Posted: 2/23/2012Provided by Citysearch -
I recently visited Hyeholde for Valentine's Day dinner. The menu was limited to select few, very pricey, five course meals. My girlfriend and I both ordered the filet and agreed that it was nothing special. Comparing it to something you could order from Outback would be about right. The other courses, included in the price, were small and mediocre at best. The price certainly did not reflect the quality of the food. The service left us nothing to complain about, but certainly did not deserve any awards. Our waiter was quiet and uncaring, although a friendly woman did check in on us from time to time. The facility itself was very unique and warm, but reminded me of an old barn rather than a castle as some have said.
Overall, I would not recommend the Hyeholde. The food was ridiculously expensive, portions were small and unsatisfying, and the service was average. Two five course meals, two glasses of cheap wine, tip, and valet ended up costing just under $240.00. As someone said in a review below, I?m honestly not sure how this place stays open. I?m still scratching my head as to what I actually paid for?