2140 N Mitthoeffer Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46229
My husband told me about "Just Pizza" when I was telling him how unhappy I was with Pappa John's & Pizza Hut's meat lovers. I mean really, where is the meat???? Just Pizza is the only place I or my family will ever buy from again. I have no idea why we would go anyplace else. If Just Pizza close every location, we will just not eat pizza anymore. There would be no point.
My boyfriend ranted and raved about this place's pizza. His buddy would bring it into work and share it.
So today my boyfriend decides to pick some up fro dinner, and it was AWFUL!
He says it it usually much better, but my first impression was nothing close to being good.
The pizza was overcooked, the crust was chewy and dry, and the pepperoni pizza we got was barely edible due to the excessive amount of grease that puddled on top of it... It tasted burnt as well.
I don't see how it could get anywhere near the high praise he had given it, but I sure hope for the sake of this pizza place that my first experience was a rare fluke and that maybe there was a new guy back there or something.
I don't normally judge a place by my first experience, but I was surprised that even my boyfriend who had praised it so much couldn't even finish all of his slices. If you know my boyfriend you know how bad it must have been. Needless to say we ended up throwing the rest away, and we had two large ones! The kids didn't like it much either. Although they loved the cheese sauce.
I only rated it a 2 since my boyfriend swears it usually tasted very good. I will try it again someday, but for now... I will keep my distance.
I had the steak dinner from there and ir was GREAT!!!!!! It was so good I had to order something else the next day, so I tried the taco salad with chicken and it was FAB!!!! I got a lot for my money and it was very much worth it! I live on the other side of town and I will travel from the far west to the far east for that food!!! It is GREAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Great service everytime I called!!!