Few days ago I ate at NYCP and food was awesome! But I wasn't surprised about it. Every single time I eat there food is amazing! I like going there, I like atmosphere, I like people that work there, and the most importantly I looove the food! Pizzas are top-notch! And it's so weird and funny to me when people complain about NYCP, 'cause I think that's THE best pizzeria in Hilton Head Is. And I'm talking about the food. I don't know if you can find better place with better food then New York City Pizza. I've been their customer for many years already and I've never been disappointed in their food! Hopefully, I'll be their customer for another ten years!!!
Our family was in Hilton Head on vacation. we saw New York City Pizza on our way to the Beach and stopped pn out way home. our 3 kids were starving. The service was exceptional and the Pizza might have been the best I've ever tasted. Not sure what happened to the last reviewer, but our experience could not have been better!! Will make sure we stop everytime we go to Hilton Head.
Food quality reminded me of the old Charthouse Resturants. Fish tasted like it just came off the boat. My wife had the teriyaki chicken and said she would order it again. Laid back feeling(we walked in with boardshorts and t's on). The owner came out from the kitchen to ask us how everything was. Very well done and I would rec. it to anyone for lunch or dinner.