I was a fan...until today. I have been enjoying their pizza since they opened here in Durham and were beside Ben and Jerry's. Today I ordered my usual Grandma w/pepperoni and sundried tomatoes. Delivery guy arrives and when I look in the box there is NO pepperoni and lots of sundried tomatoes. I call back and advise them my pizza is incorrect. I asked that my card be refunded and the driver can pick up this pizza (I have a serious phobia about sending food back at any restaurant so I w...view moreould rather just have my money back). The person at Cinellis tells me she will let the driver know and he will call me back. I wait patiently (hungry) for the driver to return and get his pizza so I can go out and pick something up. I get a call back from I guess the manager telling me that the pizza cook checked the pizza and the driver checked the pizza and per them there is pepperoni on the pizza. This takes me aback,,,did this woman just accuse me of trying to scam them out of a pizza? I tell her I have been waiting for him to pick up the pizza and clearly I am not trying to steal their pizza. Luckily, I live less than 5 min away from the restaurant so i told her I will deliver the pizza to her and she can see exactly what is on it. When I reach Cinelli's there was no manager in sight so the poor receptionist had to hear my wrath and search for the mysterious missing pepperoni. I told her I would give her $20 if she could find even the hope of a pepperoni on this pizza. I got my money back BUT I am still pissed. I know it doesn't mean much to them but they will never get any of my business again. I would rather eat cardboard from Domino's than be accused of trying to steal a $20 pizza. and I WANT MY $3 CASH TIP I GAVE TO THE LYING DRIVER.\rview lessProvided by Citysearch
604 at West VillageAdd to mybook
- BBB Rating:
- General Info:
- Casual dinning, fine dinning
- Extra Phones:
Phone: (919) 682-3690
Primary Phone: (919) 682-3690
Phone: (919) 688-9378
- Payment method:
- amex, discover, master card, visa
- Warehouse District, Downtown Durham
604 West Morgan Featuring Cinelli's
604 West Village
604 W Morgan Italian Eatery
West Village Apartments
West Village Apts
- Apartments, Apartment Finder & Rental Service, Furnished Apartments
- Other Information:
Cuisines: Mediterranean, Italian, European, Continental
Price Range : Above Average
I joined CitySearch just to clarify the identity and quality of 604 W. Morgan. I live in the neighborhood (Warehouse District) and want nearby businesses to succeed if they're good and there seems to be a great deal of unfortunate confusion about this restaurant in reviews.
""604 W. Morgan, featuring Cinelli's"" IS a confusing concept. 604 is an upscale terrific Italian restaurant:; Cinelli's is an ok, casual pizza place. They share a site, but they have very different menus and ...view morewhen you go to one restaurant you are not aware the other one is connected unless you go out of your way to walk around a few corners and through. 604 is a lovely place, with great ambiance, wonderful waitstaff and fabulous food. The ""604 bruscetta,"" with garlicky white beans and shaved Parmesan served with broccoli rabbe is a dish I think about sometimes and crave; the pasta with wild mushrooms is earthy and satisfying; I've had lovely fresh fish; and miracle of miracles, their salads are beautifully composed and perfectly dressed, a rare event in my experience.
Some reviewers mention ""Tosca."" It was the previous tenant of the space. It served Italian red sauce food that was consistently drowning in its sauce. 604 is on another plane entirely.
To confuse things even more, Cinelli's used to be in the strip mall where Whole Foods is. It was a nice, unpretentious place with good pizza. How it got attached to 604 I don't know, but the quality is not as good as it was in its old home, but still ok.
If you want an excellent dinner in a quiet, gracious atmosphere, 604 is a great choice.view less
used 604 West Morgan Eatery as the venue for my wedding reception of 80. First off, let me say that the food was fantastic. One cannot have a reception for a bunch of foodies and come out without complaints, I can honestly say that out of the picky eaters and eloquent tastes that make up the majority of guests at all weddings. We were able to accommodate all. Secondly, the space, we had a dj, cake table, gift table and all. We ate family style and I have no complaints. The food was cou...view morerteously served, and the bartender was wonderful. We had an open bar tab up to a limit and they were very honest about the cost of the drinks. We received everything that we asked for and more. The restaurant owner (Sean) was extremely kind and honorable in all of his transactions. The event coordinator Carolyn did her best to accommodate all of my ideas, and requests, and was actively involved during the brainstorming process and during the set up on the day of the event. I can say that everything went perfectly and I had a great time. I highly recommend this restaurant as a great place to eat, and as a great place to hold events.
The ambiance of the location is beautiful and our pictures turned out great.view less
Let me begin by saying that I recently had a delicious lunch at Cinelli's (in the same room as 604 - it's basically the same place) and was very pleased. So when I saw a Groupon offer come up for 604, I purchased it immediately.\r
At dinner, for 604 (again, same room as lunch), my husband and I were greeted politely and shown to a table. It's a lovely setting, props for ambiance. We mentioned the Groupon deal and the waitress asked to see it (fine, that's typical of many Groupo...view moren offers). She then placed it in the corner of our table and told us to keep it there so she could pick it up at the end of the meal. We both thought that odd, like we were being singled out because we dared to use a coupon!\r
That aside (Pete picked up and put it back in his wallet until it was time to pay), we ordered from the pricey dinner menu, which didn't bother us with or without the coupon.\r
As an appetizer, I ordered the mozzerella plate w/ heirloom tomatoes for us to share. The waiter (a trainee) returned with a plate of mussels. We decided to keep the mussels (and paid full price) - about 1/4 of them were not opened. Taste was so - so. \r
Pete ordered the chicken parm dish for his entree, while I ordered the Lobster Cognac Sauce (scallops, crabmeat, shrimp, cream, and mussels over squid ink pasta). The food arrived in a timely manner, looked fair (not as great as it sounded).\r
Pete's chicken parm was okay. It came with a side of pasta, which was cooked properly. The disappointing factor here was the bland marinara sauce. Nothing special, nothing to remember it by.\r
My dish was quite disappointing. There literally was one scallop, sliced in half, two medium shrimp, six mussels (all opened), and the crabmeat was missing in action (not there). The cream sauce was good, but so heavy (and too much) that it overpowered the rest of the food. The pasta itself was a bit mealy, I prefer al dente.\r
One other small peeve, I drank water with my meal. I asked for a carafe to put on the table so the wait staff would not have to keep coming over to fill our glasses. The young woman waitress (who was training the young man) said that she couldn't leave her pitcher there because it was against health code. I didn't ask for a pitcher, I asked for a carafe. Nitpicky perhaps, but those little things make a difference.\r
Overall, the food was not up to par. As for the Groupon, it has its merits. We have discovered new places to dine because of it (and Living Social), and have become regulars at many of the places we found through those deals (paying full price).\r
For a much better seafood pasta, try the Blue Fin Bistro in Wake Forest.. The seafood and pasta combo there is scrumptious (loaded with seafood), also a few dollars cheaper ($19 vs $21 here), and was more of what I had hoped to get at 604.view less
Tonight my friends and I ate at Cinelli's for a friends birthday. In total there were about 16 of us, so a decent size party. To start with the waiter came around and only took one drink order at a time. He would take the order, then leave the table without speaking to anyone else and then come back maybe 5 minutes later without the drink! This went on for quite some time to the point that people started going to the bar in order to get their drinks because it was quicker to just get i...view moret yourself. (at no point was anyone offered a refill even on water without having to ask) There were a couple of people at the table who were never even offered a drink!
Next, he took our food order which was another train wreck. It seemed like he could only do one thing at a time and he didn't really care at all. The food was sub-par, and that's generous. The food is also very expensive...the bill for my husband and myself ended up being $85.
When he came with the checks, same thing...he would bring a couple at a time and then disappear without even collecting the checks that he had handed out. Two people at the table ordered dessert and he brought them their check for their dessert separately before he had even brought them their dessert! My husband ended up having to hunt the waiter down for our change, and when he finally found him the waiter pulled it out of his pocket and said he thought he gave it to him already. (I certainly wasn't going to tell him to keep the change after that experience...not to mention with gratuity tacked on he got a $14 tip just from us which he certainly did not earn)
This was the worst dining experience I have ever had. The food was just ok, the bill was way too much, and the service was god awful. I felt completely ripped off when we left, and I really don't mind paying for good food and good service, unfortunately this place offered neither. That's 4 hours of my life I will never get back....yes...4 hours is how long it took us to eat there with the waiter disappearing every 5 minutes! I would highly suggest staying away from this place unless you like paying for overpriced food and being ignored or treated like crap!view less