Find a business

        (223) 212-0036CallVisit WebsiteVisit WebsiteMap & DirectionsDirections823 Newville RdCarlisle, PA 17013Write a ReviewWrite Review

        Menu

        Appetizers
        • Soup Of The Day
          fresh choices made daily
          $2.95
        • Baked French Onion
          $3.25
        • Tavern Stuffed Mushrooms
          tavern stuffed mushrooms with crab imperial
          $5.95
        Salads
        • Rustic Tossed
          topped with tomatoes, green peppers, cucumbers and onions served in our own sun-dried tomato and basil bowl
          $4.95
        • Crisp Caesar Salad
          topped with croutons and grated romano cheese served in our own sun-dried tomato and basil bowl
          $4.95
        • House Greek Salad
          topped with pepperocini, tomatoes, olives, green peppers, onions and feta cheese all served in our own sun-dried tomato and basil bowl
          $5.95
        Fresh Seafood
        • Broiled Haddock
          fresh, broiled with light butter. (includes a choice of two side dishes)
          $10.95
        • Rustic Crab Cakes
          in house specialty (includes a choice of two side dishes)
          $10.95
        • House Battered Shrimp
          our house battered shrimp. served with cocktail sauce (includes a choice of two side dishes)
          $10.95
        View Full Menu
        Provided by
        Partner Logo

        Reviews

        Hi there!
        Rate this business!
        What do you rate this business?First-classBetter than mostAbout what I expectedNot the worst...Disappointing
        Click to Rate
        JH
        John H.

        03/01/2023

        Overall
        Food
        Service

        Food and service is great
        The owner worked for me many years ago

        Helpful(0)Flag
        KD
        Kari D.

        08/17/2016

        Overall
        Ambiance
        Food
        Service

        The service ruined our night! The waitress wasn't happy we didn't order expensive meals and practically pushed us out the door.

        Helpful(0)Flag

        Details

        Phone: (223) 212-0036

        Address: 823 Newville Rd, Carlisle, PA 17013

        Website: https://rustictavern.com

        More Info

        Best in casual, fine dining in a relaxed atmosphere.

        Contact us today
        General Info
        Located in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, the Rustic Tavern is a successful mix of a casual atmosphere with the added touch of fine dining. Relax with friends and family by the fireplace or on the deck. Proprietors Tom (chef) and Penny Petsinis offer a wide variety of menu items utilizing local produce, meats and other products as well as weekly fresh seafood specials. In addition, the Rustic boasts a wide variety of wines and spirits. We look forward to providing you with a memorable dining experience, and remember “It’s all good!”
        Email
        Services/Products
        Take Out Available, Fine Dining & Tavern Dining, Lunch Menu Available, Outdoor Patio, Indoor & Outdoor Eating Outdoor Patio, Banquet Facility, Freshest Seafood, Seafood & Pasta, Daily Specials, Steak Seafood & Pasta, Mixed Grille, Salads, Steak, Fresh Seafood, Prime Steaks Chicken Pasta, Sandwiches.
        Brands
        Daily Specials
        Payment method
        amex, discover, visa, mastercard, cash
        Price Range
        $$
        Languages
        Greek
        Other Link

        https://rustictavern.com

        Social Links
        Categories
        Wine Bars, Bars, Restaurants
        Other Information

        Parking: Private, Free

        Specialties: Rehearsal Dinner;Weddings;Cocktail Parties;Business Meetings;Wedding events;Private Parties;Banquets;Anniversaries;Banquets;Anniversaries;Business Meetings;Rehearsal Dinners;Anniversaries;Banquets;Cocktail Parties;Wedding Events;Business Meetings;Rehearsal Dinners;Cocktail Parties;Private Parties;Private Parties