Mr B's-A Bartolotta Steakhouse
18380 W Capitol Dr, Brookfield, WI 53045
Fax: (262) 790-9162
Mr. B’s – A Bartolotta Steakhouse – Brookfield
Mr B's - A Bartolotta Steakhouse - Brookfield
Parking: Lot, Private
Bike Parking: No
Wheelchair Accessible: Yes
Cuisines: Barbecue, American, Take Out, Steakhouse, Seafood
Alcohol: Full Bar
Takes Reservations: Yes
Outdoor Seating: Yes
Specialties: Private Functions, Parties
No coupons available
Never disappointed previously. Service was very friendly but our appetizer took forever. Without complaining about it, staff also felt we waited too long and brought 2 other apps for free to apologize. Of 4 people at our table, only I got the bad steak. I had the "classic" strip steak, which used to be all they had, now they have a premium steak menu as well, at a very premium price. I suppose I should have gone premium. My fork would barely go into the steak, and cutting it was very difficult. I would have sent it back but we finally got our food at 9:15 PM on an 8 PM reservation, and I did not want to wait. Everything else was top-notch, but honestly, I'm a bit iffy on whether I'll go back.
I took my parents out for dinner last week and it's to bad my mom's steak had to be sent back, my dad liked his, but as he stated later he has had better. I thought my food was pretty good and the service was excellent. At least our night wasn't a total loss we had a great time in Badger States infiniti limo.
02/14/2011Provided by Citysearch -
We went to Mr. B's from recommendation of a friend. Our first impression was it is really crowded so it must be good. Well, I had to send the 1st bone-in ribeye because I would have needed a chain saw to cut it. I know that isn't the cook's fault, sometimes you run into a bad cut of meat. The second go around I decided not to do the bone-in, I just did the regular cut. It was tender and it had a good flavor. My wife had the veal porterhouse which was good not great. Service was very good, Micheal & Ted took care of everything. It was an OK experience not as good as we expected, Milwaukee Chop House & Carnivore much better!!
12/16/2009Provided by Citysearch -
Have been here several times, and not sure why I keep giving them chances....The ribeye is horrible, my wife always gets the tenderloin which is very tender and flavorful...service is ""ok"", tables are very close together, thought it was quaint at first but annoying by the second time from hearing four other conversations when trying to have a decent meal. If you are in the Brookfield area please try Flemings, or Jakes.....definetly a ""guaranteed"" perfect steak evertime..
Bartolotta's are typically a class act. Not this night. Greeted by a young gal who said "Reservations?" And then we waited......... Not a good evening, how are you folks tonight.......? Unfriendly wait staff, dirty dishes sat on the table, steak arrived not as requested etc.Never offered coffee, food too very long to arrive between courses. Very expensive. Small rooms, dark. Alot of noise from the dining floor directly above. For the expese of eating there, there were far too many annoyances. Lake Park Bistro on the other hand...you are greeted by friendly staff, bartender friendly, wait staff perfect in every way. I have been there more times than I can count. It is always perfect. I would not return to Mr. B's.
08/17/2008Provided by Citysearch -
MY BOYFRIEND AND I WENT THERE LOOKING FOR A GOOD TASTING STEAK. WE HAD BONE-IN RIBEYE, LOBSTER TAIL AND SHRIMP COCKTAIL. THE STEAK HAD ABSOLUTELY NO FLAVOR AND THE LOBSTER (WHICH WAS OVERCOOKED) AND SHRIMP WERE JUST OK, NOT GREAT. FOR THE PRICE, WE WERE THINKING ""AW MAN THIS IS GONNA BE GOOD"" AND WE WERE SO WRONG. ONE POSITIVE IS THAT WE HAD A GOOD SERVER ""LUKE"" BUT THE SERVICE WAS WAY TOO LONG BECAUSE THEY WERE BUSY (""WHAT ARE THESE REPEAT CUSTOMERS THINKING? "" IS MY QUESTION NOW!) PRICES ARE PRETTY COMPARATIBLE TO ""RUTHS CHRIS STEAKHOUSE"" MAYBE A LITTLE LESS BUT NO WAY DOES IT EVEN COME CLOSE AT ALL. DO YOURSELF A FAVOR, IF SEARCHING OUT A GOOD STEAK DON'T GO THERE AND GET ROBBED, NOT WORTH IT!
05/30/2004Provided by Citysearch -
Every few months I get a craving for a great steak - charred and medium rare - and Mr. B's satisfies it. Try the Filet with brandy peppercorn sauce, grilled asparagus with lemon butter, and roasted rosemary potatoes. Don't get stuck in the back where there are no windows. It will greatly dinimish the experience.
12/19/2002Provided by Citysearch -
My wife and I are preferred members at Bartolottas for one reason: their food and service are consistently good. We went to Mr. Bs on 12/17/02. We ate in the bar area because a table was not available until 8, which weve done before. There were a couple large parties waiting in the bar so service was a little sluggish at first but a total of 7 different servers attended our table during our meal. The crab cakes have to be made with real crab, very good. The filet and ribeye were excellent with the rosemary potatoes very flavorful. The wine at all three restaurants is nothing to write home about, had better. And I am NOT going to mention the price because good food comes at a cost.so stop complaining about the price!!! God I hate that. Go to Ponderosa if you want a cheap steak.