Pickerington Italian Restaurants

Filters
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection
Omezzo Restaurant & Pizzeria

1. Omezzo Restaurant & PizzeriaMenu

(9)

1755 Hill Rd NPickerington, OH 43147

(614) 866-7606

I heard about this restaurant by a friend of mine who is a former employee of Chef Z. It just took one time for me to try one of his dishes and I wa…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

2. Pizzeria New YorkMenu

(5)
BBB Rating: A+

833 Hill Rd NPickerington, OH 43147

(614) 862-4743

My family loves New York Pizziaria for the stone cooked pizza, great atmosphere, and friendly service.

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection
Taranto's Pizza Barn

3. Taranto's Pizza BarnMenu

BBB Rating: A+

601 Hill Rd NPickerington, OH 43147

(614) 837-6555
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

4. Donatos PizzeriaMenu

(1)

1214 Hill Rd NPickerington, OH 43147

(614) 759-8000

Almost every order that I've place an order something is wrong! I had an issue tonight and got blown off by jeremy the manager. I will be calling co…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

5. Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

(4)
(888) 254-9060

cherished this business all of the twenty years living in Florida. Both Red Lobster and Olive Garden were outstanding facilities to dine.

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection
Scali Ristorante & Deli

8. Scali Ristorante & DeliMenu

(32)

1903 State Route 256Reynoldsburg, OH 43068

(614) 759-7764

Me and the girls went to lunch today, and tried Scali from an recomendation from an co- work. We loved it!!! The food was great, we met the family …

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

9. Butch's Italian CafeMenu

(11)

6394 Gender RdCanal Winchester, OH 43110

(614) 834-3201

We went there with an open mind and was very happy for doing so. The food was great and the timing was perfect. Plenty of time for talking, but ne…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection
Milano's Italian Restaurant & Pub

10. Milano's Italian Restaurant & PubMenu

(8)

6916 E Broad StColumbus, OH 43213

(614) 861-1277

I've been dining at Milano's with my husband for a couple years now, as often as once a week. The staff all know us, what we eat, and treat us like…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection
Fazoli's

11. Fazoli'sMenu

6830 E Main StReynoldsburg, OH 43068

(614) 856-9750

From Business: Welcome to Fazoli's fast, fresh, Italian restaurant in Reynoldsburg, OH. Our Pasta and Sauces, Breadsticks and Salads are FRESHLY prepared throughout the day. Oven-…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

12. Johnny's Pizza and Pasta

BBB Rating: A+

5041 Chatterton RdColumbus, OH 43232

(614) 837-3476
Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

15. Lola & Guiseppe's TrattoriaMenu

(9)

100 Granville StColumbus, OH 43230

(614) 473-9931

I have been going to Lola's for a few years now and I have NEVER been disappointed!!! The food is always amazing and the atmosphere is just perfect!…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

16. Lola Fresh Italian & More

(1)

100 Granville StColumbus, OH 43230

(614) 473-9931

The food is really good and the owners are very friendly. I would have given five stars but the service is a bit slow.

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

17. Ciao Vino Italian KitchenMenu

121 Mill St #131Columbus, OH 43230

(614) 532-5470

From Business: This Italian restaurant is full of life with a state of the art brick oven for pizza and our extensive wine list. We have a lovely room for private events up to 36 …

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection
Basi Italia

18. Basi ItaliaMenu

(25)

811 Highland StColumbus, OH 43215

(614) 294-7383

wonderful people and great food makes this resturant the best italian in the city. The valet was very kind and helpful in greeting me to the establi…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

19. Minico's Italian Restaurant

(3)

992 S Sunbury RdWesterville, OH 43081

(614) 899-1100

This resturant is the best Italian food in town. Much better than Pasquales, the people are great, and even though its not on the menu ask for Fann…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection
Monte Carlo Italian Kitchen

20. Monte Carlo Italian KitchenMenu

(5)
BBB Rating: A+

610 W Schrock RdWesterville, OH 43081

(614) 890-2061

Always have a great lunch experience at Monte Carlo's!

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

21. Marcella'sMenu

(3)

615 N High StColumbus, OH 43215

(614) 223-2100

This was a fine place the atmosphere was excellent. The service was fantasic. The prices and portions were perfect!!! I cannot wait to dine again.

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection
Martini Modern Italian

27. Martini Modern ItalianMenu

(16)

445 N High StColumbus, OH 43215

(614) 224-8259

I had the best time at Martini last week....I loved our server first of all, he was professional but didnt act stuffy like other fine dining servers…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection
Pasqualone's Ristorante

28. Pasqualone's RistoranteMenu

(18)

5766 Emporium SqColumbus, OH 43231

(614) 890-2070

A friend told us it was the best Italian food in Columbus and I have to agree! Service excellent, food even better! If you are looking for a cont…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

29. Tony's Italian RistoranteMenu

(10)

16 W Beck StColumbus, OH 43215

(614) 224-8669

I have been to Tony's on several occasions and everything always has been above par. The veal melts in your mouth and the sauces leave you wanting m…

Add to mybookRemove from mybook
Added to your food collection!
Error when adding to food collection
This business was removed from the food collection

30. Due Amici RestaurantMenu

(8)
BBB Rating: A+

67 E Gay StColumbus, OH 43215

(614) 224-9373

After reading several reviews online I was hesitant to go but decided it was in my best interest to go and make my own conclusion. Boy am I glad I …

Didn't find what you were looking for?
magnifying glass
Helpful Reviews 
Omezzo Restaurant & Pizzeria
Alecia C. rated
Yummy

I heard about this restaurant by a friend of mine who is a former employee of Chef Z. It just took one time for me to try one of his dishes and I was immediately hooked wanting to come back for more. So I did just that! Regardless of the travel, almost once a week I will visit Omezzo for his Chicken and Shrimp Penne Alfredo! His Alfredo sauce is like no other!!! I always scrape my plate when I'm finished!lol And I never leave one bite of food left! He truly has a god given gift when it comes to sharing what he loves with people like me who appreciate the dedication and expertise of cooking! Definitely when it's of an Italian decent culture! His service skills are top notch and I always feel welcomed. I would recommend the whole city of Pickerington to come down and taste this delicious food! Last but not least his Tiramasu is to die for!!! I will always come back for more. Probably in another week!lol

Pizzeria New York
picktown1 rated
this is not the pizzeria i know

The pizzeria new york in pickerington ,ohio is very good at there job. Everytime i have been in there i have had nothing but great food and service. All the employes is very respect full. i have never known the pizza shop to have ever close at 6:00 or 6:45pm because i am in there at least every two days. So i dont think that you should bad mouth this nice establishment without really trying to give it a chance. pny's #1 fan

Pizzeria New York
dk4kids01 rated
war of words

it sounds to me like the bad review was written by a competitor and the glowing review was written by someone with a vested interest in the business. Neither review is correct. The place isn't the worst ever, but they are not a gift from the pizza gods either. Pickerington doesn't have great pizza selection so until adriaticos moves a location in this is the best we have but the others we have are donatos, pizza hut, pizza cottage, domino's, etc you get the idea.

We just redesigned yp.com! Do you like it?
× Not a Fan

× Thank You!

Feedback