Pizza Places in Lancaster, OH
i
About Search Results

YP - The Real Yellow PagesSM - helps you find the right local businesses to meet your specific needs. Search results are sorted by a combination of factors to give you a set of choices in response to your search criteria. These factors are similar to those you might use to determine which business to select from a local Yellow Pages directory, including proximity to where you are searching, expertise in the specific services or products you need, and comprehensive business information to help evaluate a business's suitability for you. “Preferred” listings, or those with featured website buttons, indicate YP advertisers who directly provide information about their businesses to help consumers make more informed buying decisions. YP advertisers receive higher placement in the default ordering of search results and may appear in sponsored listings on the top, side, or bottom of the search results page.

Fat Cat Pizza
(740) 652-1111

1448 Ety Pointe Dr NW
Lancaster
OH 43130

This has always been my favorite pizza place even after moving out of town. Bummed that the old west location shut down but the new ety road is real…

Domino's Pizza
(740) 654-1300

620 N Memorial Dr
Lancaster
OH 43130

Get deals. Lots of pizza for your money. This is what I order when I want just pizza and lots of it!

Papa John's Pizza
(740) 653-1555

728 N Memorial Dr
Lancaster
OH 43130

Tasty pizza for a large chain store. Price was fair with pick up and coupon. Staff didn't really appear to like there job but they appeared to be yo…

Original Tiberios
(740) 654-2317

2610 N Columbus St
Lancaster
OH 43130

If your looking for real Italian food then your going to the right place.

Fat Cat Pizza
(740) 652-9240

1415 Sheridan Dr
Lancaster
OH 43130

Pizza Hut
(740) 653-3050

632 N Memorial Dr
Lancaster
OH 43130

From Business: Get oven-hot pizza, fast from your local Pizza Hut in Lancaster. Enjoy favorites like Original Pan Pizza, Breadsticks, WingStreet Wings, Hershey's Chocolate Chip …

Cristy's Pizza
(740) 653-8106

914 N Pierce Ave
Lancaster
OH 43130

Excellent Pizza or try a Calzone. They have a new building with a drive thru. You don't even have to get out of the car.

Massey's Pizza Subs & Salads
(740) 653-6666

1229 N Memorial Dr
Lancaster
OH 43130

From Business: Local pizzeria chain serving wide range of pies (including famed pepperoni), subs, salads & more.

Diamond Jim's Pizza Downtown
(740) 681-1701

111 N Columbus St
Lancaster
OH 43130

Jenny's Pizza
(740) 808-8423

358 Lincoln Ave
Lancaster
OH 43130

From Business: Jenny's is a carry-out & pizza delivery in Lancaster, Ohio restaurant. Offering pizza, 8" & 16" subs, chicken wings, salads and more.

Wisecarver Pizza
(740) 422-8711

620 N Memorial Dr
Lancaster
OH 43130

Diamond Jims Pizza Downtown
(740) 974-6060

1154 Forest Rose Ave
Lancaster
OH 43130

Cedar Hill Pizza and Subs
(740) 654-5949

1403 Cedar Hill Rd
Lancaster
OH 43130

Rudy's Pizza & Subs
(740) 400-4438

1458 N Columbus St
Lancaster
OH 43130

Pizza Express
(740) 689-8006

1649 E Main St
Lancaster
OH 43130

Franco's Pizza
(740) 422-8533

1635 River Valley Cir S
Lancaster
OH 43130

Osteria Alla Romana
(740) 785-9154

1453 Tiki Ln
Lancaster
OH 43130

LL Pizza Co
(740) 652-9410

925 Ety Rd NW
Lancaster
OH 43130

Pizza Crossing
(740) 687-1860

4235 Mud House Rd NE
Lancaster
OH 43130

Nick's Restaurant
(740) 653-3268

702 W Wheeling St
Lancaster
OH 43130

Nick's is a small family owned restaurant located on the west side of town across form old bill baileys. As soon as you walk in the door the place f…

Massey's Pizza
(740) 653-6633

1358 Ety Rd NW
Lancaster
OH 43130

I used to get Massey's Pizza when I was growing up in Columbus. When I moved to Lancaster I missed it! Oh not anymore it's in Lancaster now. They ha…

Donatos Pizza
(740) 653-7772

765 E Main St
Lancaster
OH 43130

From Business: Established in 1963, Donatos is a family-owned and operated chain of restaurants that offers a variety of pizzas. The chain operates more than 200 stores in over …

Italian House
(740) 654-6741

182 E 6th Ave
Lancaster
OH 43130

great taste, great price

Cristy's Pizza
(740) 687-0770

1436 Tiki Ln
Lancaster
OH 43130

This is GOOD pizza. They have excellent pizza. I just can't say enough about how good it is. I have an idea, try it!

Little Caesars Pizza
(740) 681-1877

841 N Memorial Dr
Lancaster
OH 43130

Holy Crap! The old saying you get what you pay for definitely applies here. Ordered on of the "Hot and Ready" pizzas and let me tell you i…

Roxy's Pizza
(740) 746-8922

5840 Old Logan Rd SE
Lancaster
OH 43130

Pizza Cottage
(740) 654-2400

2223 W Fair Ave
Lancaster
OH 43130

The best Pizza! We used to Drive to Buckeye Lake which is about 20 or so minutes away from Lancaster to eat at the Pizza Cottage. Thank goodness we …

magnifying glass

Didn't find what you were looking for?
Please help others by helping us do better.

Suggest a Business
Helpful Reviews 
Donatos Pizza
Robert M. rated

Was a semi-frequent customer until today. Placed an order last week in the middle of the afternoon, they were not busy. They said 15 minutes for pickup, I showed up 15-20 minutes after I ordered and I paid. I proceeded to wait 15-20 additional minutes to receive my food. The person working there says that they credited my account for the food. (Not my credit card I paid cash) I tell them that it was no problem waiting but I appreciate them doing that. Get my food home and it's cold, fully cooked just no longer hot. This leaves me wondering what they were doing with it for 15-20 minutes extra? But I'm thinking it's free so I just warmed it up in the microwave. Today I decide to try them again, planned on using my credit towards ordering a few pizzas for people watching the osu game. Person on the phone says there is no record of this happening or any credit on my account.... Maybe I just got unlucky, but it seems there is a pattern of people not knowing what is going on there, leading to poor customer service. Needless to say I ordered elsewhere, going to avoid donatos, at least this location, for a long time.

Papa John's Pizza
Irene K. rated

Lousy service and no customer service... Ordered pizza online early in the day for delivery in the evening. We called when the pizza was 15 minutes late - got put on hold 3 times and then told they were behind but our pizza was on the way. We live less than a mile from the restaurant The lukewarm pizza arrived 30 minutes later. No apology. We complained to Papa Johns and they said the owner/operator would be in touch shortly - that was a week ago.

Original Tiberios
stivi.nechovski.5 rated
Great food, and lushanas dressing is the bomb dot com...

If your looking for real Italian food then your going to the right place.

Domino's Pizza
cecelia.root rated
My goodness I don't know what ...

My goodness I don't know what you have done but my pizza was eatiable but not as good as in the past and I have been a regular customer for awhile and I think you all are using cheaper ingredients. Cutting corners? WOW I don't think I will order again. Guess I will have to shop around.