Having grown up in Middletown I've seen my fair share of pizza places pop up. Middletown Pizza is by far the best one around. The sauce is just enough with the right amount of sweetness. They don't over or under do it with the toppings and the cheese. The crust alone is very eatable (especially for those who don't like the crust usually like myself!). Their only downside is they don't deliver. As fast a Middletown is growing...I wish they'd pick up on this and then I think their place would really flourish. As far as other dishes...they've got some good greek dishes. I paricularly like their pasta carbonara too.
As we all know the pizza in DE stinks!! (as do the bagels)...Except at Middletown Pizza... The family style restaurants has enough entertainment to keep the kids happy, crayons, pac-man, jukebox and tv's, A CLEAN BATHROOM! and the nicest staff ever. Thomas, always a smile (and nice triceps too.) Their pizza, pasta "gravy" and pizza fries are a Friday night staple at my house! Check it out...the drive is worth it for YUMMY pizza! (no delivery :( )
Great place to eat. My wife and I visit 2-3 times per month. They have a great menu, great service and are friendly people. We have never been disappointed with their food.