In mybookFood Collection (edit)
Added to your food collection.
Removed From mybook!

We took this business out of your food collection.

Papa Joes Italian Eatery

Add to mybook

This listing has been
added to mybook.

This listing has been
removed from mybook.

Business Details



in Business

Papa Joe's Italian Eatery proudly offers traditional favorites as well as their own creations. Half orders are plentiful and full orders are hearty and generous. Papa Joe's guarantees your dining pleasure and would be pleased to honor any special request whenever possible. Buon Appetito! John Bellone and Glen Tribotte, Owners and Chefs.
Social Links:
Visit Facebook Page
Do you know the hours for this business?
General Info:
Mon 11:30 am- 2:30 pm Tue- Thurs 11:30am-2:30 pm ; 4:30 pm-8:00pm Fri 11:30am-2:30 pm; 4:30 pm -9:00pm Sat 4:30pm-9:00pm Sun Catering Only. Papa Joe's Italian Eatery is an Italian Restaurant in Rochester, NY. Papa Joe's Italian Eatery is an eat-in restaurant or a take-out restaurant. Papa Joe's Italian Eatery offers drive-thru service. Papa Joe's Italian Eatery caters Italian food. Papa Joe's Italian Eatery offers pasta specialities and speciality sandwiches. Papa Joe's Italian Eatery offer chicken entrees, veal entrees and seafood entrees. Papa Joe's Italian Eatery offers homemade pasta.
Rochester Italian Restaurant; Eat-In Restaurant; Drive Thru Restaurant; Take-Out Restaurant; Italian Food Catering Services; Italian Eatery; Appetizers and Specialty Sandwiches; Soups and Salads; Chicken Entrees; Veal Entrees; Seafood Entrees; Homemade Pasta; Pasta Specialties
Payment method:
amex, discover, visa, mastercard
485 Spencerport Rd., Gates - In the CVS Plaza
Italian Restaurants, Take Out Restaurants, Caterers, Restaurants
Other Information:

Parking: Lot, Valet, Private

Wi-Fi: No

Bike Parking: Yes

Attire: Casual

Good For Groups: Yes

Good for Kids: Yes

Take Out: Yes

Cuisines: Italian, European, Continental

Alcohol: Beer, Wine

Takes Reservations: Yes

Outdoor Seating: No

Specialties: Casinos

Price Range : Average

More »

Less »


Papa Joes Italian Eatery


Review this business:Click to Rate
Share Review

Like this review? Share it on your social network to get the word out!


Walked in and was greeted by a nasty old woman. She asked me if I had reservations in a rude tone. I said yes. I was told that I need then when I called for hours. She told me I was lucky because I would not have been able to eat here without them. WOW. The I was seated and had to deal with a waitress with an attitude. The food was just ok. I will not be back

Like this review?YesFlag Abuse

Customer service is terrible. Nasty miserable hostess/greeter. We were asked do you have a reservation at 4:30PM ??? Just when the doors opened. No we said. She said then we can not accommodate you. Not a way to run a business. I do have many choices of restaurants and do not have to be treated this poorly. So my family went to another restaurant where they wanted our business.

Like this review?Yes  (1)Flag Abuse

Used to be a good place to eat with good food, and not too long of a wait. Now you have to make reservations even if you get there early. It took forever to get through their phone line. The tables are so crammed. The last three times I have come here, I have been bitterly disappointed, well no more!!! I work too hard for my money, and my wife and I used to love the food here, and it is so lackluster in flavor. Our waitresses completely ignored us, and to get a glass of wine with di...view morenner is a joke! Even the Hostess had an attitude. This place has turned into a joke! Don't waste your time!!!!!view less

Like this review?YesFlag Abuse

Never mind the food beware of the nasty old fart hostess that is rude and will run you out the door. This is how to run a good business with great food food into the ground. No I do not have a reservation but you have lots of open tables so you tell me you are full? Then you tell me If I sit down I will have to be out by 5:45PM. F U Lady.

Like this review?YesFlag Abuse

Pit bull hostess needs some customer service training and people skills. Called several times for reservations and was told no spaces open for the night in a rude tone. Went there and was told no seats and was shown the reservation list. Half the tables were open. Told some friends who all had the same experience with this Rude old Hostess and walked out. I have told friends do not bother going there. Not worth the aggravation.

Like this review?YesFlag Abuse
Granddaughter Remembers

I have grown up on Italian food all of my 6 plus decades and I can honestly say that Papa Joe's is right up there with Grandma's home cooking. The food was plentiful, just like a Sunday afternoon, gathered around Grandpa's and Grandma's formal dinning room table. Grandpa use to say if you leave the table hungry, it is your own fault. I didn't leave Papa Joe's table hungry. As a matter of fact, the full portion provided enough leftovers for two more meals!!! It would have put a gre...view moreat big smile on Grandpa's face. Papa Joe's is now one of our favorites and we will definitely be returning for another large portion of something that we know will make us groan with culinary pleasure. Along with the great food, the service was exemplary. Our greeter and server made us feel like one of the family. Thank you for a delightful experience and thank you for stirring up fond memories of times gone by.view less

Like this review?YesFlag Abuse
Great food, with great prices and serving size - a rare find!

For $11 I ordered the largest portion of lasagna I had ever seen. It tasted fantastic. They have my favorite tasting sauce in the city and I am very particular. Service is always great. The staff is very friendly and professional. They specials that they offer are quite amazing. Two people can go and eat a full meal with a glasses of wine for under $30. I have never found a better value. Order the homemade oil with garlic and spices for your bread. Most people can make three meals out...view more of one order at this place. I really don't think that we could make the food ourselves any cheaper. We certainly could never touch the quality. Another favorite is the Cannelloni. On a side note I am not a big fan of salads but I always finish my plate here. I don't know where they get their blue cheese from or if they make it themselves but it is really good. I always get creamy and crumbly blue cheese. \r
The only problem I can mention is that I think that we may have told too many people about the place. It used to be relatively empty when we would visit but now it's packed almost every night of the week. Agetina's has to be sorry they let the two chefs go that run the place because Agetina's is not the same. Well at least I have a new favorite and its right down the street. \r
If you like the place, please don't tell anybody about it. ;-)
view less

Like this review?YesFlag Abuse
Provided by Citysearch
They have it right..nearly perfect.

Last night was our first visit. Decor was very nice. Waitress and staff were excellent. Portions are unbelievably large. The bread was served warmed and delicious, everyplace should do this. Salad was great, lettuce, tomatoes, cucumber, banana peppers, black olives, chick peas, shredded carrots, and croutons with a good tasting Italian dressing. Also it was served cold and crispy,very fresh. Not one who is particularly fond of salad I cleaned my plate. I ordered an appetizer of ...view moresteamed clams for a very reasonable price. The bus staff was unbelievable, the restaurant was full, whenever I moved a dish to the side of the table it was gone. They were very mannerly and must have been trained well. I watched when customers left their tables were cleaned off and reset in a minute (I should have timed them). I ordered chicken French which was very good and plentiful with a side if linguini. The sauce was good but not the best to me. I add this because I believe that tomato sauce is very subjective. Everyone likes the taste of a different pasta sauce. I could go on about this but characters are limited here. My wife had chicken Parmesan which was fantastic along with a side of penne with a meatball. Waitress was very nice and experienced. I recommend this restaurant highly. The menu has a lot of items that I would have liked to try. I will have to go back.view less

Like this review?YesFlag Abuse
Provided by Citysearch

When ordering take-out the pickup time can be anywhere from 1/2 hour to 1 1/2 hours, depending when you call. They take 5 orders per 1/2 hour.Their food is exceptional, if you are hungry call right when they open so your wait is only 1/2 hour.

Like this review?YesFlag Abuse
Map & Directions
More About the Business
Ad Banner
Visit Website For Menus!
Send to Phone
Papa Joes Italian Eatery

485 Spencerport Rd BldgRochesterNY 14606

(585) 247-7920

Send this business listing as a text message to a mobile phone.


Your text message was sent.

To opt out at anytime, send the word STOP to YP411.

To get a help message, send the word HELP to YP411.

There was an error sending your text.

Please try again.

Terms: The recipient of this text message may incur charges depending on their wireless carrier. Not all carriers are currently supported.

Message Business

What would you like to know?



We were unable to send your message. Please try again later.

Add a Photo
Papa Joes Italian Eatery

485 Spencerport Rd BldgRochesterNY 14606

(585) 247-7920

  • Photos should be clear and in focus
  • Photos should be of the business, product or service, not an illustration or clip art
  • Photos should not be an advertisment or include contact information
Add a New Collection
Oops! There was a problem saving the new custom collection.
Please try again.
Collection Name cannot be empty
Upload a Photo

Remaining Characters: 100

Remaining Characters: 500

We just redesigned! Do you like it?
× Not a Fan

× Thank You!