I am a Loyal Customer of Papa Toni's Pizza for 10 years. I hear It has been open for 26 years. If you Love Pizza like I do you know the importance of the quality and taste of a good pizza is the care that is put into it. Papa Toni's has it down! You can watch them make your pizza, so you know it is fresh. Home Style all the way. I talked to the manager to see if I could have the recipe of the sauce and he said "not today.... maybe tomorrow" haha. He's never going to give it to me, anyways this is a great place to get a really good Pizza!
Great pizza made with fresh mozzarella and fresh ingredients. I liked the busy pizza-restaurant ambiance and enjoyed the selection of beers on tap. Even though the pizza took a while to arrive, the wait wasn't too bad since I kept myself occupied with the excellent bruschetta starter. Blue Ribbon is a welcome change from the big franchises. It may be a little pricey, but is definitely worth it.
Very attentive staff. Chef came to our table to address diet restrictions. Food was as good as the home restaurants in Chicago. Looking for a combo dipped with sweet, then this is your place. As good as Taylor Street. Great selection of tap craft beers and the usual light weight imposters.