Italian Restaurants in Lancaster, OH

About Search Results

YP - The Real Yellow PagesSM - helps you find the right local businesses to meet your specific needs. Search results are sorted by a combination of factors to give you a set of choices in response to your search criteria. These factors are similar to those you might use to determine which business to select from a local Yellow Pages directory, including proximity to where you are searching, expertise in the specific services or products you need, and comprehensive business information to help evaluate a business's suitability for you. “Preferred” listings, or those with featured website buttons, indicate YP advertisers who directly provide information about their businesses to help consumers make more informed buying decisions. YP advertisers receive higher placement in the default ordering of search results and may appear in sponsored listings on the top, side, or bottom of the search results page.

Italian House Pizza Subs

1. Italian House Pizza Subs

(740) 654-6741

182 E 6th Ave
Lancaster, OH 43130

great taste, great price

Massey's Pizza

2. Massey's Pizza

(740) 653-6633

1358 Ety Rd NW
Lancaster, OH 43130

I used to get Massey's Pizza when I was growing up in Columbus. When I moved to Lancaster I missed it! Oh not anymore it's in Lancaster now. They…

Jenny's Pizza

3. Jenny's Pizza

(740) 808-8423

358 Lincoln Ave
Lancaster, OH 43130

From Business: Jenny's is a carry-out & pizza delivery in Lancaster, Ohio restaurant. Offering pizza, 8" & 16" subs, chicken wings, salads and more.

Osteria Alla Romana

4. Osteria Alla Romana

(740) 785-9154

1453 Tiki Ln
Lancaster, OH 43130

Sugar Bears Pizzeria

5. Sugar Bears Pizzeria

(740) 689-1717

147 Cedar Hill Rd
Lancaster, OH 43130

From Business: *Smoke-Free Environment *Dine-In - Take-Out - Delivery

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

6. Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

(740) 687-4409

2093 Schorrway Dr NW
Lancaster, OH 43130

The Olive Garden will forever be my favorite Italian Restaurant. I love the crisp salad served at the table with unlimited refills. I've ordered…

Fat Cat Pizza

7. Fat Cat Pizza

(740) 652-1111

1448 Ety Pointe Dr NW
Lancaster, OH 43130

This has always been my favorite pizza place even after moving out of town. Bummed that the old west location shut down but the new ety road is…

Massey's Pizza

8. Massey's Pizza

(740) 653-6666

1229 N Memorial Dr
Lancaster, OH 43130

Finally got to try this pizza yesterday and it was the best!!! Excellent!!!


9. Rome116

(740) 785-5518

1348 Ety Rd NW
Lancaster, OH 43130

Great selection of fresh pastas, phenomenal pizzas, and amazing desserts. Rome 116 sources locally and uses incredibly fresh, quality ingredients.…

Red Lobster

10. Red Lobster

(740) 681-9433

1515 River Valley Cir N
Lancaster, OH 43130

A great Sitdown Dinner with nice atmosphere. It's always good but, not much new. Maybe the fare doesn't lend itself to new exciting recipes. …

Mediterranean on 33

11. Mediterranean on 33

(740) 654-8237

1147 N Memorial Dr
Lancaster, OH 43130


My family has been a long time loyal customer to Mediterranean on 33 for years but after our experience today we will never be back. I have never…

Diamond Jims Pizza Downtown

12. Diamond Jims Pizza Downtown

(740) 974-6060

1154 Forest Rose Ave
Lancaster, OH 43130


13. Sbarro

(740) 654-9809

1635 River Valley Cir S Ste 5009
Lancaster, OH 43130

Pacer's Italian Cuisine

14. Pacer's Italian Cuisine

(740) 468-9207

111 S Main St
Pleasantville, OH 43148

if this place was in Pickerington it would be a huge success but then again, maybe it works b/c it is where it is

Anthony's Italian Restaurant

15. Anthony's Italian Restaurant

(740) 743-1522

107 E Main St
Somerset, OH 43783

From Business: Anthony's We have a Pizza Pasta Sub & Salad Buffet $6.95 Wednesday 5:00 pm to 8:00 pm Friday & Sunday 11:00 am to 2:00 pm We offer Delivery & Pickup as well as a…

Omezzo Restaurant & Pizzeria

17. Omezzo Restaurant & Pizzeria

(614) 866-7606

1755 Hill Rd N
Pickerington, OH 43147

I've been coming here since right after it opened. The owner, the staff, the food, all amazing! Super clean. I can't say enough great things about…

Pizzeria New York

18. Pizzeria New York

(614) 862-4743

833 Hill Rd N
Pickerington, OH 43147

My family loves New York Pizziaria for the stone cooked pizza, great atmosphere, and friendly service.

Cristy's Pizza

19. Cristy's Pizza

(740) 862-6611

1001 S Main St
Baltimore, OH 43105

I did a review on Papa Boos, whos restaurant side is ran by Cristy's, but this is one of their actual restaurants. The pie is very good, as are the…

Shirky's Pizza Zone

20. Shirky's Pizza Zone

(740) 756-9663

70 E Canal St
Carroll, OH 43112

The latest management of the pizza place at the heart of Carroll has made changes for the better. The pizza crust is just right with lightly…

Pizza Ria's Too

21. Pizza Ria's Too

(740) 862-5969

2330 Main St
Thurston, OH 43157

Owners are very friendly. Pizza is good. Meatball subs are great, but i usually get extra meatballs.

Tommy Wayne's Pizza

22. Tommy Wayne's Pizza

(740) 969-4969

5805 Chillicothe Lancaster Rd SW
Amanda, OH 43102

King's Grand Central

23. King's Grand Central

(740) 240-1044

8340 Main St
Rushville, OH 43150

Arlington Pizza Pasta Steak

24. Arlington Pizza Pasta Steak

(740) 400-4438

949 S Main St
Baltimore, OH 43105

Was the best pizza I've had in a long while. Delivery was fast and friendly. Would recommend and will buy again.

Pizza Crossing

25. Pizza Crossing

(740) 385-8558

58 N Mulberry St
Logan, OH 43138

Best pizza in town! We're from Columbus and drive here for the pizza! I'm addicted! Stop by and try it sometime :)

Cardo's Pizza & Tavern

26. Cardo's Pizza & Tavern

(614) 834-8101

7897 Refugee Rd
Pickerington, OH 43147


Great pizza, awesome staff and a great selection of craft beers. Family absolutely loves eating here! The wings with Cardos Sauce are delicious. …

Domino's Pizza

27. Domino's Pizza

(614) 837-2220

1027 Hill Rd N
Pickerington, OH 43147

I drive from Powell to Pickerington to get this pizza. The food is fantastic and the people are very friendly.

Cristy's Pizza

28. Cristy's Pizza

(740) 380-1901

1320 W Hunter St
Logan, OH 43138

Fantastic pizza and subs!!!

Pizza Cottage

29. Pizza Cottage

(740) 928-1144

4592 Walnut Rd
Buckeye Lake, OH 43008

Had a really GREA Italian salad and the thin crust pepperoni pizza had fresh baked flavor and lots of topping. Will be back when in area.

Taranto's Pizza Barn

30. Taranto's Pizza Barn

(614) 837-6555

601 Hill Rd N
Pickerington, OH 43147


Great pizza at the right price will be back.

magnifying glass

Didn't find what you were looking for?
Please help others by helping us do better.

Suggest a Business