There is something for everyone and the portions are large enough to split. My wife and I always get the California Club and the Rhuben. You won't go away hungary.
Close to downtown Arcata, Live From New York has some really great pie...not organic, yet very yummy and a nice place to sit down and have a slice.
Smugs has heavenly pizza -- the freshest of topings, the crust is wonderful, and we love that it is a locally owned business!