Chesire Village has the best pizza at a fair price. It uses the most ingredients and the workers have always been exceptionally polite and helpful. I usually have to get extra cheese at most places but not at Cheshire Village Pizza! It always has my food ready when I need it and it handled a group of 15 quickly with no problem even though I had not called ahead. My vote - Hawaiian and Mushroom/Sausage! I do it about once a month.
Ramuntos is an excellent pizza joint, probably the best in town. As someone who is a regular at many local pizza joints, I can assure you of this (local college kid =P) Ignore the one star review... Pizza joints are often run by kids, and even more often human beings.... Mistakes get made, that mistake sounds rather innocent and innocuous anyways... Give it a shot!
When you tire of cheap imitations using a variety of (cheaper) cheeses, come to Amicci's. Great taste - Great value. Amicci's delivers anywhere in the city of Keene.