VICOLO Ristorante is an excellent restaurant in a lovely, small town.
I have been a number of times and each time I am more impressed. The owner is very personable. There is a nice cooperative feeling among the servers. The owner will accomodate you and make sure that his customer's suggestions are addressed by the cook and the staff.
The combination of quantity and a relaxed atmosphere makes you feel at home. They also provide complimentary cordial drinks... Italian Grappa that will sure change the way you view grappa (excellent) and in the event that you have room for dessert... order a homemade Tiramisu - it will be the golden seal of a great dining experience.
I thank the owner for bringing an authentic Italian place to the small neighborhood of Old Tappan.
I WILL DEFINITELY BE RETURNING!