Very disappointing meal! I ordered the $30 Coconut shrimp with a side of tostones,You would think for the price you'd get a decent amount of shrimp right?.WRONG! how does 7 shrimp even sound fair for the price, I asked the waiter is that a mistake? No he replies.my son salmon was so small we compared it with the ones I buy at fish market smh.and OhThey give a small rice with corn, and some hard ass vegies,But who the hell wants that! if I want rice I stay home. We went home hungry sad to say. The bread was the only thing I guess they were hoping to fill us..we did not touch rice or veggies & refused there white looking salad.isnt salad suppose look green? Lol Please take this warning and Do NOT go to sammys fish box. they will take your money and feed you.
We enjoyed another Couples night at the lobster box. Service and food is always great. There was a light crowd which was unusual for a Saturday night on City Island. Tried the seafood paella for two, it could easily feed four......
Great experience at this restaurant, parking is good and the service was better than i expected it to be
Great little shop to get a great order of fried or steamed seafood. They also have a good variety of sides. Cole Slaw, macaroni salad, fries, cakes and pies etc. good value for the price point.
This place sucks ass balls!!! Worst food I've ever had!!!!! My delivery was over a half hour late, my food was cold and my order was incomplete! When I tasted the food it came right back out!!!!!!! Mind you I was at work, no bueno! I can't believe that a place like this is still open and in this neighborhood!!! DON'T EVER EAT HERE! UNLESS YOU NEED TO LOOSE A QUICK 5 POUNDS AFTER USING THE BATHROOM!!!! I would've given it a lower rating but 1 is the lowest you can give!
It was great.... Always going in for the fried fish..... Yummy in my tummy plus have very good servicr..
Over 30 years I have gone to Sammy's Fish Box, and seen its improvement, it was more about taking friends there as a novelty then for terrific food. Today I can say everything was better than ever, and can now place you guys in the five star food and service category. The prime rib was slamming and so was my friends NY strip. YOU guys Rock!!!
Let me start off by saying I found a dead fly in my salad while I was eating from the salad. When the manager/one of the owners came in stead of being understanding and sympathetic with what happened he was rude and and some how upset at me. I wished there was a way to share the pictures I have.
The food is great! Drinks are awesome! & I really like that they are open 24hrs!...try the lobster tail!.,
I won't be back to Sammy's Fish Box. If you go, expect huge portions of over-priced, under-seasoned frozen food. It was noisy, crowded and kind of grimy. They packed us in like hogs to a trough. It was not the relaxing dining experience I was looking for. If not for our cheerful and attentive waitress I would have given Sammy's one star.While waiting in line to be seated at a cramped table we were subjected to a sleazy manager named Steve verbally abusing and curse out a waitress in front of us. It was appalling and unprofessional. Her crime was seating a lucky party of two at a four person table. Our two seater was so small they could barely fit the bread plates, relish tray, salad bowls, wine glasses, and finally entrée platters on the tiny table. The busboy didn't bring us water until we asked the waitress halfway through the meal, and even then they had to remove a bread plate here, and salad bowl there to negotiate room for the water glasses.If you enjoy paying a lot of money for bland, previously frozen seafood served in a rowdy atmosphere, then Sammy's is the place for you.