Nick's is a small family owned restaurant located on the west side of town across form old bill baileys. As soon as you walk in the door the place feels very welcoming and inviting. The staff was friendly and very helpful when I asked what items sold the best there, the waitress quickly pointed out there many specials and I decided to get the super sub. Let me say you wont be disappointed if you order this it has loads of meat and toppings. I ordered a pizza to take home and was surprised how good it was as well the sauce isn't as sweet as some of the other shops in town but in my opinion that's what makes it great. I highly recommend visiting this small shop or even getting something delivered.
Showing1-29 of 29results
This has always been my favorite pizza place even after moving out of town. Bummed that the old west location shut down but the new ety road is really nice and has live music on most Saturdays. Staff is so nice and of course the pizza is delicious!! I think other reviews have had one unfortunate experience but I have eaten there so much and it has been great ninety nine percent of the time.
Do you remember when Tiberio's was downtown? Do you remember when the older couple ran the show? If you liked that than you will love the Original Tiberio's. Homemade pasta, stromboli, and salads. If the last time you tried Tiberio's was when they where downtown right before they closed i urge you to give them another shot you wont be disappointed.
Tasty pizza for a large chain store. Price was fair with pick up and coupon. Staff didn't really appear to like there job but they appeared to be young. Pizza was as i ordered it and was ready when i got there. I'll order again when i get another coupon.
Our family lived in Lancaster for 10 years, and it has always been our favorite pizza place. We now live 400 miles away, and my kids still want me to call and see if they will deliver. Now when ever we visit family, Fat Cats is a must on our list.
Pizza Hut is the family choice. They have pizza in every style tou could want. My favorite is their thin and crispy. Just can't get that kind anywhere else. My friends like the crust with cheese and so we are all happy when we go to Pizza Hut.
I used to get Massey's Pizza when I was growing up in Columbus. When I moved to Lancaster I missed it! Oh not anymore it's in Lancaster now. They have the crunchy stuff under the crust and the toppings are fresh and delicious!
Love the pizza and atmosphere of the new location on Edy rd! Grown up eating the pizza and still tastes great! Family friendly with great service! Love fat cat pizza! Other reviews don't do it justice!
Great food! The sauce is not sweet and everyone seemed friendly. The subs are really good. My faviorite was the mexican pizza but be prepared it is very spicy.
The best Pizza! We used to Drive to Buckeye Lake which is about 20 or so minutes away from Lancaster to eat at the Pizza Cottage. Thank goodness we our own now!