Tux selection is good. Fitting is fine. Friendly enough. One beef: the business hours the staff actually open the store are very different from what are posted on the building and on the web. You can take your chances and maybe find someone working. Maybe not. Not the way most owners would choose to treat the customers!
I have rented from Elite Tuxedos twice now and both times were horrible. In both instances the fittings were way off and much too large, I would strongly suggest going anywhere else than here. You would be better of getting buying from a second hand store.