Anthony's has been here for as long as I can remember. Their subs and pizzas are amazing. No matter which one you pick, you'll never be disappointed. I did recently want to try something new so I ordered their nachos (appetizer) for about $8. It was definitely a huge serving. I did not get jalapenos. Unfortuntely I did not like the nachos one bit. They covered them with fresh sliced parsley - which overpowered the entire meal. I tried taking the pieces out but it had already added the flavor to it. No where did it say parsley was on the nachos - if it did, I would have asked them to hold it. Very disappointing. I maybe ate four bites because the parsley was so overwhelming. Other than that, I've never had an issue. Everyone is usually friendly :)
Everyone is always friendly! Their pasta meals are big enough for two people to share and taste amazing and are not expensive (unbelievable portions). I always order their breaded mushrooms.. and unlike their competitors they don't count them out. They literally give you a gigantic container filled. Best subs in Martinsburg, hands down- no matter if its hot or cold. Only downside is no delivery. But I like less than two mins away so isn't a big deal for me.
Just finished lunch here. Saw the new review and stopped in. OMG what a lunch. These people are so friendly. Their place is spotless and there food is great. Don't miss out...Oh and the price is good also. Coming back you can be sure