Richard's Coin Exchange, run by Paul Richard, is the real deal. The other guy with the "Indian Head pennies" probably had coins that really were worth 10 cents. The problem with such a niche industry like coins and antiques is that a lot of people have very different expectations for their possessions, as opposed to the real monetary value of things. Paul is a sweet old man and he is honest. His store holds a variety of coins, foreign and domestic, old and new, in good conditions. Otherwise, I don't think he'd be regularly off with his products, going to conventions all over the USA. Paul is also the most understanding man when it comes to sentimental value, because, his store makes him into a hoarder by nature. Tucked away behind a restaurant and shadowed by the large CVS in Amherst Center, Richard's Coin Exchange is a guaranteed good conversation and sweet company. If you know what you're looking for, the odds are high that it's there.