Find a business

        Saved to Favorites

        (717) 609-1593Visit WebsiteMap & Directions823 Newville RdCarlisle, PA 17013Write a Review

        Menu

        Appetizers
        • Soup Of The Day
          fresh choices made daily
          $2.95
        • Baked French Onion
          $3.25
        • Tavern Stuffed Mushrooms
          tavern stuffed mushrooms with crab imperial
          $5.95
        Salads
        • Rustic Tossed
          topped with tomatoes, green peppers, cucumbers and onions served in our own sun-dried tomato and basil bowl
          $4.95
        • Crisp Caesar Salad
          topped with croutons and grated romano cheese served in our own sun-dried tomato and basil bowl
          $4.95
        • House Greek Salad
          topped with pepperocini, tomatoes, olives, green peppers, onions and feta cheese all served in our own sun-dried tomato and basil bowl
          $5.95
        Fresh Seafood
        • Broiled Haddock
          fresh, broiled with light butter. (includes a choice of two side dishes)
          $10.95
        • Rustic Crab Cakes
          in house specialty (includes a choice of two side dishes)
          $10.95
        • House Battered Shrimp
          our house battered shrimp. served with cocktail sauce (includes a choice of two side dishes)
          $10.95
        View Full Menu
        Provided by
        Partner Logo

        Reviews

        Hi there!
        Rate this business!
        What do you rate this business?First-classBetter than mostAbout what I expectedNot the worst...Disappointing
        Click to Rate
        JH
        John H.

        03/01/2023

        Overall
        Atmosphere
        Food
        Service

        Food and service is great
        The owner worked for me many years ago

        Helpful(0)Flag
        KD
        Kari D.

        08/17/2016

        Overall
        Food
        Service

        The service ruined our night! The waitress wasn't happy we didn't order expensive meals and practically pushed us out the door.

        Helpful(0)Flag
        B.M.

        04/23/2011

        Provided by DexKnows
        Overall
        Just proves not to judge a book by the cover

        it isnt the best looking on the outside, but the inside is great fine dining, food is wonderful, I try something new everytime I go there and it has now become my favorite and first choice for dining out.

        Helpful(0)Flag
        YPMobile User

        06/30/2010

        Provided by Superpages
        Overall

        The Best Delmonico's in Town!! Gorgeous environment, wheather you are on the deck or sitting beside the fireplace. AWESOME Snickers Martini's, Fresh Lobsters out of the tank, Cloth table linens. I love this place!! Very cute and reasonable priced...

        Helpful(0)Flag
        Carmen

        05/21/2010

        Provided by DexKnows
        Overall
        Good Food

        Nice quite restaurant. Food was good and service was excellent.

        Helpful(0)Flag
        NC
        new customer

        05/19/2010

        Provided by DexKnows
        Overall
        loved it

        Love the food, the atmosphere and the convenient location.

        Helpful(0)Flag
        Bill

        05/18/2010

        Provided by DexKnows
        Overall
        sales manager

        Great place for lunch and dinner. excellent food and service.

        Helpful(0)Flag
        KS
        Kendra S.

        05/18/2010

        Provided by DexKnows
        Overall
        Great food! Reaonably Priced!

        Love the scallops at the Rustic!!! Always a great meal! Good service too!!!!

        Helpful(0)Flag

        Details

        Phone: (717) 609-1593

        Address: 823 Newville Rd, Carlisle, PA 17013

        Website: http://www.rustictavern.com

        More Info

        Best in casual, fine dining in a relaxed atmosphere.

        General Info
        The Rustic Tavern, located in Carlisle, Pennsylvania is a mix a successful blend of casual atmosphere with the taste of fine dining. For lunch, the Rustic Tavern boasts a wide selection of sandwiches, salads and soup. For dinner, expect a full range of appetizers as a perfect start to a wide selection of fresh seafood, steaks, ribs and pasta. In addition the Rustic's full bar boasts a wide variety of wines and spirits. Check the Rustic's website often for updates and info on special events and live musical entertainment. Tom, Penny and the entire Petsinis family look forward to welcoming you to an unforgettable dining experience!
        Email
        Services/Products
        Lunch Menu Available, Fine Dining & Tavern Dining, Indoor & Outdoor Eating Outdoor Patio, Take Out Available, Outdoor Patio, Banquet Facility, Fresh Seafood, Steak Seafood & Pasta, Mixed Grille, Seafood & Pasta, Daily Specials, Sandwiches, Prime Steaks Chicken Pasta, Steak, Freshest Seafood, Salads.
        Brands
        Daily Specials
        Payment method
        amex, discover, visa, master card, cash, debit
        Price Range
        $$
        Languages
        Greek
        Other Link

        http://www.rustictavern.com

        Other Email

        Social Links
        Categories
        Wine Bars, Bars, Restaurants
        Other Information

        Parking: Free, Private

        Wi-Fi: No

        Attire: Casual

        Wheelchair Accessible: Yes

        Alcohol: Full Bar

        Takes Reservations: Yes

        Outdoor Seating: Yes

        Specialties: Rehearsal Dinner;Weddings;Cocktail Parties;Business Meetings;Wedding events;Private Parties;Banquets;Anniversaries;Banquets;Anniversaries;Business Meetings;Rehearsal Dinners;Anniversaries;Banquets;Cocktail Parties;Wedding Events;Business Meetings;Rehearsal Dinners;Cocktail Parties;Private Parties;Private Parties