Bring your own butter and don't bother with the cold cuts (or deli meat, as some folks say)
They do a pretty good job with the bagels. In fact, they probably are the closest thing to a NY bagel that you can find here in Anchorage. However, they don't have real butter - only margarine. What?! How can you call yourself a New York Bagel Deli if you don't have real butter? I'm sorry, but New Yorkers DON'T put margarine on their bagels. Also, don't even bother trying the cold cuts. No self-respecting New Yorker would ever eat the processed stuff (especially the roast beef - blech!) this place puts on their sandwiches. Definitely not worthy of being called a deli. In short, it's worth going there if you're going to pick up your bagels and bring them home with you, but if you want to eat there, bring your own butter and skip the cold cuts altogether.