayed up to a week.

Regular Hours

Extra Phones

Fax: (414) 272-1456

**Our Specialties Are:** * Italian And French Bread * Specialty Tea Cookies * Cannoli-Both Chocolate And Original **Italian Pastries Such As:** * Tiramisu * Sfogliatelle * Pastacciotti * Small Cassata Cakes * Breads * Rolls * Cookies * Cookie and Pastry Trays for Special * Occasions * We Ship Anywhere in the United States
Payment method
all major credit cards
Price Range
Milwaukee's East Side We are located conveniently on the corrner of Humboldt Avenuee and Brady Street.
Lower East Side
Social Links
Dessert Restaurants, Food Products, Bakeries, Cookies & Crackers, Wedding Supplies & Services, Wholesale Bakeries, Cookies & Crackers-Wholesale & Manufacturers
Other Information

Parking: Street

Bike Parking: Yes

Cuisines: Dessert, Bakeries

Cuisine: Mediterranean, Italian, European, Ice Cream, Pastries

Price Range : Below Average



No coupons available


Hi there!
Rate this business!
First-classBetter than mostAbout what I expectedNot the worst...Disappointing
Click to Rate
Share Review

Like this review? Share it on your social network to get the word out!

Karri L.


Yummy Cookies & Pastries

They make the best pastries I've ever had!!! You need to get there early though because they sell out fast or call and order ahead and they'll make them for you.They also have a large choice of tasty cookies.



Provided by Citysearch - 
Not what we expected

My husband and I love to find ethinic and gourmet food shops when visiting other cities. On a recent visit to Milwaukee, we stopped in Peter Sciortino's Bakery on Brady Street -- a very disappointing experience. We especially love mom and pop bakeries as my my husband's grandfather owned a bakery business in Cincinnati for nearly 50 years.

Peter Sciortino's was advertised as an one of the best known Italian bakeries in Milwaukee but does not even bake ciabatta bread. Even though we arrived early, less than an hour after the bakery opened, the few loaves of bread on the shelf looked as if it they were baked by the local IGA grocery store, not an ethnic bakery.

Upon entering, we were hoping for the smell of fresh bread, but instead found the bakery to smell like an old donut shop. Although we planned to purchased cookies and cannolis to take home to our daughter, we left without purchasing anything as the older woman behind the counter was extremely rude and gave the impression that her customers were more of a bother than anything.



Provided by Citysearch - 
Service with an attitude

Good cookies, though if I am charged $8.95 per pound or any price for that matter, I would expect that the sales lady who just gave the previous customer their change back not pick up each cookie that I choose with their bare hands.

That is ridiculous and I wish I had said something...

Their salespeople have a tendancy to cop an attitude like they're doing you (the customer) a favor..

Not planning on going back..can only imagine what happens if a cookie is dropped...does it get placed back on the shelf?



Wonderful Bakery

The absolute best hard rolls in town. Unique Italian pastries are the specialty here. I have been coming here for years on Sundays and have never been disappointed.



Excellent, Excellent, Excellent

Sciortino's provided pastries for a pastry table at our daughters wedding. We have been long time shoppers as Sciortino's, but, this was exceptional. The staff was very helpful in choosing the pastries and cookies. They also arranged the trays beautifully. It was a big hit. Everyone commented on how delicious everything was. Of course, I knew it would be. Thank you Sciortino's, for helping to make our daughters wedding special.



Provided by Citysearch - 
Best Pastries EVER!

When I lived in Madison, I used to plan trips to Milwaukee so I could visit Brady Street for this bakery and a side trip to Glorioso's deli. Their bread is perfect - crusty outside, tender inside. They have these wonderful lemon pastries that are made with hundreds of layers of flaky layers of phyllo dough and a lemon creme.

I've never experienced poor service - it's a popular place, and the staff is busy, but I've always been treated promptly and personably by their staff.



Provided by Citysearch - 
Over rated place

After reading the two reader reviews, I would have to side more with the first guy. The second reader review guy needs to get up to that place in Menomonee Falls and check out better bread, better prices, and last but not least, people that wait on you that don't act like their doing you a favor!



Provided by Citysearch - 

after having lived in many italian city's, and worked in bakeries, i would have to say that sciortino's has top quality product, and the people there know quality. i must add i was also every pleased with the sevice even though the store was gammed pack with loyal customers. great product, every clean!!! keep up the good work.