This review is LONG overdue, but well deserved. I hired Tiffany's Catering for a low key BBQ picnic style wedding at Stewart Park in Ithaca, NY. I originally contacted them about 6 months in advance -- they were quicker than most to respond, and actually listened to what I wanted and quoted it accordingly (many others tried to shove in extra costs that I didn't want). The prices were incredibly reasonable, and the options were flexible. I handled all the planning for our wedding, and asked Howard & Eric (of Tiffany's) a TON of detailed questions ahead of time, so I could really understand and plan around the big picture. They were always pleasant, patient, knowledgeable, accommodating, and quick to respond. They were even able to use all vegetarian ingredients for the side items! The only reason I hesitated going with Tiffany's is because of the large handful of negative reviews I found online. But I guess those should always be taken with a grain of salt - people are far quicker to review when they are unhappy rather than when they are satisfied. Plus some people who have never worked in the service industry have very false expectations. In the end, I'm *incredibly* happy I decided to stick with them - they arrived on time (I also rented ceremony seating from them, so they had to arrive even earlier for setup) - the bartenders were sweet people, I'm told the food was great (as the bride, I regret not having the time to really enjoy any of it), the staff were really awesome people, full of character - and the setup & teardown was so efficient, they were all cleaned up and gone before I even noticed! Would use them again for any future events, no question.
I was recently married and my fiancé and I hired Tiffany’s Catering for the reception. Our event was at a family member’s camp, which while beautiful with its scenic views and waterfront location has nothing else that is needed to throw a party for 200 people. However, our party planner from Tiffany’s was great. He came to our camp and helped us figure out all the things that we needed/wanted for our big day. Our decision to go with Tiffany’s was definitely correct, it was one stop shopping, not only did I get the menu I wanted but all the rentals I needed as well. Our reception was fantastic. I heard nothing but great reviews on how excellent the food was and how great of service people were receiving. My fiancé and I definitely noticed how happy our family and friends were throughout the reception. If you’re in need of catering services I highly recommend giving Tiffany’s Catering a call.
Tiffany's Catering Company recently did our spring wedding. We went with the "buffet number 2" option then added some appetizers and the bar. The food was spectacular, and the people raved about the appetizers all nights. The guy that was in charge, kept everything running smoothly the entire wedding keeping us on track and making sure all the food stayed fresh and warm for the entire line of guests. The bartenders were friendly, and even started knowing some of the guests and would have their drinks ready for them when they saw them walking up to the bar. You do not find that kind of customer service out of wedding bartenders often. I will recommend Tiffany's Catering to any and all of my friends and family members and will be sure to use them again.