Shelter Island Pizza

Filters
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

1. Bellazita Pizza

53 N Ferry RdShelter Island, NY 11964

(631) 749-5463
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

2. Restaurant Bella Vita Pizza

(1)

53 N Ferry RdShelter Island, NY 11964

(631) 749-5462

It's about time Shelter Island had a great pizza place! The pizza here is delicious!!!

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

3. La Capricciosa Pizza

135 3rd StGreenport, NY 11944

(631) 477-1625
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

4. Restaurant Bella Vita Pizza

53 Ferry RdSag Harbor, NY 11963

(631) 749-5462
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

5. The Brick Oven PizzaMenu

135 3rd StGreenport, NY 11944

(631) 477-1625
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

6. Emilio'sMenu

400 Main StGreenport, NY 11944

(631) 477-2828
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

7. Bella RomaMenu

(2)

265 Middle Country Rd Ste L, Coram NY, 11727Coram, NY 11727

(631) 732-3000

I regreted moving out of Coram to Selden thinking I could no longer enjoy the best pizza, in my opinion, getting delivered to my home. After explai…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

8. Cheesy Charlie's PizzeriaMenu

46455 County Road 48 # 103Southold, NY 11971

(631) 765-3400
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

9. Sausages Pizza & Pastabilities

MainMontauk, NY 11954

(631) 668-1144
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

10. Pelligrino's Pizza BarMenu

1271 Noyack RdSouthampton, NY 11968

(631) 283-9742
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

11. Little Joe Restaurant & PizzaMenu

(1)

24 Colonial Springs Rd, Wyandanch NY, 11798Wyandanch, NY 11798

(631) 643-6012

95 minutes for delivery of sub par pizza is not to be strived for. Never again. Food quality was way below average

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

12. Conca D'Oro

103 Main StSag Harbor, NY 11963

(631) 725-3167
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

13. Michelangelo Of Southold

53345 Route 25Southold, NY 11971

(631) 765-4600
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

14. Ciro's PizzaMenu

530534 Nesconset HwySmithtown, NY 11787

(631) 724-5745
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

15. Conca D'oro

MainSag Harbor, NY 11963

(631) 725-3167
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

16. Rocco's Amici Express Pizzeria

(1)

1028 Route 28A, Miller Place NY, 11764Miller Place, NY 11764

(631) 928-0100

great food, but a little bit on the expensive side

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

17. Goomba Johnnys Pizzeria

(3)

374 Mooney Pond Rd, Selden NY, 11784Selden, NY 11784

(631) 736-0722

Good food, good pizza (for what's around) that is bundled by courteous service. I have nothing bad to say about Goomba Johnny's Pizzeria, their deli…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

18. Michelangelo Pizzeria & Restaurant

(1)

11 Eastport-Manor Rd, Eastport, NY 11941Eastport, NY 11941

(631) 325-0363

With three locations to choose from you can't go wrong dining in or just grabbing a slice to go. Veal dishes to die for, fresh seafood and always wo…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

19. Pizza PlaceMenu

(1)

2123 Montauk HwyBridgehampton, NY 11932

(631) 537-7865

The Pizza Place is the perfect place for low key pizza, pasta dishes and perfect for kids. This tiny little non-descript restaurant on Montuak High…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

20. Fierro's Restaurant & PizzeriaMenu

(1)

104 Park PlEast Hampton, NY 11937

(631) 324-5751

i live on pizza i could probably set a guiness world book record for how many slices i have consumed in my life and travels i suffer i…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

21. Southampton Pizza-Deli Caterer

623 Hampton RdSouthampton, NY 11968

(631) 283-1774
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

22. P&G Pizza and Deli

20 County Road 39Southampton, NY 11968

(631) 377-3909
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection
American Pie Pizzeria, Pasta, & Gelato

23. American Pie Pizzeria, Pasta, & Gelato

(1)

2044 Montauk Hwy. (Bridgehampton Commons)Bridgehampton, NY 11932

(631) 613-6177

Incredible pizza at reasonable prices. Friendly staff, fast delivery. Their entrees are delicious and made with the freshest ingredients. I've ha…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

24. World PieMenu

(2)

2402 Montauk HwyBridgehampton, NY 11932

(631) 537-7999

Great spot for a weekend brunch, especially to bring a date. Good food, good service, and a nice location. Hope to eat there again soon.

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

25. Astro's PizzaMenu

237 Main StAmagansett, NY 11930

(631) 267-8300

From Business: Our pizza place has been family owned and operated for over 40 years with our variety of delicious pizzas and Italian Cuisine. Our restaurant serves an array of Nor…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

26. La CapanninaMenu

MONTAUK HwyWainscott, NY 11975

(631) 537-2626
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

27. La Capannina

364 Montauk HwyWainscott, NY 11975

(631) 537-2626
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection
Serafina

28. SerafinaMenu

104 N Main StEast Hampton, NY 11937

(631) 267-3500
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

29. Fresco Pizza Deli

623 Hampton RdSouthampton, NY 11968

(631) 259-2987
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

30. Michael Angelo Pizzeria

10095 Main RdMattituck, NY 11952

(631) 298-4100
Didn't find what you were looking for?
magnifying glass
We just redesigned yp.com! Do you like it?
× Not a Fan

× Thank You!

Feedback