We have been to Victoria's many times and it has ALWAYS been great. We take guests here from out of town. A word of caution; the portions are HUGE! They set a plate of pasta in front of me that I would have set on the table for my whole family--and we can EAT! The bonus is that there is no cooking at home for the next day or so. The atmosphere and service are superb.
The food is amazing and you get unlimited salad and breadsticks which are a great bonus. Sometimes if you go later in the evening there can be a bit of a wait but if you time it right then there should be no problems getting a table.
We have been to several of the Grazies while traveling in WI. All were perfect. Great food, great service, lunch menu is very nice. Their Chicken and Wild Rice Soup is my favorite! A must when in WI.