Nicky's has returned after being gone from the extensive pizza scene in Genva for a number of years. Their pizza is exceptionally good if you prefer a softer, slightly thicker crust. Not as thick as Uncle Joe's but more so than Cam's. Their sauce is very good, the toppings cover the pizza just enough. They don't overwhelm the cheese or the crust but aren't hard to find either. The service is very good. You can eat in or take out. They don't deliver but that's okay with me. Their dining area has an option of sitting next to the TV or sittign in a sun room and watch things go omn outside. The waiting area for take out is a little small but other than that I find on issues with them. The prices are a bit high but so is the quality. The only issue can be the traffic to get out is you want to go East on 5 & 20. So just go West and turn at the light. In a city that abounds with good places to get a pizza I would highly recommend trying this one.
Can be on the pricier side, but it's well worth it. One of my favorite places to order from on pizza and wings (and movie) nights. Great sauce and cheese here, pizza quality you won't find at a cookie-cutter pizza chain. I guess they serve other food but I wouldn't know... can't get past their pizza & wings!
If you like New York style pizza (can be on the greasy side) then this will be one of your top 3 favorite places to get pizza.