I visit here often, at least every other week. This is the BEST pizza place I have been to. The food is EXCELLENT!! The staff is warm, friendly, and inviting. The restaurant is always clean, even the bathrooms, which is very important to me. The unfortunate review provided by the woman who said that she would never even visit the restaurant due to an unfortunate telephone conversation seems unfair. I agree that staff should be friendly on the phone, however there is a strong possibility that she may have called during a rush and that it was all hands on deck. If this happened soon after the store opened, it is a possibility that they may have been understaffed until they figured out the correct staffing rhythm for this location. I hope that she doesn't continue to deny herself a Maddio's pizza from one experience on a phone call. That would be unfortunate FOR HER. Everyone should visit the restaurant at least once. You'll see why I am hooked on this pizza. My favorite: Portobello Pesto on wheat crust. AMAZING! NO, I am not an employee. NO, I do not have any personal ties to this restaurant and NO, I am not being paid for this review. I am a real person, providing a real honest review.
I eat pizza probably more than what I should and have had pizza from many different local establishments. Uncle Maddio's has a ongoing promotion where you get a free pizza with every 10th pizza you buy, they give you a small punch card to keep track. To give you an idea, I am actually due for my fourth free pizza from Maddio's, that's more pizza than I care to admit. Regardless, every single pizza has been the same quality, excellent. You pay what you get for with the individual 9in with 3 toppings from as many fresh toppings as you would ever believe. I have also recently convinced my boss at my work to have them cater a staff meeting, the quality was just as good, and everyone loved it. It's really a shame that the other reviewer gave such a low rating to a really great place just because they had one bad experience, this happens anywhere you go. So, regardless of such a review, I will continue to enjoy my Maddio's pizza and highly recommend it to everyone, I know I've brought many people to taste their awesome pizza.
Pizza was average, overall I was disappointed. I ordered extra, extra cheese and it came with about the same amount of cheese you'd get at other pizza places normally. Also, I got the "Bye, Bye American Pie" and had the chicken, ham, pineapple on one side. Then sausage, pepperoni and hamburger on the other; with bacon all over. I tasted only one bite of bacon, one bite of sausage and only a couple of pepperoni. They seem to be a bit stingy on cheese and the more expensive meats. They were very generous with the hamburger, which I recommend NOT adding because that's all you'll taste. I will try them again one more time and I hope this was just not one of their best first pizzas.