Shelter Island Italian Restaurants

Filters
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

1. Restaurant Bella Vita Pizza

(1)

53 N Ferry RdShelter Island, NY 11964

(631) 749-5462

It's about time Shelter Island had a great pizza place! The pizza here is delicious!!!

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

2. 18 Bay RestaurantMenu

23 N Ferry RdShelter Island, NY 11964

(631) 749-0053

From Business: 18 Bay is a Chef owned and operated restaurant. We serve a four course Italian inspired Chefs menu that is a direct reflection of the local markets. Dinner begins w…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

3. D'latte Pastry Gelato Bar

218 Main StGreenport, NY 11944

(631) 477-4060
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

4. Porto Bello IncMenu

1410 Manhasset AveGreenport, NY 11944

(631) 477-1515

From Business: Porto Bello features Northern Italian Style Fare with weekly specials that venture into more Contemporary American Dishes. Signature dishes of our Dinner menu inclu…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

5. II Capuccino MadMenu

(1)

30 Madison StSag Harbor, NY 11963

(631) 725-2747

If you have deep pockets and are looking for a place to eat or take out a date, this is your place. Amazing food, amazing dessert... culinary excell…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

6. Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

(4)
(888) 254-9060

cherished this business all of the twenty years living in Florida. Both Red Lobster and Olive Garden were outstanding facilities to dine.

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

8. Tutto Il Giorno

(2)

5 Bay StSag Harbor, NY 11963

(631) 725-7009

So, in a word: GO! This restaurant was recommended to me by a friend and private chef who I shared a house with back in the early part of the 21st c…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

9. Caci North ForkMenu

56125 Route 25Southold, NY 11971

(631) 765-4383
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

10. Pagano's Little Italian Place

2850 Wells RdPeconic, NY 11958

(631) 477-6766
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

11. Cappelletti Italian GrillMenu

(2)

3284 Noyac RdSag Harbor, NY 11963

(631) 725-7800

Sadly, I agree with the prior review - which was from quite a while back. NOW - it's more on point than ever. The prices are SKY HIGH, and you nev…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

12. CittanuovaMenu

(4)

29 Newtown LnEast Hampton, NY 11937

(631) 324-6300

Cittanuova in the heart of east hampton village, a great restaurant/bar to people watch while dining with a short list of excellent food a …

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection
Nick & Toni's

13. Nick & Toni'sMenu

136 N Main StEast Hampton, NY 11937

(631) 324-3550

From Business: We're celebrating our 25th year in the Hamptons and will be commemorating our Silver Anniversary with an interior facelift! We will be closed for approximately 6 we…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

14. Sam's RestaurantMenu

(2)

36 Newtown LnEast Hampton, NY 11937

(631) 324-5900

Sam's is the real deal. No pretense. Real food for real people. The service is warm and friendly, and the restaurant has a home-like feel with th…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

15. Felices Italian Restaurant

MainAmagansett, NY 11930

(631) 267-3339
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

16. Michelangelo of Eastport

(1)

31455 Main RdCutchogue, NY 11935

(631) 298-0230

I love this place. I have for years. When my husband was alive we would go here once a week. I can never get enough. I only eat one thing but my…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

17. Nello Summertimes Hotel-Rstrnt

(1)

136 Main StSouthampton, NY 11968

(631) 287-5500

the absolute worst restaurant experience I've ever had. High prices, lousy food & awful service

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

18. Felices Italian Restaurant In

237 Main StAmagansett, NY 11930

(631) 267-8300
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

19. Mama Felicia Trattoria & Pizza

18 Jericho LnEast Hampton, NY 11937

(516) 334-1141
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

20. L I Pasta Co

48 Sag Harbor TpkeEast Hampton, NY 11937

(800) 591-2203
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

21. Villa Italian SpecialtiesMenu

(2)

7 Railroad AveEast Hampton, NY 11937

(631) 324-5110

Let me start by saying I am full Blood Italian, and my parents were born in Italy. I have spent my whole life enjoying the best italian food... so I…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

22. Monastero II Ristorante

126 N Main StEast Hampton, NY 11937

(800) 764-0387
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

23. SaracenMenu

(4)

WAINSCOTT Stone RoadWainscott, NY 11975

(631) 537-6255

i come to this place every week-end(where else would i go?!),thats the best place to go out here have fun,enjoy the food and of caurse see my fav…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

24. Touch of VeniceMenu

28350 Main RdCutchogue, NY 11935

(631) 298-5851

From Business: Established in 1989 Touch of Venice is a family owned and operated restaurant serving Long Island's North Fork for over 20 years.We have full bar, a private room fo…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection
Robert's

25. Robert'sMenu

(3)

755 Montauk HwyWater Mill, NY 11976

(631) 726-7171

nice place with good food and attentive service

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

26. Tutto Il GiornoMenu

56 Nugent StSouthampton, NY 11968

(631) 377-3611
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

27. Luigi's RestaurantMenu

(3)

1295 Boston Post RdOld Saybrook, CT 06475

(860) 388-9190

Great food, good service. Chicken Cacciatore is my FAVORITE here!

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

28. Edgewater RestaurantMenu

(3)

295 E Montauk HwyHampton Bays, NY 11946

(631) 723-2323

really excellent food!

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

29. Sant AmbroeusMenu

30 Main St Ste ASouthampton, NY 11968

(631) 283-1233
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection
Paul's Italian Restaurant

30. Paul's Italian RestaurantMenu

(1)

21 Hill StSouthampton, NY 11968

(631) 283-1861

with a great location if you're shopping in Southampton. Good pizza and other Italian food.

Add a New Collection
Oops! There was a problem saving the new custom collection.
Please try again.
Collection Name cannot be empty
Upload a Photo
(optional)

Remaining Characters: 100

Remaining Characters: 500

Cancel
Save
Didn't find what you were looking for?
magnifying glass
Helpful Reviews 
We just redesigned yp.com! Do you like it?
× Not a Fan

× Thank You!

Feedback