Saved to Favorites


Hi there!
Rate this business!
First-classBetter than mostAbout what I expectedNot the worst...Disappointing
Click to Rate
Edited: 09/12/2021
Don't waste your time or money...

Don't waste your time or money, the food was disgracefully prepared.
The filet was absolutely tasteless, chewey and cooked improperly.
The so called crab bisque was thick and pastey with absolutely not a glimmer of crab or flavour. I've had better coming out of a can, yuk!!
The service was appauling, the soup was served with a spoon hanging out of it, there was no bucket for the crab shell.
No one ever came back to the table to see if we needed anything.
The so called manager/owner was indignate and didn't even apologize for our discontent but instead held firm to an attitude of non discript care.
There are so many really wonderful dinner houses in Buffalo that so far surpass the Scotch N Sirloin that I can not understand what keeps them in business.

Monique S.



A fantastic bar to have a beer and unwind. I love it here! I just stumbled upon this bar a little while ago.



Every thing is well seasoned a...

Every thing is well seasoned and delicious from their appetizers to the main dishes. My mouth is watering just thinking of their food.



Provided by Citysearch

On a restaurant strip where lot's of places come and go. To my understanding the Scotch has been around forever because of the quality of their steaks. My friend suggested this place for our party. It was a little pricey but the food was so worth it, picture perfect. The salad bar was very fresh and had lot's of choices including fresh pumpernickel bread, my favorite. The party that I was with really enjoyed themselves, maybe a little too much. We moved the party to the bar area after dinner and it was busy with a mixed crowd of people and some cute waitresses!!



Provided by Citysearch
Never Again

My wife and I recently had a better than mediocre meal at the Scotch N Sirloin, although you can definitly do better elsewhere both on price and quality.
What torqued me off is this: the two times we have been there this year we were overcharged for items we never ordered or received. Both times! Each overcharge was $7.00 to $8.00. Just small enough to hopefully not be noticed but large enough to add up to some serious dough if done consistantly to numerous customers.
We eat out several times a week in lots of places and have encountered this little ""mistake"" a few times before.
Never once has the mistake been in our favor (undercharged) Always the error favors the house.
Coincidence?? I really suspect not.
When I brought this to the manager's attention he was apologetic and seemed truly concerned.

However, we don't need this kind of issue when trying to have a relaxing night out. With so many other excellent restaurants to choose from in the area we will skip the Scotch N Sirloin for forever with no tears shed.



Provided by Citysearch
Poor quality

Recently ate here for the first and last time. The decor has all the charm of a soup kitchen, and I'd guess the food quality is similar. The salad bar is laughable, they obviously haven't put a dime back into this place. Frequented by very old people who probably don't know much better. I implore you, don't make a mistake by going here, it's very expensive considering the very poor quality.



Provided by Citysearch
Disappointment All Around

Seated 75 minutes after being told the wait was 30 - 45 minutes. The service was dismal. Obvious signs that we wanted something (closed menu, arms crossed, the look of Hey!! Over here!) seemed lost on the waitress. We had to ask for everything and all requests required a wait. Steaks were mediocre. Pricey for what we got. Undercooked to start. Then re-cooked to black on the outside and still undercooked inside. Service was lacking overall. Gross misjudgment by the hostess. Waitress overloaded with 2 large groups plus 4 5 additional tables- she never had a chance. The restaurant seems uncertain as to what it wants to be. Blue-jean oriented in the bar, with peanut shells on the floor, but pricing that causes one to choke. Do one or the other, but not both. Its not working. Hire more wait staff help and a hostess who can estimate time.



Provided by Citysearch

The Scotch n Sirloin is a consistently excellent meal. The casual atmosphere and superb food make it a restaurant my husband and I go to a few times a month. Highly recommend!



Provided by Citysearch
Good, but not #1

This is a good restaurant, the service can be cold and not very helpful. The salad bar is fresh but ordinary, and boring. Last time we were there we were crushed between the wall and a large, very loud party of 15.
The steaks are good but the last 2 times I had to send mine back because of the doneness being wrong.



Provided by Citysearch

This was our second time here, and we weren't disappointed! Our server lacked personality skills, but the food was great. A friend of mine from work also recently informed me that their Happy Hour is awesome (FREE wings & great deals).



Provided by Citysearch

great food & great salad bar great time all around



Provided by Citysearch
MMM, beef

Scotch has the best steak I have ever tasted! It is tender and can be torn apart with just your fork. The atmosphere adds to the genuinely delightful meal.



Provided by Citysearch
Scotch 'n Sirloin Scorches!

Scotch 'n Sirloin is everything a great steakhouse should be - full of wood, excellent service, and yummy steaks! They're even in the Entertainment book!



Provided by Citysearch
like being at home

Last review dated 12/02. Have been back a number of times since. Still the same; ""GREAT""!! Prices are reasonable compared to the ""elite"" steakhouses in the area and reservations are needed for Friday & Saturday or do expect a 60-90 min. wait, but while waiting head for the bar area and relax.

Not many places offer a salad bar anymore; I happen to like creating my own salad and not have some person in the back putting together a non-descript combo of whatever.

Last visit was Mothers Day with my wife, daughters and son-in-law, asked for Kevin and he came out to greet us even though the place was very busy and he was working the grill even though he is now one the owners.

Still a good value when it comes to steakhouses in Buffalo.



Provided by Citysearch
Nicely Done

A nicely done atmosphere greats you as you stroll through the main entrance. If you haven't been here before you are in for a treat.


Phone: (716) 837-4900

Address: 3999 Maple Rd, Buffalo, NY 14226


More Info

General Info
Founded in 1969, Scotch 'N Sirloin is a fine dining restaurant that serves a variety of food items for lunch and dinner. Its menu includes top sirloin steak, filet mignon, fish, salmon, scallops, prime rib, crab legs, pork chops, french fries, fried shrimp, beef kebobs and lobster tails. The restaurant also serves marinated chicken breast, French onion soup, shrimp cocktail and stuffed mushrooms. Scotch 'N Sirloin offers a children's menu that includes chicken fingers, hamburgers and hot dogs. It maintains a banquet that can accommodate up to 60 guests for business functions, holiday and birthday parties, wedding rehearsal dinners and anniversaries. Additionally, the restaurant features a lounge and organizes a range of entertainment shows. Scotch 'N Sirloin is located in Amherst, N.Y.
Extra Phones

Phone: (716) 837-0987

Phone: (716) 261-9809

Fax: (716) 837-0987

Payment method
all major credit cards
Price Range

Dba Scotch N Sirloin

Other Information

Parking: Lot, Free

Bike Parking: Yes

Wheelchair Accessible: Yes

Cuisines: American

Wi-Fi: No

Alcohol: Full Bar

Attire: Casual

Takes Reservations: Yes

Outdoor Seating: No

Price Range : Below Average

People Also Viewed